• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Essay on audiophilia in n+1

At no time was I required to pay anything to read the article in full. Were you?

The email opt-in pop-up box appeared for me after scrolling down a few pages into the article.
'Subscribing to the site' (i.e., agreeing to get emails from the site), is free, and easily 'cancelled' later if you don't want the emails. How is that 'entrapment', even mildly?

(FWIW, the way I discovered this article was by leafing through a physical copy of n+1 at a local book store. Which I then bought, the old-fashioned way.)
 
Really? https://www.etymonline.com/word/audiophile Says 1951 from High Fidelity magazine. Maybe @mhardy6647 would know.
Yup. The n+1 article notes a two part(!) profile of Emory Cook in The New Yorker in 1956 -- I looked it up, the word audiophile appears in it, as a word already in use:
Cook is a brash, quixotic sound engineer of forty-three, with blue eyes, close-cropped gray hair, a sturdy build, and a firm hold on thousands of devotees of high-fidelity, or hi-fi, recordings—a remarkably articulate group of zealots, who refer to themselves as audiophiles and look upon him as the grand panjandrum of their cult.
https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/1956/03/03/ear-driven
and yeah, that is paywalled.
 
HIGH FIDELITY: Design, Construction, Meas- urements-George Fletcher Cooper and others -Gernsback, 128 p., illus., paper, $I.50. In- tended for the audio man, or " audiophile ," who prefers to design, construct and experiment with his own audio systems

Found this reference to a book through JSTOR. Reference appears in: The Science News-Letter, Vol. 64, No. 17 (Oct. 24, 1953), pp. 268-270

Yes, science, measurements and audiophilia were synonymous in 1953!

Cannot find the book though.
 
Here's the google books entry

It looks like Google digitized it in 2006, but probably pulled it offline for legal reasons.

Gernsback Publications -- as in Hugo Gernsback, who published the first sci-fi magazine, Amazing Stories, in 1926
 
From a certain height, the problem becomes one of knowledge itself: Do you believe what you hear, or do you hear what you believe?
I do not think that is the correct difference. This would only make sense, if “hearing“ and “believing“ were independent in any meaningful sense, but they are not. Both are intertwined to a degree that they are practically the same thing.

The separation is between those who hear-believe and those who know that they have to doubt what they “hear“ unless a long list of controls are carefully put in place. That is what objectivist means and measurements are in many cases a way to replace this controlled listening, and they are much more reliable most of the time. But you all know that.
Most people who subscribe to objectivism will use data to narrow down their choices to the top performing units but will then use subjective criteria to make the final choice.
If audition means to listen to gear before buying, than I did not do that for ages.
I make the choice without listening, if there is subjectivity, then it is in the judgement from measurements (knowledge).
And considering the effort needed to have a meaningful audition (for speakers etc, for electronics I do not see any reason at all to do it), I do not see me changing my process.

Audition takes place afterwards, to confirm my choice and maybe to improve on the compromise (EQ etc.) that is at hand. And there is always a compromise in audio.
 
Then you are either denying historical reality -- the story of ASR's founding is evidence of that reality -- or being pedantic about the use of the words.

Yes, we all can't help having subjective feelings about audio gear. No, that doesn't make everyone subjectivist audiophiles in the historical sense, i.e., listeners who claim that differences in the sound are what determines their choice. It's them who don't factor in the subjective role of appearance and 'feel' on preference.
Subjective feelings? Not sure what that means, seems more an oxymoron to me. I try to leave emotions out of buying gear or having attachments to gear....it's gear. LOL. Was just thinking about the bikes thing, okay, maybe some feelings apply to gear, like memories and such.

As to auditioning/shopping before buying, that's not been convenient for a very long time, mostly as it's been too long a drive. OTOH nothing has arrived broken per se, after purchasing un-auditioned (but based on research), so haven't had to return things after getting a chance to hear it setup in my room.
 
HIGH FIDELITY: Design, Construction, Meas- urements-George Fletcher Cooper and others -Gernsback, 128 p., illus., paper, $I.50. In- tended for the audio man, or " audiophile ," who prefers to design, construct and experiment with his own audio systems

Found this reference to a book through JSTOR. Reference appears in: The Science News-Letter, Vol. 64, No. 17 (Oct. 24, 1953), pp. 268-270

Yes, science, measurements and audiophilia were synonymous in 1953!

Cannot find the book though.
Well then: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/BOOKSHELF-ARH/Technology/Gernsback/Gernsback-48-High-Fidelity.pdf


1789695586821.png
 
Really? https://www.etymonline.com/word/audiophile Says 1951 from High Fidelity magazine. Maybe @mhardy6647 would know.
Well... no, I don't :facepalm: but I am honored (I think!) by the shout-out, and I do know how to search worldradiohistory.com, so I am in the midst of taking a look.

The term was apparently common by at least mid-1954.
1789694647129.png

source: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1954-Jun.pdf

Audio's precursor, Audio Engineering, offered this tidbit in an editorial in 1952:
1789695002389.png

source: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1952-Apr.pdf

Oh, and this from https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1953-Sep.pdf
1789695404943.png


Here's the earliest one that turned up in the 1950s search, from a letter to the editor:
1789695638224.png

source: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1951-Dec.pdf

and this in a Stancor ad from earlier in 1951:
1789695768146.png

source: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1951-Aug.pdf

FWIW, Ads in Audio magazines from even the early 1950s list "audiophile net" prices. :rolleyes::p

A search of the 1940s issues of Audio Engineering for audiophile returned the empty set. ;)
 
I do not think that is the correct difference. This would only make sense, if “hearing“ and “believing“ were independent in any meaningful sense, but they are not. Both are intertwined to a degree that they are practically the same thing.

The separation is between those who hear-believe and those who know that they have to doubt what they “hear“ unless a long list of controls are carefully put in place. That is what objectivist means and measurements are in many cases a way to replace this controlled listening, and they are much more reliable most of the time. But you all know that.

If audition means to listen to gear before buying, than I did not do that for ages.
I make the choice without listening, if there is subjectivity, then it is in the judgement from measurements (knowledge).
And considering the effort needed to have a meaningful audition (for speakers etc, for electronics I do not see any reason at all to do it), I do not see me changing my process.

Audition takes place afterwards, to confirm my choice and maybe to improve on the compromise (EQ etc.) that is at hand. And there is always a compromise in audio.
Yeah, I think the real difference boils down to people who understand measurements are reliably (if not exhaustively in any given test) descriptive of what they hear, and that cognitive biases also affect what they hear, and everyone else who knowingly or not rejects one of those propositions.

Fwiw I've rarely been able to audition gear before buying, but also haven't been disappointed by many purchases. Knowing how to read graphs definitely helps...
 
Well... no, I don't :facepalm: but I am honored (I think!) by the shout-out, and I do know how to search worldradiohistory.com, so I am in the midst of taking a look.

The term was apparently common by at least mid-1954.
View attachment 559343
source: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1954-Jun.pdf

Audio's precursor, Audio Engineering, offered this tidbit in an editorial in 1952:
View attachment 559345
source: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1952-Apr.pdf

Oh, and this from https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1953-Sep.pdf
View attachment 559346

Here's the earliest one that turned up in the 1950s search, from a letter to the editor:
View attachment 559348
source: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1951-Dec.pdf

and this in a Stancor ad from earlier in 1951:
View attachment 559349
source: https://www.worldradiohistory.com/Archive-All-Audio/Archive-Audio/50s/Audio-1951-Aug.pdf

FWIW, Ads in Audio magazines from even the early 1950s list "audiophile net" prices. :rolleyes::p

A search of the 1940s issues of Audio Engineering for audiophile returned the empty set. ;)
You have the best knowledge of that WRH of anyone I've seen, by the way.
 
At no time was I required to pay anything to read the article in full. Were you?

The email opt-in pop-up box appeared for me after scrolling down a few pages into the article.
'Subscribing to the site' (i.e., agreeing to get emails from the site), is free, and easily 'cancelled' later if you don't want the emails. How is that 'entrapment', even mildly?

(FWIW, the way I discovered this article was by leafing through a physical copy of n+1 at a local book store. Which I then bought, the old-fashioned way.)
No.
 
At no time was I required to pay anything to read the article in full. Were you?

The email opt-in pop-up box appeared for me after scrolling down a few pages into the article.
'Subscribing to the site' (i.e., agreeing to get emails from the site), is free, and easily 'cancelled' later if you don't want the emails. How is that 'entrapment', even mildly?

(FWIW, the way I discovered this article was by leafing through a physical copy of n+1 at a local book store. Which I then bought, the old-fashioned way.)
I don't see an option to sign up without subscribing.

https://www.nplusonemag.com/subscribe/ This has priced tiers.

Edit: I can't see more than a few paragraphs without the rest of the text being blocked.
 
Last edited:
You have the best knowledge of that WRH of anyone I've seen, by the way.
Thanks, but -- it's easy if one has even a little time on one's hands.
Virtually ALL of WRH's contents are searchable!
Their search tools are pretty brute force, but I cut my teeth in the days of Dialog and dial up (literally) modems, so I view it more as an exercise than a task. ;)
 
I was talking about "La Maison de l'audiophile" which dates from the late 1970s but the term was apparently already used in "La revue du son" (founded in 1954).
 
Back
Top Bottom