• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

DAC measurements

It makes me laugh when I hear reviewers saying that on this song the female voice is so warm all that, but the little reverb effect on her voice comes from an Yamaha SPX900 with an PCM78AP ADC and an PCM56P DAC from the 80's, so the wonderful warmness you love about her voice comes from an 80's DAC that was used everywhere.
...or a Lexicon 42 or even a "Modern" TC M5000 :D What about the highly sought-after "character" sound of Akai MPC DAC's? No question they did sound good, but can hardly measure like a modern chip will. Hardly transparent - and used for effect and production desires - but sound great stamping their signature all over the sound :)
 
Last edited:
And in the 90's so many best selling albums like Alanis Morissette Jagged Little Pill were recorded on ADAT, that's the tape recorder from Alesis that used an S-VHS cassette tape to get 8 digital tracks, and they stacked and linked several machines to get 24 or more tracks, these machines were not known for having the best ADC of the industry, imagine the amount of jitter coming from 4 VHS cassettes who tries to stay synchronized with a time code

As far I as I know nobody has really complained about the sound quality of this album.
 
...or a Lexicon 42 or even a "Modern" TC M5000 :D What about the highly sought-after "character" sound of Akai MPC DAC's? No question they did sound good, but can hardly measure like a modern chip will. Hardly transparent - and used for effect and production desires - but sound great stamping their signature all over the sound :)
Who or what evidences this "character" sound, tho?
 
Who or what evidences this "character" sound, tho?
Anyone using an MPC is bound by it (no digital outs on OG MPC's that have the "sound")... MPC's are all over those classic records in spades... I believe there are quite a few MPC DAC emulations out there trying to recreate the vibe...

A quick search reveals:
What Makes Classic MPC Sound Unique
    • Bit Depth & Sample Rate: The MPC60 uses a nonlinear 12-bit converter at 40 kHz, while the MPC3000/2000 lines moved to 16-bit / 44.1 kHz with distinct interpolation and resampling behaviors. [1]
    • Conversion & Clipping: Vintage character comes heavily from how hard the input A/D converters are driven (clipping/saturation), the anti-aliasing low-pass filter topologies, and the D/A converter output stage (such as PCM54 or PCM69A chips). [1, 2, 3]
    • Aliasing & Pitching: Shifting or pitching samples down on older units introduces signature aliasing and high-frequency roll-off. [1]

A "Character" unit for sure :) And no questioning that it has a delightful signature that just works...


And in the 90's so many best selling albums like Alanis Morissette Jagged Little Pill were recorded on ADAT, that's the tape recorder from Alesis that used an S-VHS cassette tape to get 8 digital tracks, and they stacked and linked several machines to get 24 or more tracks, these machines were not known for having the best ADC of the industry, imagine the amount of jitter coming from 4 VHS cassettes who tries to stay synchronized with a time code

As far I as I know nobody has really complained about the sound quality of this album.
But the Mackie 8-Bus summing that was a common match for the ADAT's had the low-headroom issue on the Subs and Main busses - I'd bet Jagged Little Pill was not done on a Mackie 8-Buss :) Sold the shit out of those Mackie's in the day! ('94-'98)
 
Last edited:
That's why I would like to see a little more info and clarity on the feature set. The features are what sets them apart these days. Soon performance won't even be a consideration it will be assumed. So what's left? Your purchase decision will be biased on what features are attached to the DAC as opposed to the DAC itself. DAC's with all their incorporated features are like a modern preamplifier or a line stage if you will. Take an old school preamplifier and add digital inputs and there you go.
 
That's why I would like to see a little more info and clarity on the feature set. The features are what sets them apart these days. Soon performance won't even be a consideration it will be assumed. So what's left? Your purchase decision will be biased on what features are attached to the DAC as opposed to the DAC itself. DAC's with all their incorporated features are like a modern preamplifier or a line stage if you will. Take an old school preamplifier and add digital inputs and there you go.
LOL
 
What a load of shit.
OK? I guess you've never produced or seen how records were made in the day? MPC is more of a hip-hop thing - but literally EVERYWHERE, and with its unique sonic signature largely attributed to the ADC/DAC and intentional non-linear behaviors...
What Makes Classic MPC Sound Unique
    • Bit Depth & Sample Rate: The MPC60 uses a nonlinear 12-bit converter at 40 kHz, while the MPC3000/2000 lines moved to 16-bit / 44.1 kHz with distinct interpolation and resampling behaviors. [1]
    • Conversion & Clipping: Vintage character comes heavily from how hard the input A/D converters are driven (clipping/saturation), the anti-aliasing low-pass filter topologies, and the D/A converter output stage (such as PCM54 or PCM69A chips). [1, 2, 3]
    • Aliasing & Pitching: Shifting or pitching samples down on older units introduces signature aliasing and high-frequency roll-off. [1]

Emulations:
Hardware, Software, & Plugin Emulation Options
    • Dedicated Emulation Plugins:
      • EM-900: A specialized plugin that meticulously models the DAC circuits, low-pass filter topologies, and character of 17 different vintage samplers (including the MPC60 and SP-1200), complete with aliasing and preamp modeling.
      • HoRNet ADDA: An analog-to-digital and digital-to-analog converter plugin adding bit reduction, resampling, and analog saturation.
      • Max for Live: Tools like the MPC Emulator by The Flava Machine model fixed converter profiles (bit depth, filtering, DAC behavior, drive response, and bass weight) for the MPC60, MPC2000, and MPC2000XL. [1, 2, 3, 4]
    • Built-in / Native Vintage FX on Modern MPCs:
      • Modern standalone Akai MPC hardware (MPC One, Live II, X, etc.) includes a Vintage Emulator effect (accessible via Knob FX or plugin inserts) with preset modes for the MPC60, MPC3000, SP-1200, and SP-1200 Ring.
      • You can also manually emulate converter clipping inside modern MPCs using a soft clipper, subtle bit-crushing (between 12 and 13 bits), low-end EQ, and tube drive, followed by internal resampling ("hard baking") to commit the sound and save CPU. [1, 2, 3]
    • Full System Emulation:
      • The classic Akai MPC3000 can be run via MAME (Multiple Arcade Machine Emulator) by supplying the appropriate ROMs, MIDI input, audio card routing, and .HF floppy disk images. Discussions and community insights on the accuracy of these software approaches can be followed on Gearspace and MPC-Forums. [1, 2, 3]
 
Last edited:
OK? I guess you've never produced or seen how records were made in the day? MPC is more of a hip-hop thing - but literally EVERYWHERE, and with its unique sonic signature largely attributed to the ADC/DAC and intentional non-linear behaviors...


Emulations:
Please expand. My objection is far simpler.
 
Please expand. My objection is far simpler.
That a poor-measuring ADC/DAC that is "abused" musically has a genre-defining impact for an entire generation of music, and sounds great doing it? Which is now being emulated in software for its charm.

Which part are you objecting to with your "What a load of shit" statement?
 
Most people would call that a massive waste of time and energy.
it's not my time or my energy, nor is it yours. and most of what I get up to in my life would be considered by many people to be an even worse waste of time and energy. honestly, unless you're saving starving people or whatever, it could be argued that everything you do is a waste of time and energy.
 
t
OK? I guess you've never produced or seen how records were made in the day? MPC is more of a hip-hop thing - but literally EVERYWHERE, and with its unique sonic signature largely attributed to the ADC/DAC and intentional non-linear behaviors...
tons of records i like were recorded on cassette 4-tracks, too, but making art is a totally separate domain from reproducing it later. evelyn glennie makes very good music and she's deaf--is that an argument for going deaf to listen to music?
 
4 track electronics have a very desirable character as well that is also emulated in software. My old Roland VS2480 also had a "Sound" between the Preamps/ADC/DAC and proprietary "RDAC" data compression. But not really a "sought after" sound - unlike the MPC's and 4-Tracks that are charming and their character is still appreciated to this day. Charming with some edges - not "Clean" or "Clinical"....

As mentioned - these are not transparent - but rather sought after for what they do to the sound in a musical way. I guess this is blasphemy???

As you were in your sterile clean rooms - have fun!
 
When you listen Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon first pressing CDs you are listening the master encoded with a Sony CX20017 DAC from 1982 with all the distortion, jitter, harshness, or the Sony CX20152 from 1985 with some oversampling.
What? Data on the CD is not analog. What does the CD have to do with a DAC chip?

DSTM was a decent demo track back in the day. It is certainly not that clean compared to modern recordings.
 
Back
Top Bottom