• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Chinese accuphase clone comparison video

It's not counterfeit and there's no IP being stolen as these clones are based on expired patents. Nothing wrong with saying this amp is built to match this Accuphase model and if someone wants to listen to the circuit of an expensive accuphase amp then why not? I doubt anyone is buying these to try and pass off as an original, some of the ones I've sent say "imput" or "selektor" on the dials!
 
It's not counterfeit and there's no IP being stolen as these clones are based on expired patents. Nothing wrong with saying this amp is built to match this Accuphase model and if someone wants to listen to the circuit of an expensive accuphase amp then why not? I doubt anyone is buying these to try and pass off as an original, some of the ones I've sent say "imput" or "selektor" on the dials!
Circuit designs by themselves aren't even copyright protectable. It's just circuits, as long as they aren't doing anything fundamentally new in order to be patentable (99.9% don't), there's no legal protection at all and everyone can use them as they wish.

A prominent contemporary example is the habit of Behringer corporation of cloning all kinds of both old and obsolete, and new and still sold synthesizer designs. It's certainly an ongoing controversy in the music community with strongly divided opinions about the morality of it all, very valid concerns, but on a legal level it's all proper and alright.
 
This is interesting to me. So are there things like Hypex clones available?

If there's no applicable copyright involved, I don't understand why there aren't loads of copies/clones of quality circuits being churned out.
By numerous companies.
 
This is interesting to me. So are there things like Hypex clones available?

If there's no applicable copyright involved, I don't understand why there aren't loads of copies/clones of quality circuits being churned out.
By numerous companies.
There aren't, because those high feedback class D designs are new enough in both the temporal and "technical creation" sense to qualify for a patent. Which they hold. Really an exceptional example.

But oldschool class A/AB designs? Those are so basic and commonplace compared, there's nothing worth patenting the offices would recognise because it's all been done countless times before, for decades. The same as the basic analog synthesis circuits in my example above.

If you tried patenting a bog standard oscillator, filter or amplifier circuit today, that has been known and used in over 9000 devices since 1959 or something, the patent office clerk would laugh you out of the building. That's exactly why stuff like these Accuphase clones is perfectly legal: there's nothing special, new, or unique about them. It's all bog standard electronic methods our grandfathers wouldn't be surprised by.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom