• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Extreme Snake Oil

I suppose so.
But in my estimation he needs chiropractor or massage table IMO.
The amount of slapping himself of the back because all these manufacturers come to him like a muse or sage, would likely give me rotor cuff issues.
I admire him for carving out his brand the way he has and I suppose that's part of it. He doesn't actually know anything about audio but over the years I've come to believe that despite all the nonsense he is a genuine enthusiast so I don't find him objectionable any more.
 
Robert Harley isn't done peddling MQA and its descendants:


A while back I came across an old review of his in stereophile where he actually disnt hear a difference between a regular CD player used as a transport and the first dedicated CD transport. Would never happen today. His ears must have gotten better with age!
 

To the reviewer the main issue with these devices isn't that they cost 30k each to do nothing useful, but that when set up together with his five-box 300k DAC he is now running out of shelf space. Granted, at 30k for the shelves he has that presents a significant additional financial challenge.

Snark aside, i thought I was beyond being shocked or surprised by audiophoolery, but somehow this managed to do both. My mind just refuses to even try and process any of the claims about these devices. I mean FFS, digital data transmission at the rates required for audio has been a trivial task for decades. My cheap consumer NAS plus my phone plus my Topping DX5 II provide performance that is indistinguishable from this stack of madness which costs close to 500k total, for three magnitudes less money!
 

To the reviewer the main issue with these devices isn't that they cost 30k each to do nothing useful, but that when set up together with his five-box 300k DAC he is now running out of shelf space. Granted, at 30k for the shelves he has that presents a significant additional financial challenge.

Snark aside, i thought I was beyond being shocked or surprised by audiophoolery, but somehow this managed to do both. My mind just refuses to even try and process any of the claims about these devices. I mean FFS, digital data transmission at the rates required for audio has been a trivial task for decades. My cheap consumer NAS plus my phone plus my Topping DX5 II provide performance that is indistinguishable from this stack of madness which costs close to 500k total, for three magnitudes less money!
Evidently there are people who are gullible yet have plenty of spare cash around for this stuff. But a fool and his money are soon parted.
 

To the reviewer the main issue with these devices isn't that they cost 30k each to do nothing useful, but that when set up together with his five-box 300k DAC he is now running out of shelf space. Granted, at 30k for the shelves he has that presents a significant additional financial challenge.

Snark aside, i thought I was beyond being shocked or surprised by audiophoolery, but somehow this managed to do both. My mind just refuses to even try and process any of the claims about these devices. I mean FFS, digital data transmission at the rates required for audio has been a trivial task for decades. My cheap consumer NAS plus my phone plus my Topping DX5 II provide performance that is indistinguishable from this stack of madness which costs close to 500k total, for three magnitudes less money!
Has to be the most ridiculous review I've ever read, and that's a high bar.

This bit was funny:

''During our conversation, Vitorino acknowledged the difficulty some people have understanding what the FLOW does.''
 
I had read "tests" of Ethernet over copper vs. fibre, but this ups that insanity by not only claiming differences between single mode and multi mode modules but between different makes of them. It's is so far beyond parody to be genuinely scary.
 
I have to say that Jay is an uniformed person. He knows nothing about audio at all and tries to be a player in the audio world. Of course thousands of idiots, I mean people will watch his videos and believe his clap trap. This is a major reason for ASR. I tried to watch his videos and lasted about 5 minutes and then I spent hours of time cleaning all the snake oil off of my system and my floor. It was a huge mess. You have been warned!! :D
 
OK... so... not exactly snake oil. Maybe better fodder for the humor thread, but not quite really funny* either.
1788821983916.png


1788821998672.png

1788822018246.png


Well... it does have a phono section. :)
 
OK... so... not exactly snake oil. Maybe better fodder for the humor thread, but not quite really funny* either.
View attachment 557148

View attachment 557149
View attachment 557150

Well... it does have a phono section. :)
Apart from the price it’s seems to have what we want ? Not that much snakeoil ? Just overpriced luxury.
 

Paul claims that his Maestro software sounds better than Roon, J-River and the like. Is this peak desperation for a snake oil salesman? Are these services measurable?
 
Such a pity Chris Brunhaver who appears to be a pretty straight guy has to be associated with him.
Keith
 
It's hard for me to get too mad at the crazy sales pitches. Is it fraud? I guess. The thing is I don't believe anyone really believes them. The people that buy these products just want to play the game because they find it fun for some reason. I don't think they are even fooled. It seems more like engaging in harmless (because no one is fooled) fantasy. Also there doesn't seem to be enough people stupid enough to buy the claims to make it economically viable based on fraud alone. Most people have got to be just playing along.
 
It's hard for me to get too mad at the crazy sales pitches. Is it fraud? I guess. The thing is I don't believe anyone really believes them. The people that buy these products just want to play the game because they find it fun for some reason. I don't think they are even fooled. It seems more like engaging in harmless (because no one is fooled) fantasy. Also there doesn't seem to be enough people stupid enough to buy the claims to make it economically viable based on fraud alone. Most people have got to be just playing along.
Pricey speaker wire often fools people on a budget here.
 
Back
Top Bottom