Audio Science Review is not listed @ Wikipedia.

[AdamG]

All for it. Will give us new Trolls to sort out but net should be positive.

 

[JSmith]

What say you?

JSmith

 

[amirm]

So do we have any current members with knowledge of how to create the page?

 

[DLS79]

So do we have any current members with knowledge of how to create the page?

I've never done it, but wiki has a page about how to do it.

Wikipedia:How to create a page - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[Audiofire]

Go to the MQA wiki article, click on Edit and search for "Audio Science Review" - add double brackets around like [[Audio Science Review]], then publish changes. A new link will be created for Audio Science Review.

First, we need more independent sources with editorial process (self-published forum posts and online videos are not enough for a new wiki article). Amir has made interviews published on YouTube, but we would need more interviews published in media with editorial control, such as online newspapers or magazines. Secondary, reliable sources are well-regarded for creating a wiki page.

Wikipedia:Reliable sources - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia:No original research - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

 

[amirm]

Here is the link to my paper on AES: https://www.aes.org/e-lib/browse.cfm?elib=22278
This is the AES paper that references ASR for headphone target: https://www.aes.org/e-lib/browse.cfm?elib=22281

AES paper proposals are peer reviewed before acceptance.

This is Sean Olive's paper that references ASR headphone testing: https://www.listeninc.com/wp/media/Perception_and_-Measurement_of_Headphones_Sean_Olive.pdf

I am hoping for a one paragraph entry, we don't need more references than above.

 

[LTig]

When the English page is ready I volunteer to create the German page.

 

[Audiofire]

"Non-notable website. No significant coverage."

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audio Science Review - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia:Notability - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia:What is significant coverage? - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Publish the draft that was rejected if you want, it could be rejected again:

Audio Science Review is not listed @ Wikipedia.

ASR, September 17...three days ago ... highest so far.

audiosciencereview.com

 

[LTig]

"Non-notable website. No significant coverage."

Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Audio Science Review - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia:Notability - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Wikipedia:What is significant coverage? - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org

Publish the draft that was rejected if you want, it could be rejected again:

Audio Science Review is not listed @ Wikipedia.

ASR, September 17...three days ago ... highest so far.

audiosciencereview.com

Maybe the page needs to look like the one for Hydrogenaudio. Add some reference links to our well known experts and Scientist.

 

[LeShog]

I'd be happy to make the italian page once the english one is ready.

Also @amirm this would be perfect for uncyclopedia

I will get it started for you as far as draft text and you all can post it on the Wiki:

Overview
ASR stands for Audio for Superior Religion. It was founded by AmirM, the God of Audio, as he is known in many circles (but not audio related). He was born in year 2000 but in order to be taken seriously, he pretends he is much older. He still lives in his parents house. Good thing they have a large garage because that is where he does his most serious work. He has been written up in all kinds of magazines (again, not audio related). He is known to hire the worst moderators to back up his angry attitude when people tell him he is no longer as good looking as he is.

The ASR forum includes many people in his own image: a bunch of vegetarians who eat steak when no one is looking. Sadly not all are as good looking as him so they hide behind avatars and aliases for their own protection.

The site has grown beyond his wildest imagination. Not because there is anything good in it but because his imagination is way too small.

The type of stuff he tests on the site comprise of audio equipment, engine oil and agricultural products (not all true). He uses stupid graphs to make stuff look good even though most of them aren't (citation needed).

Finally, he is looking for someone to run the site so that he can just sit back and order that person around (no citation needed for this as it is obvious).

History
No one knows why Amir got the urge to start the site. Some say he was too lonely and needed a companion. Since no real person would play that role, he decided to create a forum and make up a bunch of imaginary "members" to post there to make him look popular.

The alternate theory is that he is money hungry as evidenced by constant pleas for donations at the end of his reviews regardless of whether the review has any value whatsoever. He has not provided public records of his tax returns (he is the first and only forum owner to be so situated). He says he is being audited but it is a safe bet that he doesn't have enough money to be of interested to the government.