• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Audiophile reviewer idiocy & insanity - A collection

gzost

Senior Member
Forum Donor
Joined
Mar 17, 2018
Messages
317
Likes
907
I frequently come across bits in audiophile equipment reviews or other articles that are real WTF moments. These are claims or deductions that go beyond the usual adherence to the weird dogmas of audiophilia and reach levels of credulity or show an absence of logical thinking that can still shock me.

Some of that gets touched upon in the various threads on snake oil, but most do not really fit there. It is the reviewer that is the focus, not the gear.

This thread is intended for collecting these bits for the delectation of all here. A brief comment will make sense in most cases, but there can very well be howlers that can stand on their own.
 
We already have this:

 
Not the best example of the category, but something I came across earlier today, in a review of third party vibration isolation speaker footers:

"There is also a hexagonal insert at the end of the threaded shaft for using an Allen wrench to make micro-adjustments for speaker alignment with laser pointers. I've watched Val Cora make such adjustments when he delivered the Acora speakers, and it can sonically take a speaker to the next level if you know how to do it."

So this is about the most minute vertical changes which will easily get swamped by normal changes in the user's seating height (e.g. sitting more or less straight). If these really can "take a speaker to the next level" then I look forward to the introduction of audiophile head vices.
 
We already have this:

I am a regular reader and occasional contributor to that thread. To me that is about devices, not about reviewer failures.
 
The best of the esoteric crazy fest are already here:

 
After the last couple of years I’ve spent reorienting myself by intensively reading this site, Floyd Toole’s Sound Reproduction book, Erin’s Audio Corner reviews, trying to understand room correction and Spinorama tests and using EQ intelligently, etc., I’m now responding to huge swathes of unsupported subjective claims elsewhere in online audio commentary with a new level of skepticism. Claims of connoisseur expertise based solely on being an overconfident hyper-consumer who buys many, many headphones or amps or cables or whatnot no longer impress me much if measurements and objective evidence are entirely absent.

For me there’s still a place for consumerist reviewing that offers useful descriptions of features, design, functionality, and impressions of sound. It helps if blatant audiophile shibboleths and fallacies regarding price=quality, parroting of marketing-speak, and golden-eared trained-listener preening are not front and center.

Personally I don’t have much of a taste for focusing on the worst subjective pseudo-technical aspects of all this by deploying Extremely Online invective about “idiocy & insanity” and snake oil and “shilling.” On one level it’s like shooting fish in a barrel — there’s just too much of it. On another level there’s the risk of responding to one form of audio tribalism with another, different, equally self-complacent kind of tribalism.
 
Back
Top Bottom