• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Hidizs S9 Pro vs Purifi power amp + L-pad box for DUNU Arashi — worth building?

jbo3320

Member
Joined
Sep 23, 2022
Messages
9
Likes
0
Hi all,

I recently bought a DUNU Arashi (planar, 26Ω, 97 dB/mW ≈ 113 dB/Vrms per spec) and I'm considering building a small L-pad / switch box so I can drive it from my speaker power amp. Before I commit, I'd like a sanity check on the design and on whether I should expect any audible difference versus the dongle I already own.

Gear I already own
- Source A (current): Hidizs S9 Pro dongle, balanced out
- Source B (planned): Topping D90LE (XLR out, preamp mode) → VTV stereo amp with Purifi 1ET6525SA modules (input buffer jumpered to unity gain, so overall gain ≈ 12.3 dB) → L-pad box → Arashi (balanced 4-pin XLR)
- The same amp normally drives KEF R3s, so the box would switch between speakers and headphones.

Planned box (per channel, L and R identical, returns kept separate)
Code:
Purifi OUT+ ──[Rs 27Ω, 25W]──┬────────── HP +
                             │
                       [Rp 2.7Ω, 5W]
                             │
Purifi OUT− ─────────────────┴────────── HP −

XLR4: 1 = L+, 2 = L−, 3 = R+, 4 = R−
Switch: per-channel DPDT (both + and −), break-before-make
        pos A → KEF R3, pos B → L-pad → headphone
OUT− not tied to chassis or to the other channel
(Purifi datasheet says not to route OUT− to GND elsewhere)

My numbers (with Arashi at 26Ω)
- Attenuation: (2.7∥26) / (27 + 2.7∥26) ≈ −21.6 dB
- Source impedance seen by the headphone: 27∥2.7 ≈ 2.45Ω
- Load seen by the amp: ≈ 29.5Ω
- Max at headphone (D90LE full scale): 1.44 V (4V mode) / 1.78 V (5V mode) → ≈116 / 118 dB SPL
- Noise at headphone: D90LE ~1.1 µV × 4.1 and Purifi ~6.6 µV(A), then × 0.083 → ≈0.7 µV → about −10 dB SPL
- Dissipation at full-scale sine: Rs ≈ 9–14 W (hence 25W aluminum-clad), Rp ≈ 1.2 W

S9 Pro, for comparison
- Member measurements here (unloaded): 4.25 Vrms max balanced, ~105 dB SINAD, noise −122.7 dB(A)
https://www.audiosciencereview.com/.../hidizs-s9-pro-measurements-dac-dongle.34082/
- Spec is 200 mW @ 32Ω (≈2.5 V), which suggests it may be current-limited (~80 mA) under load. Not verified, since the review had no load board.
- I plan to check this myself: 27Ω dummy load + DMM, 1 kHz 0 dBFS, stepping the volume up to see where the voltage stops rising.

How I listen
With the D90LE at around −28 dB, peaks are roughly 88–90 dB SPL (~70 mV at the headphone). I also run PEQ (AutoEQ to a 5128 DF target, about −3.8 dB preamp).

Questions
1. At these listening levels, should I expect any audible difference between the S9 Pro and the Purifi + L-pad, level-matched and blind? My guess is no, apart from current headroom on loud bass-heavy peaks, but I'd like to hear from people with more experience.
2. Any flaws in the box design? In particular the OUT− handling with the Purifi modules, the switching, and whether I should add a fuse/polyfuse for protection.
3. Given that I usually sit at −28 dB on the DAC, would you change the resistor values (e.g. 47Ω/2.7Ω for a lower max-SPL ceiling)? Or keep 27/2.7 for headroom with quiet classical masters and my HE400se (~107 dB/V)?
4. Overall: is this worth building, or should I just keep using the dongle?

Thanks!
 
1. At these listening levels, should I expect any audible difference between the S9 Pro and the Purifi + L-pad, level-matched and blind? My guess is no, apart from current headroom on loud bass-heavy peaks, but I'd like to hear from people with more experience.
I once built a speaker output to headphone adapter using an l-pad, but felt it acted as a tone control depending on the l-pad's setting. This was with a Dyna SCA35 tube integrated amp which lacked headphone output. I never bothered to repeat the experiment.
 
This is plain stupid, no two ways about it.

Your headphone is as far removed from the category of headphones for which a Speaker Amp might make sense, as they come.

It's stock Prius with a huge wing levels of stupid.
Isn't it the same principle as the Hifiman headphone adapter? I was under impression that rather than buying an expensive headphone amps, if I have a power amp already, I could save some money by doing this.
 
Back
Top Bottom