Point taken. But the distortion can't cause corrupt results, it just shows that the thing differentiating the DACs is not distortion. Which I don't think anyone believed it to be. I tried to read up on what people said about A/S about distortion, but it's a 65-page thread and I couldn't figure out a by-thread comment search.Then they shouldn't attempt to cross religions and use our methods of controlled testing. Their idea was to prove their point using our means as to it being credible. In that sense, we do get to show evidence that could cause corrupt results.
I did find this comment from Josh, though:
I did some basic measurements with Multitone to check whether the box was affecting A differently from B. The FR was untouched. The box seemed to add some distortion, but it was equal between A and B. I mentioned the Multitone 32 numbers in this ASR post, which I screenshotted earlier in this thread.
Once I knew it was equal between A and B, my concern was that any noise added by the box would make it harder to pass the test. Indeed, I didn’t think the DACs sounded as “good” through the box, but I can’t separate that from the fact that ABX tests aren’t exactly as “fun” as normal listening.
So he was never hiding the ball re: distortion. IMO the FR differences are too slight to account for the positive result. So far the only damning thing is the differences in relay sound. And that's just your word against his. For the record I believe you.