• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Help me replace my Genelec 8341's for the sanity of my beloved wife

@AdrianusG

She went on to tell me about the comments some of our friends have passed which include: "they look like a blood pressure monitor" the one's you see in hospital, the one's where you sit next to it on a chair and put your arm actually into a large machine and it prints out a report for you. Other evil comments were mentioned which I won't say on here as saying those comments will upset us audio loving people. The funny thing is, they are not wrong. :D
 
Given the size of your space, unless you need the power, LSX IIs are tiny - just 155mm width, and the matching stands are pretty - but they are not going to disappear. It will have a similar look to your genelecs. The website does allow you to "see" them in your own space - presumably through uploading a photo. I'd still keep the genelecs for a rainy day or the bedroom - you could play "Je t'aime... moi non plus".
 
I guess we haven’t seen the conclusion of this drama yet.

It’s a real bummer that the found the sound he likes so much and probably has to get rid of it.

On the other hand, I’m certainly with his wife on the looks of the Genelec. I would not place one of those in our house.

That said my wife’s reaction to different loudspeakers has always been fairly unpredictable to me. She’s ended up liking looks of certain speakers I would’ve imagined she would find repulsive. And liking other speakers were a bit more traditional.

Of course, to her the best speakers are ones she would never see.
 
On the other hand, I’m certainly with his wife on the looks of the Genelec. I would not place one of those in our house.
Not my Genelecs, I would love to see your designer houses. :)

9CA8064A-8CDC-4E67-BAFE-EB93FC4BF864.png
 
Not my Genelecs, I would love to see your designer houses. :)

View attachment 422052

While I still wouldn’t personally buy a Genelec, those are about as well integrated as I guess I will see anywhere.

Since speakers and decor has become a subject and you asked, though not that I have a designer home, I’ll post a few pictures of my listening room. In renovating the room I set myself a tough task of integrating a projection based Home Theatre with surround-sound, as well as separate two channel speakers which are driven by different front end and amplification. That’s piling a lot of speakers into one room (I keep all the source and amplification equipment in a separate room), and there were some ergonomic challenges, but in the end I got what I wanted. I swap between two different floor standing loudspeakers. Here’s a glimpse of the listening and Home Theatre room from the hallway with the Thiel CS2.7 speakers visible:

IMG-3920.jpg


The design employed a professional acoustician - the ceiling bulkhead was actually designed using stretched brown felt fabric that looks like a solid ceiling, behind which acoustic material is strategically placed as well.

Closer and you can see the speakers share a room with velvet covered Home Theatre speakers (to make them more discrete against the black velvet background);

IMG-3849.webp


Inside:

IMG-3848.webp


My Joseph Audio speakers:
IMG-3862.webp


Inside:

IMG-3846.webp


Towards the seating position (my JVC projector is hidden behind the sofa - it’s on an automated lift that rises the projector up to the right height when the Home Theatre mode is activated):

IMG-1634.jpg


Night listening:

IMG-3845.webp


IMG-1806.jpg


Not to everybody’s taste, I certainly understand, but since I’m not a fan of the look of pro gear, this suits me fine.
 
Tannoy, there will be something that everyone can live with.
 
Some of those Purifi 2 ways are quite good; March Audio, Buchardt, Radiant. March has the benefit of not being very deep, though the height and width is more than a Buchardt, which is compact looking from front on.

Personally, sometimes I think people are overly hung up on how one thing may look, especially when it is an object that brings equal joy to the other person.
As long as it';s change the look but not remove having hifi speakers entirely then it's ok imo. Otherwise it's the complete opposite thing where one person only wants their way.

Also, imo, the speakers don't stand out any more than people leaving coats and bags lying around the place.

I hope you manage to find something suitable though )
 
Also, imo, the speakers don't stand out any more than people leaving coats and bags lying around the place.
My wife is unusually OK with the speakers and stereo that I chose for our living room. (The only place physically large enough to have it in this very small house.)
But, if you are unwilling to leave your outside shoes off & change to indoor shoes (we have a selection of various sizes & styles) or have your coat & bag hung up in the closet by the front door for that purpose, you are NOT coming inside.
She is the watch dog for that sort of thing & even I am obedient to it.
I am not known for conformity to rules ('m more like Smokey Yunick was to NASCAR, Trans Am & Indy racing in the late 50's through 80's:
[As with most successful racers, Yunick was a master of the grey area straddling the rules. Perhaps his most famous exploit was his #13 1966 Chevrolet Chevelle, driven by Curtis Turner. The car was so much faster than the competition during testing that they were sure that cheating was involved; some aerodynamic enhancement was strongly suspected, but the car's profile seemed to be entirely stock, as the rules required. It was eventually discovered that Yunick had lowered and modified the roof and windows and raised the production car's floor] {to lower the body}).
But there are things that she puts her foot down about and those are some of the very few.
Since her rule are very few, I find them tolerable.
 
Last edited:
I too suggested we add some 8351b's but it was lovingly vetoed.

1748708511070.png
 
It takes two to tango, if spouse is so meticulous about looks, ask if possible to make a fabric sock to cover the speaker. I've done it myself with spandex, it's very acoustically transparent when stretched...
It's not always about looks to them, it may be about how much dust, pollen, etc. it may hold. My wife has severe allergies to airborne particulates of dost, pollen, etc.
It may be an actual practical decision on their part.
 
I would simply suggest that you procure a projection TV system with an acoustically transparent screen just big enough to hide the Genelecs! You and wife would enjoy an updated larger TV screen and you could then keep your amazing Genelec 8341As - which I also happen to enjoy!
 
I actually ordered a pair of BMR's in walnut just before I bought the Genelecs. I cancelled the order before they were built in favour of the Genelecs. Shipping them to the Uk was just too risky and I was concerned about resale value over here should I not like them.....still, they are beautiful speakers with well designed crossovers with quality parts. Can't deny that.
The Philharmonic HT Towers are slim with beautiful veneer options and are a good step up from BMR Monitors on stands. And less intrusive looking. They ship overseas all the time.
 
Back
Top Bottom