• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Dr. Toole Nominated [Now Appointed] for Order of Canada!

When the switch occurs, is the switch clever enough to synchronize to short gap in the music? So you don’t get “a cut” in the middle of say a drum beat? Just wondered - never had the opportunity to do such a test.
 
When the switch occurs, is the switch clever enough to synchronize to short gap in the music? So you don’t get “a cut” in the middle of say a drum beat? Just wondered - never had the opportunity to do such a test.
The listener controls when the switch occurs.
 
From years of taking such blind tests, the smaller the impairment, the shorter the delay needs to be. In the case of very small differences such as high bit rate lossy codecs, watermarks, generational loss, jitter audibility, etc., I have found that even half a second may be too long. The switching itself because an event that the brain notes and concentrates on vs what you are trying to find. Most powerful is when the switching is instant where this disturbance is not there and memory of the past event is quite fresh before and after the switch.

When I first took the blind test of speakers are Harman, I found the 3 to 4 seconds an infinity compared to what I was used to. But as you say, for speakers, the difference is usually quite large so it became a small nuisance and did not get in the way of making an assessment.
And as you know this is also the beauty of DSP corrections, the ability to instantly A/B filters.

@Floyd Toole congratulations and thank you so much for all the hard work, together with @Sean Olive and others.
The research has been invaluable to me as an enthusiastic hobbyist in this field!

Between the research done by you and others, the spinorama measurements Amir and others provide, modeling tools and acces to instant on/off DSP filtering functionality I now have acces to research, data and tools I could only dream of 20+ years ago.

Thank you for still interacting with people on ASR, I do not post much but I greatly enjoy reading through the discussions.

With highest regards,
Ype
 
What a deserved and high honor of Order of Canada for Dr. @Floyd Toole as a Member! https://www.gg.ca/en/appointments-order-canada-june-2026

"Floyd Edward Toole, C.M.
Ottawa, Ontario

Acoustics researcher Floyd Toole transformed global understanding of sound reproduction through groundbreaking work at Canada’s National Research Council. His innovative loudspeaker measurements and NRC facilities spurred Canadian loudspeaker manufacturing, and he advanced room acoustics and loudspeaker standards at Harman International. His definitive textbook continues to guide the field worldwide."
Very happy to hear this!
 
Who is Martijn Mensink's audio hero? (Mensink is the founder of Dutch & Dutch)
It is Floyd Toole.
From Dutch & Dutch's Facebook-site:

1784054550924.png
 
James Tanner (Bryston) on Floyd Toole (source: Bryston's facebook site):
Screenshot 2026-07-20 213440.jpg
 
I met Dr Toole in 1989 when I was working at the Banff School of Fine Arts as a recording engineer. My boss new Floyd and they arranged a practice presentation of the material he was presenting at the AES convention a few days later. I believe it was one of his first ones, about the the effect of directivity errors. It wasnt hard to tell the man was brilliant and his work was important and going to make a difference.
 
Back
Top Bottom