It is difficult to examine bass decay because you need to look at multiple graphs to get a good idea of what is going on. I will take graph 1 as an example, since it is most obviously Dirac ART. There is no point telling you that it is "L+R Oct 5" since the name is so unhelpful.
View attachment 563060
We will start by looking at the frequency response because it provides important context for the graphs we will view next. We see that the bass is commendably flat up to almost 200Hz.
View attachment 563059
Now we look at the waterfall. Here, I have extended the time window to 1000ms, and selected the "Normalise to peak at every frequency" option. The reason you "normalise to peak" is because all peaks will ring for longer, and if you leave it as-is, you will get a misleading view of the decay. Also note that I have expanded the y-axis so that you can see the entire measured spectrum.
There are a few things to see here. First, look at the high frequency decay. Notice how it drops down fairly smoothly before it hits the noise floor. You can see some tones (drops down and then forms a straight line that looks like a sheet) between 200-300Hz and also at 1kHz. That will be extraneous noise in your room producing those tones. Keep these tones in mind for the next graph.
Now look at the bass decay. Notice how lumpy it is. There are a few reasons why:
1. the period is long (50Hz takes (1000/50) 20ms to reproduce), so reflections are already arriving at the microphone before the speaker has finished producing the signal. Those reflections produce the lumpy response.
2. Noise floor typically rises at the bass region, in the same area where the speaker's frequency response is falling. However we know the latter not to be the case since we have examined the FR graph, so the only question is whether we are looking at room noise and not bass decay.
It can be incredibly difficult to tell the difference, especially since you have only taken a single 256k sweep. To properly tell, you need to suppress the noise floor as much as possible. Take multiple 1M sweeps then Vector Average them. This can push the noise floor down by as much as 90-100dB.
If you want, you can use the RT60 Decay view to get a better appreciation of the shape of the time slice.
View attachment 563061
Now we look at the spectrogram. Again, I have selected the "Normalise to peak at every frequency" option. The first thing we see is that decay is not uniform across the spectrum. Your bass is much drier than everything above 200Hz. Indeed your room looks very "live". So you would probably benefit from some room treatment above 200Hz.
The next thing to see are all the wisps between 200-300Hz, as well as that tone at 1kHz. Cross reference this to the waterfall where I showed you those tones. That is room noise.
Now we come to that huge spike in "decay" below 30Hz. Cross reference this to the frequency response (first graph), and you will see that your FR drops below 23Hz or so. Then examine the waterfall, and you will see that REW's "Normalise to peak" option has boosted room noise, which is producing that huge decay peak. So we ignore it.
The question is - what is producing all that "decay" between 40-50Hz? See my previous point about signal-noise.
Anyway, your statement:
... is incorrect. We CAN measure ART improvements in the time domain. You just have to take the proper measurement.