• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Fosi V3 mono amp to replace defective BASH amp in HSU Subwoofer?

SineWave

Active Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2020
Messages
133
Likes
161
I need to replace the defective amp in my HSU VTF-2 mk3 subwoofer.
Thinking to get the Fosi Audio V3 mono mini amp instead of replacing the HSU with the stock BASH, or maybe some other mono amp.

Bass management will be done through my AVR.

The woofer is 4 ohms.

The stock BASH is 250W.
The Fosi is 240W.

I'm having conflicting/vague/little information on either amp if I am looking at RMS or Peak watts, as well as distortion at the rated RMS.
So I am not sure what to get.

I'd like to stick with the same amount of power (or more) that the BASH has. The BASH plays more than loud enough for me.
I'm leaning towards the Fosi. Its price is in my budget ($139).

Any suggestions?
 
I need to replace the defective amp in my HSU VTF-2 mk3 subwoofer.
Thinking to get the Fosi Audio V3 mono mini amp instead of replacing the HSU with the stock BASH, or maybe some other mono amp.

Bass management will be done through my AVR.

The woofer is 4 ohms.

The stock BASH is 250W.
The Fosi is 240W.

I'm having conflicting/vague/little information on either amp if I am looking at RMS or Peak watts, as well as distortion at the rated RMS.
So I am not sure what to get.

I'd like to stick with the same amount of power (or more) that the BASH has. The BASH plays more than loud enough for me.
I'm leaning towards the Fosi. Its price is in my budget ($139).

Any suggestions?
There is no such thing as RMS watts.

Most amplifier power ratings are determined using a 1 kHz signal. The power that a given amp produces at other frequencies can vary. In good amps, the power is pretty uniform regardless of frequency (within reason). In the absence of strict and uniform industry standards, some manufacturers may take advantage of obfuscation to promote "optimistic" ratings.

I do not have experience with the Fosi V3 Mono. However, I have taken detailed measurements of a similar (but older and less capable) amp based on the same TI TPA3255 chip: the Aiyima A07. I measured its power into 4 ohms at 100W, well below (i.e., -4 dB) the 250W the BASH amp claims to deliver.

Be aware that your subwoofer's BASH amp provides some features that the Fosi doesn't: low-pass crossover filter, phase switch, adjustable Q control. You will need to use a crossover somewhere upstream in your audio chain to provide that functionality. Is your AVR capable of that? You will also need to play with the gain settings on the Fosi to level match how your system was configured.

CAUTION: Be aware that the Fosi uses a BTL topology, which is different from how the BASH amp operates.
  • The negative output terminal on the BASH amp is ground.
  • The negative output terminal from the FOSI is not ground. It carries a mirror of the voltage on the positive terminal. If the positive terminal is at 10 Vrms the negative terminal will be at -10 Vrms.
You would have to connect the Fosi only to the driver and ensure that nothing else is connected either inside the subwoofer or downstream from it.

Unless you are knowledgeable about electricity and comfortable working with it, and have a thorough understanding of the rest of the equipment in your audio chain, this might not be a good project for you.
 
There is no such thing as RMS watts.

Most amplifier power ratings are determined using a 1 kHz signal. The power that a given amp produces at other frequencies can vary. In good amps, the power is pretty uniform regardless of frequency (within reason). In the absence of strict and uniform industry standards, some manufacturers may take advantage of obfuscation to promote "optimistic" ratings.

I do not have experience with the Fosi V3 Mono. However, I have taken detailed measurements of a similar (but older and less capable) amp based on the same TI TPA3255 chip: the Aiyima A07. I measured its power into 4 ohms at 100W, well below (i.e., -4 dB) the 250W the BASH amp claims to deliver.

Be aware that your subwoofer's BASH amp provides some features that the Fosi doesn't: low-pass crossover filter, phase switch, adjustable Q control. You will need to use a crossover somewhere upstream in your audio chain to provide that functionality. Is your AVR capable of that? You will also need to play with the gain settings on the Fosi to level match how your system was configured.

CAUTION: Be aware that the Fosi uses a BTL topology, which is different from how the BASH amp operates.
  • The negative output terminal on the BASH amp is ground.
  • The negative output terminal from the FOSI is not ground. It carries a mirror of the voltage on the positive terminal. If the positive terminal is at 10 Vrms the negative terminal will be at -10 Vrms.
You would have to connect the Fosi only to the driver and ensure that nothing else is connected either inside the subwoofer or downstream from it.

Unless you are knowledgeable about electricity and comfortable working with it, and have a thorough understanding of the rest of the equipment in your audio chain, this might not be a good project for you.
Thanks.

I mentioned that my AVR will be handling Bass Management, so lack of x-overs, leveling and such won't be an issue.

BTL won't be an issue since I will be removing the BASH from the signal. It will be:
AVR rca out >
rca-in on new amp -spk out >
+/- terminals on subwoofer driver

I did the above, after I posted, using a stored away AVR in place of the 'new amp'. I didn't push the old AVR because it is only rated at 6 ohms and my wife was already asleep in the next room. But I think it would be able to push it harder to where it would be as loud as I ever played it before.

Again, I am not sure how to compare watt powers because there are so many different measurements for each amp.
My old AVR on the back says not to use anything less than 6 ohm, but the specs mention 4 ohms dynamic power.
Below is my old AVR's amp spec. I used a single CD channel input and a single front channel output.
Would the Fosi be rated to push with about the same power? At least it would be able to handle a 4 ohm load better and not burn out my old AVR.
Rated output
(6 Ω, 1 kHz, THD0.1%)
Front : 135W + 135W
Center : 135W
Surround : 135W + 135W
Maximum Practical Output (6 Ω, EIAJ)Front : 170W + 170W
Center : 170W
Surround : 170W + 170W
Total harmonic distortion factor0.08% (at rated output)
Cross modulation distortion factor0.08% (at rated output)
Dynamic Power180W + 180W (front, 4 ohm)
 
It would work fine. You'll lose the phase switch but you can flip the output wires of the Fosi if the room correction tells you phase is inverted.

There may be a caveat in that the Hsu amplifier has bass boost that you will lose but room correction should fix it.
 
Thanks.

I mentioned that my AVR will be handling Bass Management, so lack of x-overs, leveling and such won't be an issue.

BTL won't be an issue since I will be removing the BASH from the signal. It will be:
AVR rca out >
rca-in on new amp -spk out >
+/- terminals on subwoofer driver

I did the above, after I posted, using a stored away AVR in place of the 'new amp'. I didn't push the old AVR because it is only rated at 6 ohms and my wife was already asleep in the next room. But I think it would be able to push it harder to where it would be as loud as I ever played it before.

Again, I am not sure how to compare watt powers because there are so many different measurements for each amp.
My old AVR on the back says not to use anything less than 6 ohm, but the specs mention 4 ohms dynamic power.
Below is my old AVR's amp spec. I used a single CD channel input and a single front channel output.
Would the Fosi be rated to push with about the same power? At least it would be able to handle a 4 ohm load better and not burn out my old AVR.
Rated output
(6 Ω, 1 kHz, THD0.1%)
Front : 135W + 135W
Center : 135W
Surround : 135W + 135W
Maximum Practical Output (6 Ω, EIAJ)Front : 170W + 170W
Center : 170W
Surround : 170W + 170W
Total harmonic distortion factor0.08% (at rated output)
Cross modulation distortion factor0.08% (at rated output)
Dynamic Power180W + 180W (front, 4 ohm)
I'm a bit puzzled by what you've posted and am unsure of how you intend to connect your AVR to the Fosi. I'd also like to ascertain how you're connecting the Fosi to the subwoofer.

The HSU VTF-2 mk3 subwoofer should not be driven by a speaker output from your AVR. As such, the concern about 6 ohm versus 4 ohms should be irrelevant. Does the AVR have a "sub out" or "LFE" output? If so, that's what should be used to connect to the Fosi. The AVR should connect to the Fosi by either an RCA (i.e., single ended) or XLR (balanced) cable. The signal sent from the AVR should not exceed the Fosi's input sensitivity (2 Vrms for SE or 4 Vrms for balanced).

Since we don't know what else the terminals on the subwoofer might be connected to, the Fosi should connect directly to the driver in the subwoofer, not to the terminals on the subwoofer cabinet. The driver will have a positive and a negative tab or connector. The Fosi should connect directly to them.
 
I'm a bit puzzled by what you've posted and am unsure of how you intend to connect your AVR to the Fosi. I'd also like to ascertain how you're connecting the Fosi to the subwoofer.

The HSU VTF-2 mk3 subwoofer should not be driven by a speaker output from your AVR. As such, the concern about 6 ohm versus 4 ohms should be irrelevant. Does the AVR have a "sub out" or "LFE" output? If so, that's what should be used to connect to the Fosi. The AVR should connect to the Fosi by either an RCA (i.e., single ended) or XLR (balanced) cable. The signal sent from the AVR should not exceed the Fosi's input sensitivity (2 Vrms for SE or 4 Vrms for balanced).

Since we don't know what else the terminals on the subwoofer might be connected to, the Fosi should connect directly to the driver in the subwoofer, not to the terminals on the subwoofer cabinet. The driver will have a positive and a negative tab or connector. The Fosi should connect directly to them.
Just think of it the same as if instead of connecting to a subwoofer, it would be front speakers:
AVR rca out >
rca-in on new amp -spk out >
+/- terminals on subwoofer driver Front Left Speaker

In other words:
I have 2 AVRs (called it #1AVR and #2AVR).
My #1AVR has RCA pre outs. So instead of using the #1AVR's internal amps, I can use external amps, like the fosi, or my (old) #2AVR's built in amp (via an RCA input, the CD input for example).
I completely remove the BASH amp.
I connect the 12" driver to the external amp directly by a speaker wire.

My concern with the 4/6 ohms is that the subwoofer is 4 ohm, and it is being powered by my #2AVR's amp which I'm reading on the amp to only use speakers more than 6 ohms.
When I do purchase a new amp, maybe the Fosi, I will use the sub out on the #1AVR, and have #2AVR out of the picture.

I'm only using the CD input now because I didn't want to go through the hassle of figuring out how to by-pass the bass management on the old #2AVR. If I don't by-pass it, it would have double duty on bass management. And using the CD input/full range helped me make sure I was setting everything up right (easier to test/hear) on a full range speaker. Once I knew I was hearing it sound correct on a full range speaker, I swapped it over to the subwoofer. It was also getting late at night and I did not want to keep my wife awake all night by trying to figure out the bass-management on the old AVR.

Edit:
To be clear, I'm only using the #2AVR as a temp solution until I get a new amp.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom