• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Battle of RCA Cables: Mogami, Amazon, Monoprice

I've been servicing a turntable setup for a friend. The accessories market for turntables is outrageously overpriced. One unit looks like it was made in a garage. PCBs look like they were designed using an Etch-A-Sketch. It's difficult to deprogram anyone who believes in that stuff.

Remember the J Keny DAC?
 
Well crimping can be very good, but it's easy to botch it so it becomes unreliable. Much easier to do a good job that lasts forever with soldering.
I've never felt comfortable with only crimping a connector. Maybe more conststent results are achieved in an industrial environment.
 
I've never felt comfortable with only crimping a connector. Maybe more conststent results are achieved in an industrial environment.
Yeah it has to be done right, then it's even better than soldering especially for high current applications where solder joints would just melt away.

Ofc that's irrelevant for audio use. No reason to bother when you're not even sure you can do it properly.

Nevertheless there's a certain audiophiles subset who swear by it. So superior, look, the industry uses it too... :facepalm:
 
Reminds me of this nonsense about crimped signal cables being oh so superior to soldered ones, which is of the devil. Nevermind the signal going through over 9000 tiny solder joints in the devices :D
Crimped connections are superior to solder. Not in any way that makes any difference for audio signals, as long as the connection isn't faulty.
Well crimping can be very good, but it's easy to botch it so it becomes unreliable. Much easier to do a good job that lasts forever with soldering.
Nah, solder joints are mechanically weak and even easier to botch.
 
Nah, solder joints are mechanically weak and even easier to botch.
Not when done at home. You need a perfect process with a good tool, the correct die and proper connector for every wire gauge you intend to crimp. I've also both crimped and soldered so there's more surface area making contact. Soldering works pretty well and fills the gaps. I don't remember having a soldering joint that failed.
 
Crimped connections are superior to solder. Not in any way that makes any difference for audio signals, as long as the connection isn't faulty.

Nah, solder joints are mechanically weak and even easier to botch.
Odd, all the broken cables I had over the decades had the actual cable breaking off right after the solder joint, a typical mechanical failure point. Not once did the joint itself fail. It really is easy to get right. Since when is proper soldering difficult? Of course we're not talking about half-slavery work under bad time and quota pressure with the supervisor breathing down your neck.
 
Odd, all the broken cables I had over the decades had the actual cable breaking off right after the solder joint, a typical mechanical failure point. Not once did the joint itself fail. It really is easy to get right. Since when is proper soldering difficult? Of course we're not talking about half-slavery work under bad time and quota pressure with the supervisor breathing down your neck.
:p Good is good and Bad is bad. LOL.. Solder should never be used where the connection is exposed to any flexing, it's brittle and will break. OTOH a solder joint that remains rigid seals the connection from air and oxidation. When I have the choice I'll crimp and then solder. Worse are the friction connections as used for every plug and cord in audio. :facepalm:
 
I think there are other parameters to consider that measuring instruments currently can't detect
Ah - the old "things we can't measure"

This is of course nonsense. Audio signals are amongst the simplest electrical phenomana to measure. Low frequency single dimensional voltage with time. We've been doing it for about 150 years.

No there is nothing we can hear that cannot be measured. Our measurement instruments are many times more sensitive than our ears.
 
Done properly, crimping is mechanically superior to soldering. For audio purposes, an excellent solder joint measures and sounds the same as an excellent crimp joint.

Years ago we had to decommission and totally replace a studio suite that has been in use for several years. All the solder joints on the (complex) wiring loom started failing at the same time. Every time we moved a panel 3 to 5 wires fell off, to access these we had to move another panel and another handful of wires fell off.

Although this is an extreme example, large complex wiring looms with solder joints can become quite "delicate" after a few years.
 
Done properly, crimping is mechanically superior to soldering. For audio purposes, an excellent solder joint measures and sounds the same as an excellent crimp joint.

Years ago we had to decommission and totally replace a studio suite that has been in use for several years. All the solder joints on the (complex) wiring loom started failing at the same time. Every time we moved a panel 3 to 5 wires fell off, to access these we had to move another panel and another handful of wires fell off.

Although this is an extreme example, large complex wiring looms with solder joints can become quite "delicate" after a few years.
This seems to be very extreme. Since 6 decades I solder and got vintage equipment to restore. Never had a solder joint which opened by itself. Of course I still use lead solder which also the military did and partly does.
 
This seems to be very extreme. Since 6 decades I solder and got vintage equipment to restore. Never had a solder joint which opened by itself. Of course I still use lead solder which also the military did and partly does.
This was a large studio installation. Three hundred plus individual soldered connections in large tied-together loom bundled. All would have been built in the late 70s or early 80s using lead solder. A similar studio built at roughly the same time didn't suffer this failure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SSS
This was a large studio installation. Three hundred plus individual soldered connections in large tied-together loom bundled. All would have been built in the late 70s or early 80s using lead solder. A similar studio built at roughly the same time didn't suffer this failure.
The fat, heavy bundle of cable was hanging onto the solder joints? If so, small wonder when there's no strain relief.
 
The fat, heavy bundle of cable was hanging onto the solder joints? If so, small wonder when there's no strain relief.
No it was installed by professional wiremen with proper bend radius, tied back to a support frame and strain-relief support given where needed.

The problem was simply that the solder joints started OK and became brittle over several years. It was one of several studios, none of the others failed this way. It was as if there was a chemical interaction, but nothing different was done in this particular build. It was a mystery.
 
No it was installed by professional wiremen with proper bend radius, tied back to a support frame and strain-relief support given where needed.

The problem was simply that the solder joints started OK and became brittle over several years. It was one of several studios, none of the others failed this way. It was as if there was a chemical interaction, but nothing different was done in this particular build. It was a mystery.
Interesting. You see, from this weird concoction with a dozen of unknown unconventional methods used, to generally condemning soldering as bad bad, that's a long way and more than a bit of a stretch, wouldn't you say?
 
Interesting. You see, from this weird concoction with a dozen of unknown unconventional methods used, to generally condemning soldering as bad bad, that's a long way and more than a bit of a stretch, wouldn't you say?
Sure. I don't think solder is bad. My anecdote was about a very weird situation which certainly does not prove solder is generally bad.

I do however have a great deal of experience of very large studio installations and previously sound solder joints fail randomly all the time.

I guess all of us have experienced a design where a connector breaks off from a PCB because a designer assumed a solder joint was strong enough to survive cable weight or frequent use. Solder is not mechanically strong.
 
For cables, I think there are other parameters to consider that measuring instruments currently can't detect
We're sorry as well.


And, re solder, I get WELDED Blue Jean cables for belt-and-suspenders (superfluous) reasons.
 
I understand that those fuses have a polarity, and must be installed in the correct direction for best results.
This would depend whether one was in the Northern or Southern hemisphere. If in the Northern hemisphere, prioritise for installation the 'up' end. Conversely, in Southern hemisphere installs, privilege the 'down' end.
If you get this wrong, nothing you can do with speakers, positioning, EQ or room treatment will have any remedial effect.
 
Ever talk to Ted Denney from Synergistic Research? I have, about 30 years ago. I didn't believe him then but I still believed other audiophile myths. Ted is a master BS artist. I mean like that Scientology guru. I can't understand how he's still in business after all these years.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom