• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Can Horns Take Place of Waveguides

I definitely come to ASR so I can listen to people beat a dead terminology horse over and over. Boy we're really making progress aren't we.
Possibilities:
  1. We are solely here for your amusement.
  2. New people often ask the same question without doing a search. Since searching can be unrewarding at times I am inclined to give them the benefit of the doubt.
  3. Terminology changes and sometimes new definitions and standards take place. Or someone pops into an old topic with new, or just better, information than found in the original thread due to different knowledge base and experience. Or whatever.
I'll leave it to you to rank them appropriately. And just to be anal, note that (a) you don't have to read the threads, and (b) you are actually reading instead of listening unless using a text-to-speech program.

That said, snark aside, I love horses and would hate to see them beaten.
 
Sometimes it is very difficult to distinguish between the appearance and function of waveguides and horns. The lines between them are blurred, and often the linguistic difference is greater than the physical one.


1791869259044.png
 
Reminds me of Yamaha wave force speakers.
And zaphs mention Of one of my fave, the mcm 54-580 / Pyle h65.

Good looking horn there above.
 
Thanks for the information!

My quick first impression is that a number of manufacturers are now making speakers with waveguides on their tweeters to perform well in Spinoramas but they are using a piece of plastic for a waveguide that could probably be banged out on a 3D printer at my local library for two bucks and then trying to charge $20K or more because the speaker system contains it. Some people may find that to be a good deal, but I am not one of those people.

So I was wondering if any manufacturers may be producing a reasonably priced system (or a DIY kit or design) using horns on both the mids and tweeters to match their radiation patterns more closely to each which perform well on Spinorama tests. I believe that to do well on a Spinorama, the horns would have to have mouths that were more or less circularly shaped so they beamed symmetrically about their on-axis lines.

I do remember reading something a long time ago about horns/waveguides having some level of unavoidable distortion due to the physics of their operation. How much of a problem is that in real world use?
 
a number of manufacturers are now making speakers with waveguides on their tweeters to perform well in Spinoramas but they are using a piece of plastic for a waveguide that could probably be banged out on a 3D printer at my local library for two bucks and then trying to charge $20K or more because the speaker system contains it. Some people may find that to be a good deal, but I am not one of those people.
Designing a waveguide that works really well with a specific tweeter and woofer combination is not trivial. Once you have the CAD file, sure, from there the hard part is getting the tweeter in without denting the dome, but the piece of plastic isn't really what you are paying for.

On the other hand, you really can just hop over to DIYAudio.com and in certain threads, find a wealth of 3D-printable waveguides for a variety of tweeters. You still need to think through the crossover with your woofer of choice, but they exist and are free / cheap.

So I was wondering if any manufacturers may be producing a reasonably priced system (or a DIY kit or design) using horns on both the mids and tweeters to match their radiation patterns more closely to each which perform well on Spinorama tests.
Not many that I know of, but you can get stuff like this: https://www.jwsound.live/designs/sawmod ... you might also find some on DIYAudio or other similar groups out there.

I do remember reading something a long time ago about horns/waveguides having some level of unavoidable distortion due to the physics of their operation. How much of a problem is that in real world use?
I think there's some but it's a matter of some debate as to how much and how bad it is.
 
My quick first impression is that a number of manufacturers are now making speakers with waveguides on their tweeters to perform well in Spinoramas but they are using a piece of plastic for a waveguide that could probably be banged out on a 3D printer at my local library for two bucks and then trying to charge $20K or more because the speaker system contains it
That's not why a speaker is expensive. With good waveguides, a huge amount of the cost is the engineering to get to that geometry. Before modern simulation, it wasn't uncommon to mock up and measure dozens of geometries. Even with modern simulation, that takes time and iteration.

All of this discounting the drivers, the box, the (if active) amp, the cost to pay people to build the speakers, to ship the speakers, to deal with returns and customer support, any dealer markup, and profit margin.
 
And, a waveguide tends to be wider dispersion compared to a horn.
Horns can narrow their dispersion in the high frequencies, which also adds free high frequency boost to a compression driver that tends to roll off in the highs.

To me, waveguides are less angular, so less Difraction (smoother response).

Here is a neat article where zaph slightly horn loads a flattish dome tweet.

Notice the waveguide adds boost below 6khz.
Good news is when you eq it flat, you now have headroom there, less strained (distortion).
Bad news, good luck passively getting it to measure flat.
 
_dsc1446433x904.png


Dsp 15" 2-way to a 1" compression driver.
Ideally you'd cross a 15" by 800hz which would require probably 20" wide horn, and also maybe a 1.4" or 2" compression driver.
You can run a compression driver below horn loading...
 
Back
Top Bottom