• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Blu-ray is dying…

Unfortunately true of the 2ch mix.
The 5.1 is much better.

Log filefoobar2000 1.3.2 / Dynamic Range Meter 1.1.1
log date: 2015-03-09 20:38:47

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Analyzed: Dire Straits / Brothers In Arms
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DR Peak RMS Duration Track
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DR13 0.00 dB -15.02 dB 5:11 01-So Far Away
DR12 0.00 dB -15.02 dB 8:26 02-Money For Nothing
DR10 0.00 dB -12.81 dB 4:13 03-Walk Of Life
DR11 0.00 dB -14.02 dB 6:34 04-Your Latest Trick
DR13 0.00 dB -15.82 dB 8:31 05-Why Worry
DR13 0.00 dB -15.79 dB 6:58 06-Ride Across The River
DR11 0.00 dB -15.31 dB 4:40 07-The Man's Too Strong

Number of tracks: 9
Official DR value: DR12

Samplerate: 96000 Hz
Channels: 6
Bits per sample: 24
Bitrate: 7702 kbps
Codec: FLAC
Just for info, my original 1985 cd,
foobar2000 v2.26.1 / DR Meter v1.0.8
log date: 2026-11-03 23:31:44

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Analyzed: Dire Straits / Brothers In Arms (CD)
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

DR Peak RMS Duration Track
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DR20 -2.00 dBFS -23.86 dBFS 5:12 01-01 - So Far Away
DR18 -2.00 dBFS -22.62 dBFS 8:26 02-02 - Money for Nothing
DR13 -6.98 dBFS -22.62 dBFS 4:12 03-03 - Walk of Life
DR14 -9.61 dBFS -27.12 dBFS 6:34 04-04 - Your Latest Trick
DR13 -14.86 dBFS -30.84 dBFS 8:31 05-05 - Why Worry
DR17 -4.78 dBFS -25.27 dBFS 6:58 06-06 - Ride Across the River
DR14 -5.21 dBFS -24.75 dBFS 4:40 07-07 - The Man's Too Strong
DR18 -2.95 dBFS -23.49 dBFS 3:41 08-08 - One World
DR15 -6.95 dBFS -26.21 dBFS 6:59 09-09 - Brothers in Arms
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Number of tracks: 9
Official DR value: DR16

Samplerate: 44100 Hz
Channels: 2
Bits per sample: 16
Bitrate: 648 kbps
Codec: FLAC
================================================================================
 
I have a BDP 93 since 2011 and a UDP 205 since 2017. I will never part with them. Old school physical media owner. over 1,000 CDs, at least 100 SACDs, and 100 Blu rays plus. Have added at least 3 dozen 4Ks as well.
LOL I have collected media for a long time, but with vinyl, too (and you're ahead of me on SACD, I'm ahead of you on the cds/blurays let alone dvds :) ).
 
Last edited:
Synchronicity at play for me today. I first discovered this issue earlier today when YouTube offered a video by Cheap Audio Man who pointed out that Blu-ray is dying (CD Fans! You Need to Know What Sony Just Did). So I started researching Blu-ray players to figure out what I should buy before it is too late... and then I saw this thread.

So ASR people: what should I buy?

Given the following context:
  • I don't own much (if any) Blu-ray content; maybe a movie / concert video or two
  • We currently have a PS4 that we can use for Blu-ray — but I won't have that in my audio system 3+ years from now.
  • The Blu-ray player will be connected digitally to an AVR system (i.e., transport) and a modern TV with robust upscaling capabilities — so the Blu-ray player's internal DAC / DSP quality is not relevant, nor is it's upscaling capability.
  • What is important is that I can fire it up in five- or even ten years, and it will still be able to load a disk, read it, and send the content out in digital format... supporting all common formats and encodings that are found on DVDs and Blu-ray recordings.
So really, this is a purchase to provide decent long-term legacy format coverage for anythe future, on those very few occasions where I might need it. Not something super cheap that won't hold up over the years... but I also do not need to pay premium for "cinematic experience".
 
Only reliable long term solution is to take the media off the disk and put it on your own storage.
100% agree. But that doesn't address that time when a friend brings over a movie, when I borrow a concert video from the library, etc.

My focus are the (rare) times in the future when we happen to have a physical slug to be played at that moment in time.
 
100% agree. But that doesn't address that time when a friend brings over a movie, when I borrow a concert video from the library, etc.

My focus are the (rare) times in the future when we happen to have a physical slug to be played at that moment in time.

I am of no help on that one. Last time my friend brought over a blu ray, I had no idea there had been a newer version of blu ray released that doesn't work in my player. So we had to download the movie...
 
I am of no help on that one. Last time my friend brought over a blu ray, I had no idea there had been a newer version of blu ray released that doesn't work in my player. So we had to download the movie...
Does the player have an update available?
 
@rcstevensonaz - I would recommend a Panasonic UB820

It’s the most reliable of the players on the market in my experience. They don’t last forever, but if you’re not watching that many discs, you’ll be okay for a good long while.
I recommend it too, it seems to be good enough for its price.
IMG_20261023_185611_111.jpg
 
Synchronicity at play for me today. I first discovered this issue earlier today when YouTube offered a video by Cheap Audio Man who pointed out that Blu-ray is dying (CD Fans! You Need to Know What Sony Just Did). So I started researching Blu-ray players to figure out what I should buy before it is too late... and then I saw this thread.

So ASR people: what should I buy?

Given the following context:
  • I don't own much (if any) Blu-ray content; maybe a movie / concert video or two
  • We currently have a PS4 that we can use for Blu-ray — but I won't have that in my audio system 3+ years from now.
  • The Blu-ray player will be connected digitally to an AVR system (i.e., transport) and a modern TV with robust upscaling capabilities — so the Blu-ray player's internal DAC / DSP quality is not relevant, nor is it's upscaling capability.
  • What is important is that I can fire it up in five- or even ten years, and it will still be able to load a disk, read it, and send the content out in digital format... supporting all common formats and encodings that are found on DVDs and Blu-ray recordings.
So really, this is a purchase to provide decent long-term legacy format coverage for anythe future, on those very few occasions where I might need it. Not something super cheap that won't hold up over the years... but I also do not need to pay premium for "cinematic experience".
Well I am in a very different situation as I own over 2500 BluRay movies and over 700 4K UHD Movies, plus 400 Multichannel SACD and at least 500 CD so I need players to last several decades so that I can continue to enjoy my physical media!

Fortunately, I have several 4K Universal players an OPPO UDP-205, a Sony UBX-800M2 and just grabed a Sony UBX-700U.
 
Fortunately, I have several 4K Universal players an OPPO UDP-205, a Sony UBX-800M2 and just grabed a Sony UBX-700U.
Just in case;




JSmith
 
Blu-Ray was a cash grab and extension of geo blocking. The improvement in picture quality didn't matter to most people but the prospect of re-buying titles you already had on DVD and the possibility (often realised) that the Blu-Ray would refuse to play because of the "protections" built into the format made it a lame duck from the outset. I have over 300 DVD's but only four or five Blu-Ray titles it's a technology that I can watch fade away without any sympathy.

DVD region blocks exist too, infact it’s more aggressive.
 
DVD region blocks exist too, infact it’s more aggressive.
DVD was very aggressive about it. I have a large number of blu-rays that are region free and I don't think any of my 4K discs have region locking. I have two DVD players that are hacked for region free, but haven't needed it for blu-ray.
 
  • Like
Reactions: EJ3
Also I read Krovatar is releasing a KBU-500 soon!

 
Two things I’ve observed:

The sound quality of blue-ray was unmistakably better.

But upscaling makes DVDs look pretty good on a 55 inch TV. Good enough to make the extra expense of Blue ray questionable.

I “own” some streaming movies that I also have on DVD, and I prefer the DVD version.
I'm in the opposite boat regarding picture quality. I've been collecting and watching Blu-Ray for 20 years and 4K for 10. I still have a handful of DVDs (that do not yet have a Blu-Ray release) and watching them is painful on my Panasonic 820 and 55" LG OLED. The difference between an uspcaled DVD and a Blu-Ray on a modern TV is night and day to me.

However, the difference between Blu-Ray and 4K oftentimes is not that immediately noticeable but it all depends on the source disc and how the HDR/DV grade is done. I definitely have some Blu-Rays that I won't be updating because the 4K version has poor HDR/DV or a bad encode.
 
I'm in the opposite boat regarding picture quality. I've been collecting and watching Blu-Ray for 20 years and 4K for 10. I still have a handful of DVDs (that do not yet have a Blu-Ray release) and watching them is painful on my Panasonic 820 and 55" LG OLED. The difference between an uspcaled DVD and a Blu-Ray on a modern TV is night and day to me.

However, the difference between Blu-Ray and 4K oftentimes is not that immediately noticeable but it all depends on the source disc and how the HDR/DV grade is done. I definitely have some Blu-Rays that I won't be updating because the 4K version has poor HDR/DV or a bad encode.
This is my experience. Blu-ray was a leap from DVD. 4K was a slight step up. I rarely ever bother upgrading a blu-ray to 4K. DVDs are certainly watchable, but compared to a blu-ray the upgrade is always clear. I still own a lot of DVDs. Many of them are older movies that haven't gotten an HD release and maybe never will.
 
I'm in the opposite boat regarding picture quality. I've been collecting and watching Blu-Ray for 20 years and 4K for 10. I still have a handful of DVDs (that do not yet have a Blu-Ray release) and watching them is painful on my Panasonic 820 and 55" LG OLED. The difference between an uspcaled DVD and a Blu-Ray on a modern TV is night and day to me.

However, the difference between Blu-Ray and 4K oftentimes is not that immediately noticeable but it all depends on the source disc and how the HDR/DV grade is done. I definitely have some Blu-Rays that I won't be updating because the 4K version has poor HDR/DV or a bad encode.
I would agree that there is an objective difference in picture quality, but it isn’t important to me.

I just don’t watch much TV or many movies. When I was younger I watched maybe two movies a year in theaters.

I can’t remember the last movie I watched in a theater.

I can’t recall any recent movies that interested me.
 
I'm in the opposite boat regarding picture quality. I've been collecting and watching Blu-Ray for 20 years and 4K for 10. I still have a handful of DVDs (that do not yet have a Blu-Ray release) and watching them is painful on my Panasonic 820 and 55" LG OLED. The difference between an uspcaled DVD and a Blu-Ray on a modern TV is night and day to me.

However, the difference between Blu-Ray and 4K oftentimes is not that immediately noticeable but it all depends on the source disc and how the HDR/DV grade is done. I definitely have some Blu-Rays that I won't be updating because the 4K version has poor HDR/DV or a bad encode.
Or (for some strange reason) the 4K audio is not as good.
 
Back
Top Bottom