• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

CD signal out vs transport interconnects. Why/which?

Thanks guys, all.

If using the player only as transport to dac across very short distance (stacked on top of each other), toslink or coaxial?

Both are S/PDIF.
for your use case it MAKES NO DIFFERENCE.
 
DVD players are more likely to change the digital output than a pure CD player, especially if they have an HDMI output.
The standard says that protected high-res data can only be output at max 16bits/48kHz on SPDIF. Some manufacturers don’t bother much and process all digital sources through an ASRC for SPDIF output, thus modifying the CDA digital stream even if that is theoretically unnecessary.
 
FWIW,
I ended up with a CD transport that outputs coax, optical and USB.
USB was the clear winner when conducting A\b testing. Cleaner with a more distinct sound stage,
then coax, which still sounded better then optical.
 
FWIW,
I ended up with a CD transport that outputs coax, optical and USB.
USB was the clear winner when conducting A\b testing. Cleaner with a more distinct sound stage,
then coax, which still sounded better then optical.
This is very unlikely unless massive issue with some of the outputs.
 
FWIW,
I ended up with a CD transport that outputs coax, optical and USB.
USB was the clear winner when conducting A\b testing. Cleaner with a more distinct sound stage,
then coax, which still sounded better then optical.
Sound stage is a property of the recording with some interactions of speakers and room. No digital transport has any influence on it, because no digital transport changes the actual audio data in any way (unless defective).

Sighted listening comparisons with long switching times (>5 s) and no level matching are inherently flawed and will not give you trustworthy results under any circumstances.
 
This is very unlikely unless massive issue with some of the outputs.
And if there were - it wouldn't change sound stage or "cleanliness" one iota - problems would manifest as one or more of dropouts/clicks/ticks/pops.
 
That’s what I meant by massive :)
From the test of the Fiio DM15, I was nothing else but impressed by the modifications of the digital signal. We’re getting closer to hearing threshold. Long time ago, the OPPO 105 had an issue, which I identified to come from digital processing, which showed itself only in some particular instances (+3dB in one channel and heavy clipping, that can be heard).

Now, a difference between coax and optical SPDIF output, probably not, unless significant ground issue / hum noise travelling via coax cable, maybe.
 
Or maybe my optical cable isn't the greatest.

Anyhow, soundstage: appeared clearer, ie the instruments were easier to place. Not wider or taller. The USB signal, in my case, just seemed to de-merge things.

Sorry if my response, and my ears, contradict your dogma.
 
Or maybe my optical cable isn't the greatest.
Unlikely, unless you're using 100m+ cables, maybe, at least to generate a super massive amount of jitter.
Anyhow, soundstage: appeared clearer, ie the instruments were easier to place. Not wider or taller. The USB signal, in my case, just seemed to de-merge things.
Again, unless significant digital signal processing is happening between these, then no.
Sorry if my response, and my ears, contradict your dogma.
Dogma? Seriously?
 
Or maybe my optical cable isn't the greatest.

Anyhow, soundstage: appeared clearer, ie the instruments were easier to place. Not wider or taller. The USB signal, in my case, just seemed to de-merge things.

Sorry if my response, and my ears, contradict your dogma.
Science is not a dogma. Testing things incorrectly and without sufficient controls leads to wrong conclusions. That's not surprising at all. Typical mistakes (as already explained above):
  • Not knowing or disregarding bias (by testing sighted)
  • Not level matching
  • Now knowing about or disregarding the effects of the very short nature of echoic memory
In your case, the additional problem is that you either don't know about or ignore the properties of digital signals: Apart from bit errors, jitter and noise on the ground plane there's nothing that could alter the sound in any way. Noise would be immediately audible when the device is turned on and nothing is playing and I have never seen a case of actually audible levels of jitter (which doesn't lead to the receiving device loosing the connection). If there were any other errors like bit flips, you would immediately hear those as louds pops, clicks and other blatantly obvious problems. If you ever used an old portable CD player without a buffer or you altered individual samples in an audio editor, you will know how absolutely not subtle those errors are.

Since you did not mention any noise, drop-outs or pops, the only plausible assumption is that the data passed through all interconnects in the same bit-perfect form and there was no audible difference between them whatsoever. Insisting that this is wrong while ignoring all the logic behind this argument would be... dogmatic.
 
Or maybe my optical cable isn't the greatest.

Anyhow, soundstage: appeared clearer, ie the instruments were easier to place. Not wider or taller. The USB signal, in my case, just seemed to de-merge things.

Sorry if my response, and my ears, contradict your dogma.
(My bold)

They don't. You haven't tested blind and level matched, so your ears have contradicted nothing, in fact they have confirmed that uncontrolled listening results erroneous conclusions.

If you had tested blind and adequately controlled, and therefore were able to prove there were a difference to be heard, we would then be in the game of finding out which of the connections was faulty in some way - still contradicting nothing. But it certainly wouldn't be differences in the sound stage you were hearing. Errors in the digital signal can't do that. Basic engineering dictates it as pointed out above.


The USB signal, in my case, just seemed to de-merge things.

Or are you able to come up with a well grounded science or engineering based argument as to how that could happen.
 
To some extend, dead cheapo optical cables PLUS sockets (at the gear side) with these horrible plastic ends are not the exact definition of quality and are highly susceptible of all kinds of faults.
Tested, proper ones though are just fine.

Edit: having a look around, Benchmark ones seems really nice at first glance.

 
Last edited:
To some extend, dead cheapo optical cables PLUS sockets (at the gear side) with these horrible plastic ends are not the exact definition of quality and are highly susceptible of all kinds of faults.
Tested, proper ones though are just fine.

Edit: having a look around, Benchmark ones seems really nice at first glance.

If the fiber optic cable were made with genuine quartz glass optical fibers, then the price would be reasonable, but they don't mention that, and it wouldn't be possible with that bending radius.

With standard POF fiber optic material, it's the same nonsense as with some expensive HiFi cables and outrageously overpriced.
Good quality POF fiber optic cable costs about €2-4 per meter from a retailer.

Metal connectors are absolute rubbish and counterproductive. The connectors should be made of black, matte plastic. A glossy finish is counterproductive because it can cause reflections, and metal connectors will eventually damage the sockets because the mating is designed for plastic. I know a technician in a repair shop who could tell you a thing or two about that. Even Toshiba issued a notice for their original Japanese Tosling connectors and sockets stating that they shouldn't be used with metal connectors.

Good quality, pre-assembled fiber optic cables from a brand cost around €5-10 per meter. I would advise against using no-name fiber optic cables, as there is now a lot of inferior POF fiber optic material on the market.

If you want truly high quality, order pre-assembled cables by the meter from a fiber optic cable supplier. With the best material, this costs around €12 per meter, and with quartz glass, around €25-40.

Incidentally, the Toslink cables, which are only 2.2 mm thick and more rigid, are the better option.
 
Nonsense.
Which part? That I found USB a cleaner sound? I don't recall you being in the room.

Seems some ppl do not understand subjectivity, and I again refer to my earlier comment on dogma.
 
Which part? That I found USB a cleaner sound? I don't recall you being in the room.

Seems some ppl do not understand subjectivity, and I again refer to my earlier comment on dogma.
Which CD drive and which DAC did you end up using?
 
Which part? That I found USB a cleaner sound? I don't recall you being in the room.

Seems some ppl do not understand subjectivity, and I again refer to my earlier comment on dogma.

I understand it well. Do you understand how dubious your report based on it is?

Have you even, for a moment, being a reader and contributor to Audio Science Review, considered an alternative explanation is for what you 'heard'?
 
Last edited:
I may be hijacking this thread a little, but I've liked the answers I've seen here from the science oriented posters. Plus it is an older thread and the OP seems to have ceased posting on it.

I'm considering buying and using the Tascam CD200-BT as a transport only, recommended and reviewed by NTTY (Thanks for that review). I currently am using an old California Audio Labs CL-10 HDCD player I bought on E-Bay years ago for I believe $200. I bought the CL-5 in 1999 for almost a grand (US) and I still have both. I'd buy the Tascam because it is new and the review here on ASR was very favorable. I see it lasting to the end of my watch so to speak.

Here are my questions if anybody with a true objective set of answers can chime in and this can apply to my current CD player and the Tascam should I buy it.

I was thinking of using a Blue Jeans Cables RCA Coaxial to hook either player up to my Bryston BR-20 Preamp. I don't know that I'd lose much or anything by not having the CL-10's HDCD's properties. I have some duplicate HDCD's that I also have on standard CD and I don't know that I hear a difference and I have no measurable way to say one way or the other. I don't have the equipment and I'd have no clue what I'm doing.

Here is my second question and it is somewhat unrelated to the initial post here.

In regard to "soundstage", I saw the answer earlier in the thread that it is in relation to the source recording.

I have Perlisten S7T speakers and they seem to respond well to room placement when it comes to loading bass. I find the bass to favorably increase the closer I place them to the front wall.

I've read different opinions about having speakers pulled out further from the front wall that say "soundstage depth" is better when the speakers are further into the room. Supposedly the depth field increases behind the speakers if they are moved into the room a little more. Is that true or rubbish? I previously used NHT 3.3 speakers and I still have them. They were damn near flush with the front wall and the bass response was very, very good. The Perlisten speakers seem better in every way sans the bass.

Again, apologies for the semi hijack questions, but if anybody here has some objective insight to what I just rambled off, I'd appreciate it.

I'm really out of my depth on this board and often feel like a moron asking certain equations and even trying to convey proper terminology. I sometimes feel I use subjective phrasing even though I'm wanting objective answers.

Thank you to anybody that can answer these questions and apologies again to the O/P if I diverted this thread in an unfavorable direction.
 
@Gio-G I may be missing something, but I only see one question in your post? In any case, asking about the speaker thing might be answered quicker in a speaker thread. Asking about the specific CD transport might be easier in that review thread.

Short answer about the speakers based on what I know: Speaker placement can have an effect on perceived sound stage, but I would not conclude that a single change (like moving them away from the wall) will always have the same effect. What creates the impression of a broader stage are the amount of reflections and their time differences relative to the direct path. So things like speaker directivity and placement, as well as room geometry and treatment (absorbers, carpets, etc.) can have an effect. Other members will probably know a bit more about this than me.
 
Back
Top Bottom