pablitho
Member
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2023
- Messages
- 50
- Likes
- 4
Hi everyone,
I'm planning a dedicated home theater in an existing room and I'd like to get input from the ASR community before buying anything.
ROOM AND CONSTRAINTS- Dimensions: 3.0 m W x 5.8 m L x 2.7 m
Walls: drywall layer mounted on masonry, polyester fiber in the gap; suspended drywall ceiling (10-20 cm void above)- Single row, 2-3 seats- 110" 16:9 acoustically transparent screen covering the full front wall; a baffle wall is planned.
Budget for the whole audio system: roughly 15-30k EUR.
WHAT IS ALREADY DECIDED- 4 sealed subwoofers, BMS 18N862 drivers in 55 cm cubic enclosures.
Two at the front (under the screen), two at the rear (~1 m behind the seats), subs must stay on the floor.-
Pro amplification: Powersoft for the subs, fronts behind the screen, still undecided (considering JTR Noesis 212RT, or some cinema pro speakers.
Source: Windows HTPC with JRiver Media Center + madVR- Planned layout: [e.g. 7.4.4 / 5.4.4 – to be defined]
GOALS: My main goal for the low end is a smooth response across the 2-3 seats and above all, better control of modal decay (sealed subs chosen for transient response). My plan is to use MSO for the 4 subs.
I understand MSO mainly reduces seat-to-seat variation and modal peaks rather than "removing"room modes, so I'd like to hear what's realistic in a room this size.
QUESTIONS:
1. MSO with 4 subs - Is the front/rear placement sensible for this room, or would you change it?
Sub-only or subs+mains configuration? Would you allow all-pass filters? How many measurement positions for a 2-3 seat single row?
2. Multichannel DAC for the HTPC - I'd like a USB DAC/interface with at least 16 analog outputs, connected directly via USB (no bridges).
Currently looking at the MOTU 16A (2025). Which one would you choose today, and are there independent measurements I should look at?
3. Object-based formats with an HTPC. As far as I understand, JRiver decodes TrueHD Atmos only as the 7.1 bed, so no height objects. How would you handle Atmos/DTS:X in an HTPC-centric system? Is there a software solution, or is bitstreaming to a processor (e.g. miniDSP Tide16) the only realistic route?
4. HTPC + DAC vs dedicated processor. I'm weighing three architectures: HTPC + 16ch DAC (full DSP freedom, FIR, MSO), miniDSP Tide16 (Atmos + Dirac ART).
With 4 subs and decay control as the priority, which would you pick? Does MSO make sense alongside Dirac Bass Control/ART, or is it one or the other?
5. Gain staging. Any advice on matching DAC output level to Powersoft input sensitivity to minimize hiss with high-sensitivity cinema speakers?
I'm planning a dedicated home theater in an existing room and I'd like to get input from the ASR community before buying anything.
ROOM AND CONSTRAINTS- Dimensions: 3.0 m W x 5.8 m L x 2.7 m
Walls: drywall layer mounted on masonry, polyester fiber in the gap; suspended drywall ceiling (10-20 cm void above)- Single row, 2-3 seats- 110" 16:9 acoustically transparent screen covering the full front wall; a baffle wall is planned.
Budget for the whole audio system: roughly 15-30k EUR.
WHAT IS ALREADY DECIDED- 4 sealed subwoofers, BMS 18N862 drivers in 55 cm cubic enclosures.
Two at the front (under the screen), two at the rear (~1 m behind the seats), subs must stay on the floor.-
Pro amplification: Powersoft for the subs, fronts behind the screen, still undecided (considering JTR Noesis 212RT, or some cinema pro speakers.
Source: Windows HTPC with JRiver Media Center + madVR- Planned layout: [e.g. 7.4.4 / 5.4.4 – to be defined]
GOALS: My main goal for the low end is a smooth response across the 2-3 seats and above all, better control of modal decay (sealed subs chosen for transient response). My plan is to use MSO for the 4 subs.
I understand MSO mainly reduces seat-to-seat variation and modal peaks rather than "removing"room modes, so I'd like to hear what's realistic in a room this size.
QUESTIONS:
1. MSO with 4 subs - Is the front/rear placement sensible for this room, or would you change it?
Sub-only or subs+mains configuration? Would you allow all-pass filters? How many measurement positions for a 2-3 seat single row?
2. Multichannel DAC for the HTPC - I'd like a USB DAC/interface with at least 16 analog outputs, connected directly via USB (no bridges).
Currently looking at the MOTU 16A (2025). Which one would you choose today, and are there independent measurements I should look at?
3. Object-based formats with an HTPC. As far as I understand, JRiver decodes TrueHD Atmos only as the 7.1 bed, so no height objects. How would you handle Atmos/DTS:X in an HTPC-centric system? Is there a software solution, or is bitstreaming to a processor (e.g. miniDSP Tide16) the only realistic route?
4. HTPC + DAC vs dedicated processor. I'm weighing three architectures: HTPC + 16ch DAC (full DSP freedom, FIR, MSO), miniDSP Tide16 (Atmos + Dirac ART).
With 4 subs and decay control as the priority, which would you pick? Does MSO make sense alongside Dirac Bass Control/ART, or is it one or the other?
5. Gain staging. Any advice on matching DAC output level to Powersoft input sensitivity to minimize hiss with high-sensitivity cinema speakers?