• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Dumb preamp/DAC question

TSullivanM

Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2023
Messages
22
Likes
1
Hi all,

I got a qeustion about preamplification that might sound dumb but I dont know at all how this works from a technical standpoint.

Say I have an integrated amplifier and I really want to use the preamp from my integrated amplifier but it is strictly analog so I connect it do my DAC and the DAC also has a volume control/preamp. But I absolutely dont want to use that one ONLY the one in my integrated amplifier.
Many people say I should just turn the volume to 100% percent on the DAC but is that always proof that only the preamp in my integrated will be used?
What if I for the sake of argument put the volume control on my DAC at 50% do I suddenly have two preamps now!?

Can someone help me shed some light on this?
 
Some DACs have a DAC-mode (opposed to the pre-amp mode) which puts out full volume, bypassing the DAC’s internal volume control.
Else, crank the DAC volume up to 80–100% and let the integrated amp do the rest.
 
Many people say I should just turn the volume to 100% percent on the DAC but is that always proof that only the preamp in my integrated will be used?
What if I for the sake of argument put the volume control on my DAC at 50% do I suddenly have two preamps now!?
It depends on the hardware.

9/10 DACs with volume control have no physical preamp hardware inside.

Instead, they just attenuate the incoming digital signal before it is converted to analog.

On these devices, setting the volume to 100% will pass the incoming signal to the converter untouched.

Then there are a handful of (mostly very expensive) DACs on the market that have a traditional, analog preamp circuit inside.

Sometimes they have a Line out port that bypasses the preamp, alongside the Pre out port.

Nowadays, an analog preamp has few if any advantages for home Hifi systems. But they're an easy upsell for less initiated customers. The word "Discrete" is kryptonite to their wallet.
 
Last edited:
I would like to add: consider looking up how much voltage the input stage of your integrated amp is good with. And what that DAC puts out at 100%. And stay under the amps limit with the volume adjustment, if needed.

It's perfectly fine to fix the volume on the DAC and just use the one on the amp.
 
What if I for the sake of argument put the volume control on my DAC at 50% do I suddenly have two preamps now!?
Not two preamps, but you do now have two volume controls reducing the volume.


If you want to use only the analogue amp pre-amp, set the DAC volume to full and it won't make any changes (or turn of the DAC preamp mode if it has that option). The only changes will then be made by the analogue pre-amp.

I would point out though - that counter to audiophile mythology, you will generally get better volume control performance using digital volume control in the DAC (Assuming DAC noise performance is good), than the analogue volume control in the Amp. Whether the difference is audible is a different topic.
 
Without detail knowledge of how the volume controls are implemented in Your specific pre-amp and DAC, it is difficult to state what would be the optimum set up.
I suggest that You simply try it both ways to decide if You prefer one way over the other.
PS. Some people are afraid that digital volume control could go crazy and fry the rest of the system because of some random software glitch. Therefore they want to have an additional analog volume control as a safety device. Myself, I have used digital volume control for over 15 years on daily basis without ever having any problems...
 
Unless you know your integrated's input sensitivity, everything is a shot in the dark.

You'll see some of them going from nice -110dB THD+N at 1V-2V input, to -70dB THD+N , with over that voltage ,mostly H2 and H3 dominated (so inaubible, but still... )

You will get peace of mind with DAC's VC to 100% though, against glitches, etc.
 
You are connecting the DAC's output to (I assume) the AUX input on your amp, and I assume the DAC gets digital input by being connected to a USB-out from a PC or similar?

I guess also, that when playing music from your PC, you'd want the volume coming from the speakers to be at around the same level as you would if say, you plugged in a normal CD player to the amp. And you might be worried about a) maximizing sound quality (because you've read about bit-fiddling/reduction as one means of volume control and b) not overloading any analogue inputs, so as avoid possible clipping.

If that sounds like the scenario, all the above advice is fine, and yes, it depends on the actual DAC you have bought.

If it's useful to compare: my office system uses a PC and a Topping DX1 (mark1) DAC, usually driving headphones, and the DAC's volume knob is useful and at hand to control the volume of my 'phones. If I want to connect this DAC to the input of the amp+speakers in my office, then on this particular DAC, the RCA output is a fixed level, but for me that's fine as the amp I'm using has its own volume knob. The RCA/line level output from the DAC is set to match the input sensitivity of most amp inputs - this is a common arrangement so should not be problem. On the PC (win 10), I happen to favour foobar2000 as my media player, and I set it to use exclusive wasapi mode, which means all the bits in the music file should go to the DAC unchanged. I also leave the windows master volume at 100% - I hear no benefit from setting it at 90% or 50% etc and like physical knobs over sliders. Now, other DACs may well have volume controls that affect their RCA outputs, so with the DAC connected to you amp, you will have two volume control potentially in the chain (ignoring windows master volume), and by and large you can you use either to set volume levels, and whatever theoretical speculation we apply to this, you probably won't hear much difference. The downside is if the DAC can have such a big output level that it cause the amp's AUX in to clip, or overload on transients.. You can experiment and see what works fairly safely (going from less to more, rather than testing with everything maxxed!), but really set the DAC output (if it has this feature) so that the voluem at your speakers is about the same as if you'd plugged in a CD player instead.
 
My two cents, for whatever it's worth:
  • Digital volume attenuation comes with a price in resolution, although with today's 24/32-bit DACs, that penalty is practically negligible. Setting the digital volume to 100% (0 dB) and using a low-distortion analog preamp makes sense if you aren't doing any DSP in the digital domain and the preamp is transparent enough.
  • Digital volume control offers some great advantages if you like to tweak your setup. For example:
    1. An integrated volume control for a digital crossover (main / subwoofer channel separation).
    2. Dynamic loudness curves to improve low-volume listening.
IMHO: A good analog preamp (whether standalone or integrated with the power amp) paired with full-range speakers is the way to go for a pure 2.0 setup (no room correction, no subwoofers, no loudness compensation).
 
Dynamic loudness curves to improve low-volume listening
I would not have a user-level volume control without that (as opposed to gain staging between components)

But it does not necessarily require DSP, plenty of analog gear has it going back to the 70's.

..


...


...

 
I would not have a user-level volume control without that (as opposed to gain staging between components)

But it does not necessarily require DSP, plenty of analog gear has it going back to the 70's.
Yet.. not dynamic. My point was about dynamic adjustment following volume (ISO 226)
Of course manual adjustment is always an option every time one adjusts volume.
Also, treble and bass controls are not enough for such correction.
 
Hi all,

I got a qeustion about preamplification that might sound dumb but I dont know at all how this works from a technical standpoint.Many people say I should just turn the volume to 100% percent on the DAC but is that always proof that only the preamp in my integrated will be used?

On these devices, setting the volume to 100% will pass the incoming signal to the converter untouched.

Many stand-alone DAC's offer the ability to take the volume control out of the circuit and just sent the signal out at some pre-determined level, If so use that.
Otherwise without having any measurement gear to test I would avoid setting it at 100%, that might overdrive the input of the preamp and cause distortion.
Personally I would play a digital source into your DAC, set the preamps volume control to maybe midway, then turn up the DAC's volume control to a fairly loud but not insane level. Then just leave the DAC's volume there forever and control listening level with the preamp.
JMHO. ;)
 
Yet.. not dynamic. My point was about dynamic adjustment following volume (ISO 226)
Yes, I am ONLY talking about dynamic

Yamaha introduced it in the 70s, separate dial.

Apt Holman, McIntosh even Radio Shack tried.

My GFP-555 does it, pure analog as with all the above

also mostly bass-only, as Dr Toole @Floyd Toole recommends.

Many of the DSP based implementations do so as well, or can be adjusted.

Not getting into the weeds, just pointing out that DSP is NOT required to get auto-variable adjustment tied to the user volume control.
 
Old volume pots had a "loudness taper tap" just to drive the analog loudness compensation circuit...
 
Yamaha introduced it in the 70s, separate dial.
Are you referring to variable loudness?
(Yamaha R-1000, from the collection :rolleyes:)



(snipped from the Yamaha CR-1020 manual, IIRC)

If so, such a feature predates Yamaha by nearly two decades.
It was a fairly common feature on integrated amplifiers from the mid 1950s until the end of the vacuum tube era in hifi (early 1960s).

Good examples:

EICO HF-20 (pp 6L6 mono integrated amplifier) Implementation essentially identical to Yamaha's
1793841188509.png

source: https://auralhifi.com/products/vintage-eico-hf-20-integrated-tube-amplifier-monoblocks
(never had an HF-20, but I did have a single HF-52, which had very similar preamp functionality)

Sherwood S-5500 (pp 7591 stereo integrated amp, bottom left)

Default "volume" control was loudness, but the "gain" control (concentric to balance) allowed one to zero out the loudness contour, if memory serves.
This one is part of the collection, and a very fine little stereo integrated amp, but I haven't used it in quite some time and my memory of the variable loudness implementation is hazy... and I am too lazy to dig out the manual. :facepalm:

If you're not talking about variable loudness... well...

nevermind-ignore-it.gif
 
Good examples:

EICO HF-20 (pp 6L6 mono integrated amplifier) Implementation essentially identical to Yamaha's
Sweet ole school integrated! I fully believe loudness compensation should be a part of todays modern gear more in the way they were in earlier days.
Not sure how "adjustable" it should be, more often than not it will then get used and abused in less then optimum ways.
OTOH the effect on human hearing has been proven-measured many times over the decades.
I still like the idea of it being switchably implemented as part of a DRC system along the lines of Audyssey's Dynamic EQ where it's response introduction is part of known volume levels that were measured during system installation. I like it here specially now that the change in front to rear balance "we complained about for years" now has a number of customizing points that can be user set. At least these options are available on my Marantz AV20 ?
 
Yes, I am ONLY talking about dynamic

Yamaha introduced it in the 70s, separate dial.

Apt Holman, McIntosh even Radio Shack tried.

My GFP-555 does it, pure analog as with all the above

also mostly bass-only, as Dr Toole @Floyd Toole recommends.

Many of the DSP based implementations do so as well, or can be adjusted.

Not getting into the weeds, just pointing out that DSP is NOT required to get auto-variable adjustment tied to the user volume control.
Thanks for pointing that out! I love learning something new every day, especially when I get something wrong.

Does the loudness curve track with the main volume control, or is it a separate knob that applies a fixed curve across the spectrum?

Truth be told... even in the digital domain, there's no such thing as a universally 'correct' adjustment based on volume alone. Factors like room size, speaker sensitivity, and personal preference all play a role so a dedicated loudness knob makes total sense.
 
Does the loudness curve track with the main volume control, or is it a separate knob that applies a fixed curve across the spectrum?
Depends on the unit of course

Having two knobs, in effect allows for custom calibration of the "stop contouring" reference point, which I consider the bare minimum enabled tweaking.

> there's no such thing as a universally 'correct' adjustment based on volume alone

Absolutely, ideally the curve itself can be user defined, or at least switch choice of "standard" curves (see https://xkcd.com/927)

Within Schiit Mimir the "intensity" of the curve application can be adjusted, unlike Eitr 2 with the less powerful DSP, can only change the reference point

Note that varying based on upstream level adjustments is VERY rare, usually only tied to THAT device's volume control.
 
IMO, for DSP users, Dynamic Loudness needs to happen in the same processing stage as room correction filters. It would not make sense to apply precise DSP filters for room acoustics only to have a downstream preamp that undermines the correction.
For pure analog streams or 'raw digital stream' users, having variable loudness and tone controls on the preamp is definitely a must.

I see an analogy here with crossovers: traditional LC analog vs modern digital crossover integration with SW channel separation.
 
Well ad-hoc PEQ "tone controls" freely adjusted by the user, varying by album or even track

is like that, even more.

Schiit Loki / Lokius is an analog solution

But using Wiim Ultra as input hub and "preamp" is much more likely.

I HAVE to keep DRC and phase / ToA tuning as its own last stage in the workflow,

because my system is transportable, and constantly getting set up in new "rooms".

Whereas speaker building, anechoic as possible EQ, Magnitude / FR crossovers, should be stable, not need re-doing every trio, or switching from Critical Listening to Film Nights to Dance Party modes.
 
Back
Top Bottom