• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Can New AppleTV 4K be competitive in TV Streamer Market

If we're talking TV - I'm content with a Roku Ultra box for the HT room. The family finds its' interface fairly user friendly.
I also get LPCM audio from Roku Apple Music app 16/44 or 24/48 depending on the recording

4K HDR TVs - Supports Dolby Vision® at 60fps, HDR10/10+ and HLG
802.11ax dual-band MIMO Wi-Fi® 6 (2.4 GHz / 5 GHz)
USB 3.0
HDMI 2.1b

I tried Roku Ultra and GoogleTV but all the ads in their interface drove me crazy.
It was great moving to Apple and all those interface ads disappeared.
 
One thing I like about my prior gen, 128k Apple streamer is listening to programs via my AirPod Pro3s which sound fantastic and bring great dimensions to video material.

I won’t be upgrading to the new streamer soon but considering the great performance of my gen 3, why would I?
 
Roku doesn’t compare to Apple. Better picture and sound. I moved to Roku when Apple refused to support Prime. Back to Apple 2 years ago. I’ll buy new model and move old one to bedroom
 
Wow, $300 for a streamer. Is AppleTV subscription included or something?
No, crazy RAM prices and they likely included enough to run one of their distilled LLMs on machine. No idea why, but shareholders need to be convinced that Apple will be the one steadily monetizing AI. They are also rumored to release some game controllers via their Beats brand, so probably another likely unsuccessful push to sell this as a casual gaming console. Will probably be $250 for the holidays on select retailers. I’ll buy one then to replace my first gen 4K, which is now not supported with latest software anymore.
 
Good point. It was Google, the poster child of personal data monetization, who once had the motto of "Don't be evil".

That reminds be of the advertising slogan of Audi USA before 'Dieselgate'.....

Truth in Engineering
 
Good point. It was Google, the poster child of personal data monetization, who once had the motto of "Don't be evil".
True, but I also don't know if there's much sense in making decisions based on guesses about the future.

At time of writing, Apple's marketing is putting a heavy emphasis on privacy for most of their products. It isn't just an internal memo, it's a selling point.

Another point of difference is that Apple makes the majority of their revenue from hardware sales. After that, it's paid services. The business model is entirely different to Google's of providing "free" services

EDIT: This isn't to say that Apple are an astoundingly ethical company, or that they won't change their mind, but as I said at the beginning - there's little point in speculating about them flipping the script at this juncture. They're doing quite well financially, and some of this could be attributed to them using security and privacy as a marketing angle.
 
True, but I also don't know if there's much sense in making decisions based on guesses about the future.

At time of writing, Apple's marketing is putting a heavy emphasis on privacy for most of their products. It isn't just an internal memo, it's a selling point.

Another point of difference is that Apple makes the majority of their revenue from hardware sales. After that, it's paid services. The business model is entirely different to Google's of providing "free" services

EDIT: This isn't to say that Apple are an astoundingly ethical company, or that they won't change their mind, but as I said at the beginning - there's little point in speculating about them flipping the script at this juncture. They're doing quite well financially, and some of this could be attributed to them using security and privacy as a marketing angle.
Google's primary revenue stream is advertising sales. Their primary products are designed to support that revenue model.
 
People are also ignoring the power house that the A19 chip inside of the new version of the box is. Sure, we are limited on what we can use the CPU for, however, I am quite sure that hardware raw power is sorted for the next 5 years at a minimum. Apps performance is something that I value greatly, and hate when they get updated throughout the years and I get a laggy experience
 
Apple Claims they don't capture user data to sell it.
They have built that message into their advertising pretty heavily. If there was ever an indication that Apple was selling customer data it would hurt sales badly.

That said, I really don't need a device with three mic's to capture room commands 24 hours a day. The existing button on the remote of previous models is good enough in the off chance I actually wanted to use SIRI. However, that almost never happens.

To me, the slightly used 2024-2025 AppleTV 4K 128 that someone might be selling to buy the new model would actually be what I might consider as the best deal.
If I am reading it right, I believe we can just buy the new remote and use a newer ipad or phone with Apple intelligence to provide the Siri function while staying on the previous model Apple TV4K. Given the terrible TV interface on every TV and external TV device, voice control may be an improvemenet. One would guess the ipad of phone with Apple intelligence could be the remote control too. My experience with the previous generation Siri has been disappointing. On the other hand, basic navigation of a TV and subscription apps is an easy problem.

That removes the "always listening" issue with the new AppleTV hockey puck. The hardware upgrades to attain Apple intelligence are a disappointment. They claim it requires a more recent ARM chip. I wonder if the new chips have an expanded instruction set related to intelligence? From my limited understanding, LLM is an exercise in matrix multiplication and memory.
 
Last edited:
They claim it requires a more recent ARM chip. I wonder if the new chips have an expanded instruction set related to intelligence?
They incorporate "neural cores" in newer CPUs, specifically for AI-type functionality. It's similar in the Windows world, with some recent x86 and ARM hardware offering cores dedicated to bringing features like Recall to life. My PCs predate the AI craze, hence, my Windows 11 doesn't Recall (apparently not a feature I'd want anyhow).

At the moment, a more Siri-fied ATV doesn't seem like a reason for me to buy the latest model, but access to future software updates probably will be.
 
Last edited:
Yes I am repulsed by that "feature".

If I must use windoze in future I will likely need to go to great lengths to disable crap like that.
 
Not sure if this requires an Apple TV, but I really enjoy listening late at night with my AirPods Max. With head tracking on I sometimes forget I'm even wearing headphones. Along with the "hand off" feature, it is quite a seamless experience.
 
Apple provides a superior user experience to the alternatives. They can charge more because most people agree with this opinion.

I got a MacBook air recently after a lifetime of windows laptops. It might as well be from another universe compared to the garbage I've been using all these years. Ironically it was quite cheap too.
 
Apple provides a superior user experience to the alternatives. They can charge more because most people agree with this opinion.

I got a MacBook air recently after a lifetime of windows laptops. It might as well be from another universe compared to the garbage I've been using all these years. Ironically it was quite cheap too.
I don't know about a different universe, but it certainly is from another planet.

Apple.png
 
I don't know about a different universe, but it certainly is from another planet.

View attachment 564356
Looking at the wrist rest of my dell 5k$ work laptop with an Intel sticker which has gradually rotated due to the adhesive softening from heat. CPU is at 20 percent and the fans have been blowing at 100 percent all day. The fake carbon fiber finish has a soft coating which is peeling off. It has no sleep mode, if I close it, the laptop will get hot enough to scare me if I put it in my bag. My Bluetooth mouse randomly disconnects about once a week. It amazes me that people buy these devices for their own use.

Apple stuff looks expensive but it isn't really. The most frugal people I know don't bother with android, they just keep their iphones for 5 years or more.
 
Apple stuff looks expensive but it isn't really. The most frugal people I know don't bother with android, they just keep their iphones for 5 years or more.
I don't think I have ever been called frugal... but my iPhone 12 mini is almost 6 years old... it is on its second battery, but still works great!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 617
I could do without the extra storage and AI Siri whatever the hell it’s called. HDMI pass through would have been a serious welcome for many but no the biggest upgrade for the Apple TV is the price.
 
Same here - 12 mini, and still working great, tho needs more frequent charging now.
Will probably upgrade soon, along with new ATV (from original version) for better Home/Matter capabilities.
AI and spy microphones will be defeated as much as possible, asap.
I agree, the UI on the remote is horrible; unintuitive and just annoying...for what? To Be Different?? Yeesh.
Just realized I can use the remote app on the watch instead - will try that.
 
I don't think I have ever been called frugal... but my iPhone 12 mini is almost 6 years old... it is on its second battery, but still works great!

Apple iPhone batteries aren't cheap.
With the telco companies offering a free iPhone every two to three years most of the time it's cheaper to upgrade than install a new battery. At least it has been for me.

If they ever gave away free AppleTV 4K units with internet service that would be great too. :D
 
Back
Top Bottom