• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Do you need high end speakers for rock and heavy metal?

I wrote a follow-up piece to the original article (that was posted in the initial post of this thread) today. Below is the ingress of the article.


Could you please tell us which measurements correlate with these mentioned desirable properties:

"reproduce it all as individual elements rather than just mush"

"stays composed no matter how demanding the music is"

"dynamic capacity"

Thanks.
 
Could you please tell us which measurements correlate with these mentioned desirable properties:

"reproduce it all as individual elements rather than just mush"

"stays composed no matter how demanding the music is"

"dynamic capacity"

Thanks.
If I had to do this as a pop quiz:

1. Distortion (THD + IMD mostly)
2. This could also include doppler distortion and resonances
3. SPL capability, flat frequency response, phase alignment (probably mostly SPL)
 
I think there is a fallacy in expecting (or even wanting) to reproduce the music like it was heard in the studio, and the music quality also isn't limited by that. I know that you know this, but just to make the point: The music that end up on the record doesn't go THROUGH the studio monitors. And studio engineers with long experience can make great mixes on pretty poor monitors (as evidenced by the infamous Yamaha NS-10).

So it's perfectly viable to reproduce music at home with significantly higher quality than what was heard by the recording, mixing or mastering engineer (to some extent depending on what they have in the studio of course).
I honestly think the fallacy is on your behalf. I think you have said this several times.

You seem to be confusing mixing monitors eg NS-10 with final mastering suite speakers. An example of the important difference.

Nobody is saying that they want to hear what the mixing engineer heard when using NS10s or whatever helps him to pick out little nuances including editing errors, background sounds, etc. They are saying they want to hear what the production team heard when they finished the final mastering and in all likelihood said something like, "now that's the sonic art that I wanted to create, that's what I want to put out there for others to enjoy if they have decent equipment."

cheers
 
I listen mostly to heavy stuff. I’ve owned a bunch of older Paradigm speakers, Goldenear Triton Twos and Revel f208s and I would say that nothing has sounded better than the Revels. Especially when I listen to well recorded albums like Tool’s Laterlaus, 10,000 Days and Fear Inoculum.
 
You seem to be confusing mixing monitors eg NS-10 with final mastering suite speakers. An example of the important difference.

Nobody is saying that they want to hear what the mixing engineer heard when using NS10s or whatever helps him to pick out little nuances including editing errors, background sounds, etc. They are saying they want to hear what the production team heard when they finished the final mastering and in all likelihood said something like, "now that's the sonic art that I wanted to create, that's what I want to put out there for others to enjoy if they have decent equipment."

Fair point.

Though I think we also need the perspective that there’s a huge history of recorded music from around the world that audiophiles listen to, stretching quite far back into recording history. I would think there would be plenty of examples one could find of older recordings (80s? 70s? 60s? 50s?…) mastered on significantly less capable or accurate speakers than the better examples you might produce. So we’ve still got a circle of confusion, which in some cases can support sigberg audio’s point, which he wrote with appropriate caveats:

(It’s) viable to reproduce music at home with significantly higher quality than what was heard by the recording, mixing or mastering engineer (to some extent depending on what they have in the studio of course).
 
Your article just says Sigberg is good for rock, no explanation as to why. Can you explain?

Admittedly, I did not read through the entire thread, did use AI to summarize, not a lot of of take away.
 
TLDR for the most part. The better the speaker, the better the playback no matter the genre. If all you play back is lite "audiophile" nonsense then anything works well enough :)

I remember back in the day some tracks from jazz at the pawnshop could make virtually any system sound amazing.
 
I remember back in the day some tracks from jazz at the pawnshop could make virtually any system sound amazing.
LOL that's one of the recordings I was thinking about/referring to.
 
LOL that's one of the recordings I was thinking about/referring to.

There was a time when I used to play such audiophile recordings on my system. (I still have both jazz at the pawnshops from my ripped CD collection on my server).
It was neat to experience a certain sensation of realism.

But after a while my focus turned to making sure I had a system that sounded good/pleasing to me with as wide a variety of recordings as possible. There’s tons of albums I enjoy listening to that are hardly Steely Dan quality, and I better be able to enjoy them too.
 
There was a time when I used to play such audiophile recordings on my system. (I still have both jazz at the pawnshops from my ripped CD collection on my server).
It was neat to experience a certain sensation of realism.

But after a while my focus turned to making sure I had a system that sounded good/pleasing to me with as wide a variety of recordings as possible. There’s tons of albums I enjoy listening to that are hardly Steely Dan quality, and I better be able to enjoy them too.
Steely Dan and Rebecca Pigeon and Diana Krall also kinda were what I was thinking of. Steely Dan is well performed, but of what particularly? :) Stuff that doesn't have a lot going on should be easier to reproduce cleanly, tho....
 
How much dynamic range do metal recordings possess in the first place? C'mon.

Some do have quite a bit, but it was a bit imprecise, I was more thinking about capacity to play back dense (a lot going on in the entire frequency band) music at elevated levels.
 
I honestly think the fallacy is on your behalf. I think you have said this several times.

You seem to be confusing mixing monitors eg NS-10 with final mastering suite speakers. An example of the important difference.

Nobody is saying that they want to hear what the mixing engineer heard when using NS10s or whatever helps him to pick out little nuances including editing errors, background sounds, etc. They are saying they want to hear what the production team heard when they finished the final mastering and in all likelihood said something like, "now that's the sonic art that I wanted to create, that's what I want to put out there for others to enjoy if they have decent equipment."

cheers

What is quite often said is that they want to hear the music "as the artist intended" or "what the artist heard in the studio". But following your logic, the artist didn't necessarily hear the final master, as that is often done by a separate engineer at a separate time, so not at the same time as the recording is done. A lot of (most?) modern music isn't recorded as a live band either, so individual tracks are laid down to create the final recording.

The artist/band may or may not get to hear and critique the final master depending on the budget of the production, and very likely is NOT hearing it in the mastering studio (which may not even be in the same country), but rather gets it sent to them and hears it on whatever they have at home.

The mastering engineer himself hopefully has decent monitors of course (I am not implying that they typically use NS10). Your example picture shows very expensive Dynaudio floorstanders and JL Audio subwoofers. I think I can quite confidently say that this is NOT a typical example of what a mastering engineer has in her studio.
 
I've never measured it, so this is conjecture, but I wonder if more complex music with fairly long sustained levels of energy and which is approaching pink noise, has a faster heating effect on voice coils and magnets than simpler music.
 
Your article just says Sigberg is good for rock, no explanation as to why. Can you explain?

Admittedly, I did not read through the entire thread, did use AI to summarize, not a lot of of take away.

Can you please clarify if you are referring to the article in the original post of this thread, or the one I most recently posted?

The first article (from the original post) is very short, and for that piece I guess it's fair critique. The point of the article wasn't really to explain how it works or why to a great extent, but rather point out that really good speakers should be able to play rock and metal well too, they're not reserved for "hifi music" or classical. There's no inherent conflict between being able to play loud and being able to play well.

With regards to the "why", I guess the first article only points out dynamic range/capacity as well as neutral / balanced tonality. Many high end speakers have neither.

The second article (linked below for your convenience) I think goes a bit further into explaining why, feel free to post follow-up questions if it still leaves you unsatisfied. But the gist of it is tonal balance, low distortion / high capacity, and building something that actually works in real rooms with regards to dispersion and tonality, and is able to provide the more elusive qualities of soundstage, imaging and separation. This is true of all music of course, but rock/metal is quite a bit more difficult to get to "that sounds good" than a well recorded lone singer with an acoustical guitar at moderate levels.

And a repeated disclaimer (as I wrote in the original post as well), these articles are of course on our website and written to build interest in our speakers, which is why it is posted in the industry forum. But I still think it's an interesting discussion in a more general sense as well.

The second article:
 
Could you please tell us which measurements correlate with these mentioned desirable properties:

"reproduce it all as individual elements rather than just mush"

I am honestly not sure. At lower levels it's the same qualities that gives good soundstage/imaging/immersiveness. To my knowledge we can't currently reliably see how well a speaker does this through measurements. There are several long threads on the topic here on ASR (here is one). A combination of good (even) dispersion and a point source seems to help. At higher levels, distortion and probably thermal compression will also play a part.

"stays composed no matter how demanding the music is"

Here I would suggest dynamic capacity in combination with even dispersion so that the elevated room reflections aren't in conflict with the direct sound.

"dynamic capacity"

Being able to play loud and handle transients/peaks without distorting and/or compressing.


You are very welcome.
 
I've never measured it, so this is conjecture, but I wonder if more complex music with fairly long sustained levels of energy and which is approaching pink noise, has a faster heating effect on voice coils and magnets than simpler music.
But you can confirm these speculations relatively quickly through measurements, or simply say: Yes, that's right - provided that the volume level is high.
 
Are there any recommended speakers to go listen to for rock/metal with a budget around 1500-2000$?
Using Dali Zensor 5 atm, so maybe the new Sonik 7 or the Opticons 6 would be an upgrade. Or maybe I can listen to some KEF Q11 meta somewhere
 
What is quite often said is that they want to hear the music "as the artist intended" or "what the artist heard in the studio". But following your logic, the artist didn't necessarily hear the final master, as that is often done by a separate engineer at a separate time, so not at the same time as the recording is done. A lot of (most?) modern music isn't recorded as a live band either, so individual tracks are laid down to create the final recording.

The artist/band may or may not get to hear and critique the final master depending on the budget of the production, and very likely is NOT hearing it in the mastering studio (which may not even be in the same country), but rather gets it sent to them and hears it on whatever they have at home.
You now suddenly move the goalposts, significantly. I wasn't asserting that "the artist's intent" is what we hear at home. But neither were you. To wit:-
I think there is a fallacy in expecting (or even wanting) to reproduce the music like it was heard in the studio, ...
And like I already said, there is indeed an appropriate sonic creation, first heard in the studio, that it is worthwhile to have at home.

The mastering engineer himself hopefully has decent monitors of course (I am not implying that they typically use NS10). Your example picture shows very expensive Dynaudio floorstanders and JL Audio subwoofers. I think I can quite confidently say that this is NOT a typical example of what a mastering engineer has in her studio.
I actually provided two example photos of mastering suites, both pretty well known figures in the industry.

And now to your final, confident, assertion that I am showing exceptions that are atypical. I don't think you are making these confident assertions while on familiar terrain. It is very much the rule that decent sound production studios have mastering suites that feature loudspeakers that are either demonstrably excellent or sufficiently expensive that the sound engineer certainly hoped and expected them to be outstanding. I live in a fairly mid-tier city of 1.5 million and have personally toured four sound mastering studios here, and without exception their final mastering suites featured very high-grade speakers indeed (details escape me, it was many moons ago).
 
You now suddenly move the goalposts, significantly. I wasn't asserting that "the artist's intent" is what we hear at home. But neither were you. To wit:-

And like I already said, there is indeed an appropriate sonic creation, first heard in the studio, that it is worthwhile to have at home.

I will concede that "in the studio" is imprecise, since there may be up to three different studio contexts or situations, potentially in different physical studios. Recording, mixing and mastering. What any given consumer means when they say "what they heard in the studio" is of course difficult to know. I suspect many are not super clear on how that process works, so they picture the artist and/or engineer in the studio listening to the track. If we keep the artist out of it, we can agree that the final mastering process is what makes sense to talk about, so we are in agreement here.

I actually provided two example photos of mastering suites, both pretty well known figures in the industry.

Well known figures in the industry will typically not be good examples, as we can reasonably assume that they have way higher-end gear than a run of the mill mastering engineer, who charges 50-100USD to master a track.

And now to your final, confident, assertion that I am showing exceptions that are atypical. I don't think you are making these confident assertions while on familiar terrain. It is very much the rule that decent sound production studios have mastering suites that feature loudspeakers that are either demonstrably excellent or sufficiently expensive that the sound engineer certainly hoped and expected them to be outstanding. I live in a fairly mid-tier city of 1.5 million and have personally toured four sound mastering studios here, and without exception their final mastering suites featured very high-grade speakers indeed (details escape me, it was many moons ago).

"decent sound production studios" - now it is you who are moving the goalpost by filtering the studios.

There are certainly mastering studios out there with great monitors. The opposite can also be readily found. Some have high-end stuff like for instance the Dutch&Dutch 8C, others aren't in any position to purchase such expensive gear.

Either way the point in the article was never "all mastering studios sound horrible", but rather that the sound heard by the sound engineer isn't necessarily the ceiling of achievable sound quality.
 
Back
Top Bottom