• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Defining High-Res Audio ...

Killing the interaction between floor and ceiling in ur listen room will have a much more dramatic result on ur listening expirance than going from 16/44.1 to 24/96 .. Etc etc

The same for diffusing your rear wall, certainly in small the medium size rooms anyhow.
To me 16/44.1 is hi Rez or at least Rez enough but that irrelevant as we all want the mastered Rez so if it was set down in 16/44.1 as some stuff was then that's ok.. If it was mastered 24/96 then might as well not mess with it.
 
Now a question for you guys right here: Is CD high-res or not?

Done right it is certainly acceptable to me. While not rare, it isn't always the case.

For the sake of permitting some labeling arguments, the widely used term "lossless" comes to mind. If it is lossless how can it not be of high resolution?

I'll have to download one of Mario's Truthful CD's and take a look. The full rate versions are very good.
 
Mario's music recordings are 24/96 ...HRA.

Mario's downloads are available in 4 flavors, including 16/44.1

I only took the 96/24 flac version.

The download code is no longer valid.

So...

I converted (in Audacity) the 24/96 to 16/44.1 with shaped dither, inverted the converted track and combined it with the original to get the "difference", and this is the spectrum of the difference track of my amateur conversion of Claire De Lune from hi-rez to CD:

upload_2016-9-3_18-9-32.png
 
Last edited:
Playing back the difference track:

My calibration volume (for 70dBC at the listening position with -20dbFs pink noise signal) was 53 on the preamp.

Turning the preamp up to 151 (wide open) and playing the differrence signal, it can be seen in the room by the microphone:

upload_2016-9-3_18-20-17.png


Turning the volume back down to 53 (normal) - the little rise there at 20kHz is the same whether this signal is playing or not --- ambient or recording system noise is all that is seen:

upload_2016-9-3_18-21-46.png


Being a deaf old fart I din hear nuffin.

Playing the 96/24 and 16/44.1 tracks and swapping silently and unobtruseively back and forth, I din hear nuffin change, either.

Your mileage may vary. If it does, show me your measurements.
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
I went the Flac route as well...High-res Audio (HRA) @ 96/24. That was the max resolution, there was no 705.6 kHz/128-bit. :)

Anything less than 88/20 and I can feel my ears buzzing and my membranes dilapidated...like a disillusion diluting in a mirror. :)

I take my high-res audio music very seriously...my ears do. :D

On a magical mystery note I like Mario's music recordings...their sound quality. What I'm hearing is what the musicians are playing.
Mario told us several times already; transparency of the captured moment from his transparent recording technique.
 
snip snip snip........

Now a question for you guys right here: Is CD high-res or not?
And this: Is vinyl and tape closer to the Master than digital CD?
And finally: What is the highest fidelity in music reproduction @ home from our sound systems?

Don't rush, take all your precious time to answer the three questions correctly. It's not a test, it's a real exam that will help determine your next direction in your audio life. Of course I am serious.

CD well done is higher res than almost any non-digital recording method. Actually as far as I know more than ANY non-digital method of recording.

Is vinyl and tape closer to the master than digital CD. I have written before about comparing reel tape, CD and LP. LP was always the odd man out. Always very obviously different. LP is not close to the master. Reel tape isn't closer than CD, though it can come close at its very finest.

So CD beats any analog format. If you go to 44.1/24 there is no question at all. So what is the highest fidelity at Home. 48/24 might be a touch better. If you simply want to be fully beyond the pale, then 96/24. Digital in one form or another is the highest fidelity.

 
High fidelity is not necessarily high resolute rendition of music emotional acuity. ...Digital PCM/DSD and lossless HR audio files. ...MQA, Pono, ...tra-la-la.

Open-reels are better. IMO
 
I love fishing, and I have reel experience too. ...Presence, ambiance, atmosphere, space and substance/consistency.

There is more there...more thickness to the instruments, to the music with open-reel-tapes.
 
I love fishing, and I have reel experience too. ...Presence, ambiance, atmosphere, space and substance/consistency.

There is more there...more thickness to the instruments, to the music with open-reel-tapes.
But the smell of fish ruins it for me..
 
I love fishing, and I have reel experience too.

can be a lonely sport tho, just me snapping pictures along the way ...
nicer with company ...
 
Last edited:
High fidelity is not necessarily high resolute rendition of music emotional acuity. ...Digital PCM/DSD and lossless HR audio files. ...MQA, Pono, ...tra-la-la.

Open-reels are better. IMO


I can understand your preference for open reel. It adds noise and lots of new odd harmonics and intermodulations that were not in the mic feed, and can help plain old stereo sound "better". Some folks just don't get it that stereo is not some sort of holy grail and that amplifying a signal perfectly, in the stereo format does not mean the best "sound". Fidelity and preference are two different things. The audio industry simply does not want to turn loose master quality recordings, they are afraid they will lose sales....they are so entrenched in sucking their artists dry and recycling old music the major labels simply will not let loose master quality, and they insist on compressing everything to hell. The industry sucks and the artists that allow their work to be compressed suck too. It would be like me painting a beautiful picture and then digitizing it and then adding dither to blur it out so it was not as good as when I created it, its what they do and its what the artists allow them to do. They intentionally feed the masses defective product. period. I have no respect for the "industry". And, by the way they compress and release dulled down dynamic music, they have no respect for me either....I get it.
 
This is a world of consumption we live in, a world of mass duplication...music and films.
Digital is perfect, hi-res audio files are perfect, UHD Blu-ray movies are perfect, hi-def movie streaming is perfect.
Digital downloading is the companion of perfection.

But when it comes to a better world, the one reel world where sound matters, where we are closer to the music played by the musicians, my best experience was from open-reel tapes played on a R-2-R tape deck. And with all the inconvenience, all the flaws, all the technical inferiority, ...it is an imperfect source and medium but still communicating a closer musical experience to the master. And if we're lucky enough to have access to the master tapes...then there is nothing more ultimate...higher dimensional music plane...HDMP.

I am 1,000% convinced of that. Anything less is for the mass duplication consumer market...high-res audio included.
...Digital hi-res audio files, digital hi-res audio players...DACs, CD players, SACD players, tra-la-la digitization. ...Digits...0, 1, digging, digs.

The best way to reinvent money circulation is mass duplication...like a drug...like cocaine. You sniff that music and you get a high, a hi-res illusion.

The master tapes are locked inside vaults with two-feet thick metal doors. ...Locked.
If you're lucky you have the key.

Lock, how much average for a quality open-reel tape of an album from an artist you like? ...Fifty bucks, hundred bucks, three hundred bucks, six hundred bucks...unobtainable? ...Near the later of that range.

I own zero Tape, I own zero Crystal Disc from Japan. Those can cost $1,000-2,000 each!

Hi-Res audio is as high as the market's trend and demand.

Just some thoughts about audio, hi-res audio. No magic powder, no alarm clock, no fireworks, no ultra multi million sound system, no spectrum analyzer, no oscilloscope with impulse response, no graphical measurements; just the music playing from the master tape in the ears of the beholder.
Measure that scientifically for fun.
 
Back
Top Bottom