- Joined
- Dec 12, 2019
- Messages
- 18,311
- Likes
- 42,278
Possibly true, but the work of good scientists is rarely aimed at confirmation of "what's established". The results under discussion here absolutely and irrevocably fail to back up what's established, and fairly cry out for investigation. @pablolie ennui notwithstanding, I find the root cause of the reported observations to be intensely fascinating. Analytical artifact would be (is) my working hypothesis,Most work in science doesn’t challenge the established science, it backs up what’s established.
Here's a a favorite example of mine, which I use as an example of "what scientists are like" in a grad-level course on glycobiology (my own area of expertise, which turned out to be chock full of the unexpected) I taught for a decade. This is how ahem one Nobel laureate thinks about his life's work, even if only in retrospect.
I think it's fairly safe to assume that, e.g., Nobelist Carolyn Bertozzi, who, among many other things in her stellar career, discovered, but did not expect, RNA covalently modified with carbohydrate, feels similarly.
Last edited:
