Hi everyone,
As i told you again, I’m using Genelec 8030C monitors, in a small treated room, mainly for mixing. I’m very happy with their clarity/imaging, but I’ve been missing some body and scale.
After listening to some larger 6.5" monitors, especially Focal Shape 65 and Kali LP-6, I noticed that they felt fuller and more “physical,” not just deeper in the sub-bass.
So I’m wondering what would make more sense:
- keep the 8030C and add a sub, probably 7050C or similar
- move to larger monitors, like Focal Shape 65, Genelec 8040B, etc.
My main question is about the 100–300 Hz region. Would 8030C + sub give a similar sense of fullness and scale, or does a larger woofer still have an advantage there?
Would be great to hear from anyone who has compared 8030C with a sub vs larger 6.5" monitors.
Thanks!
I have the 8030 for a few years now and since a few months with a sub, the Genelec F two. I use a Wiim ultra as streamer/eq and connect it via spdif to the sub. Volume control by genelec remote.
I too doubted about getting a sub or bigger monitors. Demoed both and in the end opted for a Genelec sub.
The answer to your question is a sub, but not as easy as it seems. I will explain. A sub fills in the lows and gives that extra punch. It also releaves the midwoofer of subduties, which results in an immediately noticeable upgrade in clarity. Voices and instruments are easier to seperate and tonality of instruments is closer to real life.
The drawback, in my opinion, is that you'll pay more for a Genelec sub than one from the competition and that smaller Genelec subs are really quite subtle in what they add: they are meant for a near field application and in my experience, won't impress on demos.
The benefit is that they're build like a tank. I opted for the consumer line F two, because I think it just looks better. The F two performs very well in a desk setup in a small room measuring 3 x 2,5 m.
For fun I tried it in my living room but soon noticed that the bass in a room measuring 10 by 5 meters just needs two 10 inch woofers, which my current speakers have.
So where does this leave you? I would definately recommend a sub. But only you can tell what sub response you appreciate. For demos I would recommend the Neumann kh750 as it is almost the opposite of the Genelec sub I now have. In demo I really felt the impact of it physically. It takes you on a rollercoaster ride, so to speak, and never lets go. Compare this with a Genelec sub of similar price, woofer size and/or amp power and decide which is worth it.
To give you an idea listen to this youtube demo, with and without sub.
Neumann kh750 sub, with and without
8030 with the F two sub
If you have any questions, I'll be here to answer. If you demo, you'll get all your answers at once.