• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

DAC audible differences are finally proven with ABX?

It is the analogy that fails. What the heck has control theory and software in common with testing audio equipment parameters?? With hearing limits and psychoacoustics and physiological acoustics? These are all scientific disciplines. Impressions based on little knowledge and emotions do not help.
 
C'mon man... I'm running out of popcorn here.
Have some of this
00CFA3EE-7054-4C23-B1C9-FD0C47838C79.png
 
It is the analogy that fails. What the heck has control theory and software in common with testing audio equipment parameters?? With hearing limits and psychoacoustics and physiological acoustics? These are all scientific disciplines. Impressions based on little knowledge and emotions do not help.
This was just because Buckeye Amps used a non audio example. You are right, psychoacoustic and physiological acoustics are called scientific. But are they really up to the end? I read some books from Blauert and others. Many tests, but some of the result is a statistical one. Even the Fletcher Munson curves are averages and may not be valid for all people. Yes, science but with some uncertainties. OK, if there is specific test procedure and equipment then the results can be compared according just to the scope of the test. But with other tests the specimen might show differences even when identical at the first test method. But I will not discuss the validity of tests further. It is endless.
 
I’ve always wonder for how many people it is a conscious decision to ignore the science?
I believe a large community of ‘reviewers’ critically depend upon the deliberate denunciation of any attempt to objectify the audio realm using scientific methods. They have a follower base of disciples voraciously consuming their declarations of warmth from here, musicality from there and subtlety from elsewhere. Any admission that such descriptions lack meaning in a rigorous exploration of sound quality are blasphemous and destructive to their entire raison d’être. Lacking any cogent argument against the science they simply ignore, ridicule and pontificate with more nonsense…they cannot rationally argue, only deny.

Virtually all of such reviewers would be instantly out of business if real science was deemed worthy…so they simply will never, ever admit it into their discussions.
 
I myself am also a published researcher who knows and have worked with a lot of well recognized researchers but I would never use their personal opinion on any subject as an objective data point. Anecdotal evidence is not evidence (nor is an appeal to authority claim).

Your response kind of proves the point: science doesn't care about feelings or opinion. Sorry.
And your response proves my point, which you entirely missed.
Sorry.
 
Any admission that such descriptions lack meaning in a rigorous exploration of sound quality are blasphemous and destructive to their entire raison d’être
Virtually all of such reviewers would be instantly out of business if real science was deemed worthy…so they simply will never, ever admit it into their discussions.
Don't forget that the consumer demand is the product for these reviewers, and they sell it to the audio product manufacturers. Obviously they will pretent it's the other way around.
 
Facts (AFAICT).


Opinion from someone who posts here but doesn't particularly like the place ?
As I’ve posted before, I think the site presents valuable information. That doesn’t mean I think it’s beyond criticism.
Same goes for AS. I think there is some nonsense posted there. Doesn’t mean there also isn’t valuable info there.
 
I know it is hard for some of you people to accept, but not everyone is interested in the ideas and methods of this site.
Well one thing is certain…YOU are not interested in the scientific discovery of what matters about sound quality. Why? Tell us why!

I suggest you overtly speak for yourself, because that is how you will be interpreted no matter how hard you try to externalize or generalize what you say.

1786381465110.jpeg
 
The box is on its way to Amir ;)
This is a good development. Great work getting this done!

Not confident testing the box will find a definitive result to explain what’s been debated here.

I’d like to see two or three of the same DAC pairs as Josh tested recorded so a wide community of listeners can participate in abx evaluation with this box as a comparator.

Could (should) use the same DAC through each channel of this box and directly (not through this box) to see if any differences can be detected there.
 
Not confident testing the box will find a definitive result to explain what’s been debated here
Let’s not second guess the results.

Once we know the state of the box and if it had a material influence on the results we can then assess things further.
 
Not confident testing the box will find a definitive result to explain what’s been debated here.

It cannot and it will not. Only if it is damned bad. Still the only info would be in getting info about the box. I have been pesimistic from the beginning, however I applaud @NTTY for his efforts and generosity. There is a human level and technical level, not the same thing.
 
I hope the box is clean so that tangent can be closed. To me, that's the most generous and charitable explanation - but also the least likely.

it's so much more likely that there is something in the testing protocol or controls that account for the astonishing result. To me the transgression is presenting this as science without any of the transparency good science demands. This is just one persons uninteresting experiment.

The behavior after the fact makes me more concerned that it was disingenuous. But we'll never know.
 
it's so much more likely that there is something in the testing protocol or controls that account for the astonishing result.

And the totality of that protocol is way beyond what this community can factually discover, in the (likely IMO) event the comparator is ‘near transparent or better’.

But we can create from a test through the same comparator a number of files that would allow both human testing vs audibility and technical analysis of what actually is different in the output. That’s where the value will be found I suspect.
 
I’d like to see two or three of the same DAC pairs as Josh tested recorded so a wide community of listeners can participate in abx evaluation with this box as a comparator.
We are in good shape there. I am pretty sure I have the D900 and SU-1 somewhere around here. And I found the Matrix Sabre-Pro MQA last night.
I have RME ADI-2 Pro FS R but he used the ADI-2 DAC FS. I don't know if that model is still in production. If it is, I am sure I can ask RME to loan a sample.

I don't have the Gustard R30 or Yggy LIM. Former should be pretty easy to get. Latter is a possibility.

I suspect we can start with what I have and then expand if needed.

Net, net, DAC availability is not an issue.
 
The box is on its way to Amir ;)
Thanks for everything you have done!

Now that this has happened, I can disclose that I will be buying the box from @NTTY for $1,200. I just couldn't let him spend so much money on this by himself.
 
Back
Top Bottom