• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

best bookshelf speakers for reverberant listening room

azimuth

New Member
Joined
Jul 24, 2020
Messages
2
Likes
1
Goodmorning everyone. I write from Italy and follow this precious forum with interest; I am grateful for the enormous commitment invested by those who administer it and by the most assiduous collaborators.

I would like to install a hi-fi system in the living room, which is a room of about 27 square meters, with an open, irregular (non-parallel opposite) and reverberating shape, which has a 3.20 m high ceiling and which has a wooden floor and ceiling. This is a challenge, also because I am not willing to make an invasive passive acoustic correction (at the moment the reverberation time is around 0.8 seconds but I plan to improve it with carpet and some absorbent panels); however, I am aware that I will have to accept compromises on the acoustic result. I prefer different musical genres, generally not very dynamic, and I particularly appreciate an adequate restitution of the voices, as well as of the instruments.

My idea is to buy the Lyngdorf TDAI 3400 all-in-one, in order to take advantage of its active correction system and to have high power. Initially I would use Tidal and listen to my CD collection, converted lossless to digital, reserving a possible insertion of a cd player.

As for the speakers, my idea is to buy bookshelf speakers, with a list price of up to $ 6,000, with a frequency response that (prudentially) does not drop below about 55 kHz, then empirically checking for compatibility environmental with the insertion of a subwoofer.

I am considering one of these options (some I have already listened to):
- Q Acoustic 300 Concept
- Revel M 106
- Fostex GX100 BJ

Do you think that in relation to the size of the environment and its volume, the listening room can be adequately sounded with these speakers, even at medium listening volumes? Beyond the subjective preferences related to listening, do you think that some options are preferable, or that there are alternatives to consider?
Thank you
 
If the room is very reverberant, have you considered speakers with narrow directivity to reduce the total amount of early reflections? And/or the Geddes approach to speaker placement? (Page 9ff. of this paper)
 
Narrow directivity speakers are fine and smooth directivity is always desirable but why try to reduce reverberations so much? If the off-axis response is good, any speaker should sound great in your space, right? If this is truly the goal, narrow directivity surely is the way as @ttimer said.

The only other recommendation I have would be to stick with speakers that ASR has recommended and reviewed (or alternatively those few manufacturers with valid measurements) or close cousins to those speakers. That way you have a good idea of what you are going to get at least in terms of measured response, considering narrow directivity may be one of your goals here. Revels certainly fit the bill here but also Genelec, Neumann, KEF R3, Dutch & Dutch, Technics SB-C700, Buchardt, JBL.
 
Thank you for the useful suggestions, which I will evaluate carefully
 
Back
Top Bottom