• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Budget coax vs 2way | no free space on the sides of the desktop.

neifle

Member
Joined
Jul 13, 2024
Messages
38
Likes
31
Hi.
I’d like to ask for advice on choosing budget-friendly speakers for my desk setup—a 42“ monitor in the center and 27” monitors on either side. I can’t position the speakers at ear level; the only option is to place them above my ears, about 30–40 cm higher, and angle them toward my ears. So my question is: should I go for two-way speakers in my case? I’d like to place the speakers on their sides, but then two-way speakers would lose their sound directivity. Am I thinking this through correctly?
My options include: MR3, JBL 104, KEF Egg 1st gen, some KEF home theater speakers with aluminum enclosures, and maybe the Tannoy Arena.
Subwoofer: Cambridge Megaworks 250D
ADAU1701
A small, square room.
 
I'm not following the 2-way speakers point.
Or the problem about angling speakers.
 
I'm not following the 2-way speakers point.
Or the problem about angling speakers.
The speakers will be mounted quite high up and tilted at an angle of about 30 degrees. Will that be a problem?
 
No.
If you try it and it's a total sonic disaster, change the angle back.
 
I've no idea why this seems so critical, but I'd just try different positions angles or whatever and see what sounds OK. It's just a desk setup! It's not as if your head is clamped into a millimetre-perfect position when in front of the PC....
 
I mean, Is there any reason why a coaxial speaker might be the best choice in this configuration? (The speakers are positioned 50 cm above my ears, 70 cm away, angled outward at 30 degrees, and pointing downward) The goal is to avoid a sweet spot that’s only 10 cm wide, so the soundstage doesn’t disappear if I decide to sit differently in my chair. I’m also checking out the Creative Pebble Nova - has anyone had a chance to listen to it yet?
 
I've no idea why this seems so critical, but I'd just try different positions angles or whatever and see what sounds OK. It's just a desk setup! It's not as if your head is clamped into a millimetre-perfect position when in front of the PC....
for me it's crucial not to lose the soundstage when moving my head within a range of 50–60 cm
 
You probably need "less beaming" speakers.
If you are only 50-60cm away you're going to need a head-clamp to maintain the right position!
 
@neifle You haven't mentioned a budget and a picture of your setup would give us more of an idea of your placement constraints.

For example, I have iLoud MTMs, mounted with the tweeters at ear height, either side of a 34" UWQHD screen, with a 15" laptop to the left and an 18" screen to the right...

IMG_20260327_172651254 (Small).jpg


Getting the tweeters to ear height is preferable as the optimal plane for the speakers is then parallel to the floor. Most of your head movement will also be in a plane parallel to the floor and lining up these planes gives you the greatest latitude for head movement.
 
Last edited:
"gives you the greatest you the greatest latitude for head movement." - move your head? Are you crazy? :)
 
I use Genelec 8010a mounted on arms. Requires no desk space.
 
@neifle You haven't mentioned a budget and a picture of your setup would give us more of an idea of your placement constraints.

For example, I have iLoud MTMs, mounted with the tweeters at ear height, either side of a 34" UWQHD screen, with a 15" laptop to the left and an 18" screen to the right...

View attachment 560197

Getting the tweeters to ear height is preferable as the optimal plane for the speakers is then parallel to the floor. Most of your head movement will also be in a plane parallel to the floor and lining up these planes gives you the greatest latitude for head movement.
1790069773467.png
 
Kali IN-UNF might be a good option...


You could sit the satellites on a VESA mount shelf like this...


(This one is now wide enough, so you'd need to extend it with a wooden plank or similar)

Actually, this one fits a wider range of VESA sizes...

 
Kali IN-UNF might be a good option...


You could sit the satellites on a VESA mount shelf like this...


(This one is now wide enough, so you'd need to extend it with a wooden plank or similar)

Actually, this one fits a wider range of VESA sizes...

Yes, I was thinking about in-unf 2 years ago, but no space behind screen for bass module at all.
 
First off: placing the speakers high up isn't the real issue for your soundstage.
The actual bottleneck here is your extremely short 70cm listening distance.

You mentioned being worried about losing the soundstage when moving your head 50–60 cm.
It's a timing issue, not a directivity issue: When you sit that close (70cm), moving your head even 20–30 cm to the side drastically changes the time it takes for the sound to reach your left vs. right ear. The speaker you move closer to will sound louder and arrive earlier, which breaks the phantom center effect = soundstage effect. A coax speaker won't fix this. This breakdown happens at short distances purely due to arrival time, no matter the speaker design.

Keep in mind that the stereo image and soundstage will always play out on a direct line between the two tweeters. Since your speakers are 50cm higher than your ears, your soundstage is also up there. If you're cool with that acoustically, go for it.

While coax options like the KEF Eggs or Tannoy Arenas sound great on paper as point-sources, a traditional 2-way design is almost always the better choice in this budget tier:
Coax drivers in budget setups usually lack cabinet volume and cone area. Standard 2-way speakers will give you much better extension down to your crossover point.
Designing a good coax driver is expensive. At lower price points, a 2-way speaker will simply give you better component quality and cleaner overall sound for the same budget.

Since you have to mount them high, place the 2-way speakers upside down (tweeters on the bottom, woofers on top) and just above the monitors. This gets the tweeters as close to your actual ear level as possible. Your brain can't easily localize low frequencies anyway, so it doesn't matter that the woofers are up top. Tilt them down 30 degrees to aim the tweeters right at your ears.

Look at the Kali Audio LP-6 v2. They have a decent waveguide that gives you a much wider, more forgiving sweet spot (in this case, sweet spot means the area before the frequency response changes much, not the area of the phantom effect). Plus, they have dip-switches on the back specifically designed to correct the EQ when you place speakers in weird positions (like high up on a wall or desk shelf).

Or check out these recommendations (best speaker for different budgets). https://www.audiosciencereview.com/...-recommendations-for-usa-by-sweetchaos.28269/
 
I use Genelec 8010a mounted on arms. Requires no desk space.
Are you mad? Don't your arms start to ache? How do you type?
If you attached a metal bar to both speakers, your head could take some of the weight, and you'd have big headphones. :)
 
....In fact I use wall brackets that swivel and tilt. :)
 
Back
Top Bottom