• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Genelec 8351b Vertical vs Horizontal Orientation

richard12511

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Jan 23, 2020
Messages
4,511
Likes
7,129
Ran some tests today to see what the measurable differences are. The horizontal orientation controls directivity down to ~250Hz, due to the wider baffle. Below are the differences I measured. Measurement is a MMM over ~2 seat cushions and no EQ applied.

Vertical vs Horizontal.jpg


My conclusion based on this? It's pretty much the same :D.
 
Ran some tests today to see what the measurable differences are. The horizontal orientation controls directivity down to ~250Hz, due to the wider baffle. Below are the differences I measured. Measurement is a MMM over ~2 seat cushions and no EQ applied.

View attachment 117904

My conclusion based on this? It's pretty much the same :D.

The room and the location of the speakers will have an impact on this. I experimented horizontal vs vertical orientation with my 8341 in our old apartment which had very narrow ”home office room”. Unfortunately I dont have the measurements anymore but there were some visible differences between circa 200-400Hz. Side walls were very close to the speakers.

So YMMV but it is great option to have.
 
The room and the location of the speakers will have an impact on this. I experimented horizontal vs vertical orientation with my 8341 in our old apartment which had very narrow ”home office room”. Unfortunately I dont have the measurements anymore but there were some visible differences between circa 200-400Hz. Side walls were very close to the speakers.

So YMMV but it is great option to have.

I've got no sidewall reflections in this room, and high ceilings. Which did you end up liking best?
 
I have to come on here to vent. The screws that came with my speakers to attach the isopods are way too soft.

One of the screws straight up broke in half with no pressure whatsoever. I was picking up the speaker and moving the speaker a few inches back, and when I set it down(gently) the screw just broke in half. So now the broken screw is stuck permanently in the 8351b. There goes the resale value of that speaker. Two of the others screws stripped completely after 2 changes of orientation. Now because of these ****** screws, I'm stuck with a right speaker in vertical orientation and two other speakers in horizontal orientation. It looks horrible.

Any ideas to get out stripped screws? I've tried ducttape, gorilla tape, ptfe, grabbit, screw grab, and none of it has worked. The screws are just too soft. Seems dumb to have to send them back for repair for something so small, but I'm running out of options. As they are right now, I can't stand the look of the right being the only vertical orientation.
 
image_6487327 (1)-min.JPG


:mad:

The only other thing I can think is to cut the wire, but then that still leaves 3 screws stuck inside. Also, once I cut the wire, I can't use the isopods anymore, and Genelec doesn't seem to sell them separately. I've asked sweetwater and a couple other vendors and none of them sell the isopods.
 
View attachment 118438

:mad:

The only other thing I can think is to cut the wire, but then that still leaves 3 screws stuck inside. Also, once I cut the wire, I can't use the isopods anymore, and Genelec doesn't seem to sell them separately. I've asked sweetwater and a couple other vendors and none of them sell the isopods.
bummer about the broken screw. there are kits sold for extracting sheared bolts and screws. You could give something like this a try:
https://www.amazon.com/Extractor-We...coding=UTF8&psc=1&refRID=AYXRC987V2K814H4P0BS

I also found that cleaning the threads out a bit help ease fastener threading on my genelecs. Mine had some excess paint that had filled in the first few threads of a couple of the mounting holes....
 
bummer about the broken screw. there are kits sold for extracting sheared bolts and screws. You could give something like this a try:
https://www.amazon.com/Extractor-We...coding=UTF8&psc=1&refRID=AYXRC987V2K814H4P0BS

I also found that cleaning the threads out a bit help ease fastener threading on my genelecs. Mine had some excess paint that had filled in the first few threads of a couple of the mounting holes....

That's similar to the one I bought.

Grabbit Speedout Pro.

Unfortunately, it didn't work :(. I've got rubber bands coming tomorrow, but I'm really doubtful they'll work given what I've already tried.
Ouch, that really sucks. Seems like an "ask Genelec support" situation?

The only problem I've had with those screws is that some of them are way over-torqued from the factory IMO :p

Thanks. I reached out to sweetwater, but didn't think to reach out to Genelec themselves.

Just needed to vent here :). Spent 4 or 5 hours messing with it yesterday. It hit me thinking about it in bed last night that I can just switch the center and left channels(since I like the look of the center better horizontally). Then tonight, after work, I carefully unhooked all the cables for left/center, and I go to make the switch, only to discover that one of screws on the center channel is stripped too, then after I hook everything back up I gently set the center channel back on the stand, and that's when the other screw(not the stripped one)breaks in half :mad:.
 
That's similar to the one I bought.

Grabbit Speedout Pro.

Unfortunately, it didn't work :(. I've got rubber bands coming tomorrow, but I'm really doubtful they'll work given what I've already tried.


Thanks. I reached out to sweetwater, but didn't think to reach out to Genelec themselves.

Just needed to vent here :). Spent 4 or 5 hours messing with it yesterday. It hit me thinking about it in bed last night that I can just switch the center and left channels(since I like the look of the center better horizontally). Then tonight, after work, I carefully unhooked all the cables for left/center, and I go to make the switch, only to discover that one of screws on the center channel is stripped too, then after I hook everything back up I gently set the center channel back on the stand, and that's when the other screw(not the stripped one)breaks in half :mad:.[/QUOTE

I am guessing that Genelec does not clean the threads after the coating/painting process and the excess paint results in extra torque required on the bolts. not a good comb with the soft and small fasteners used for the isopods. I hope you are able to remove the broken bolt, real bummer specially at this price point.
 
Wow, the white ones really do look alot better than the black or grey finish. How long do you have to wait for a custom finish like that?
 
WTF?
 
Wow, the white ones really do look alot better than the black or grey finish. How long do you have to wait for a custom finish like that?

I waited roughly 3.5 months for my 8351Bs, about 3 months for the 8341As. Granted, this is including pandemic shipping times, so it may be shorter in normal times.
 
FWIW, you could put the vertical one in the center. At least it won't look as asymmetrical while you figure it out.

I think you can get a specialized drill bit and drill into the screw. You only need it to catch, not drill a hole. Then you can twist the screw out. Dangerous, I know. You might consider taping around the hole in case the drill slips. You might even be able to do it manually depending on how soft the screw is.

Good luck.
 
Back
Top Bottom