Amir already did that
some pages ago and his comment was that he heard day and night difference.
Hence the revival of the thread.
Thanks for providing a embarrassing (for me) example of what I railed against: 'forgetting (or not reading) what happened here a week ago'.
Perhaps you or he can help me through Amir's post there.
Amir's
listening signal chain, as best I can glean, was
AudioPrecision (AP) analyzer/signal generator optical out ---> DAC optical in---> DAC RCA out ---> AVA RCA in -->AVA RCA Out --> A90 headphone amp--> 'random IEM'
The
measuring signal chain would attach the measuring device to either the same AVA RCA out or A90 amp's headphone out.
AIUI, the AVA ABX box has a built-in level matching feature, using trims and a numerical display. Amir used the trim control on AVA to "get them to match to about 0.07 dB which was achieved with trim level of 90 vs 99" (99 on the AVA being 'max level' i.e. no trim). He then listened to white noise via a headphone amp and IEMs. He heard a whacking big night and day difference beween A and B right away! Then with a 1 kHz tone, still different: the 99 trim sounds louder than the 90. Same result if done blind: it seems AVA level matching sucks!
Then: "I try many different methods to measure the output of the AVA from AP to digital voltmeter. They all show that fraction of dB difference [presumably, ~0.07dB]. No way am I hear[ing] that slight difference so clearly." [Which is all little hard for nontechnician me to parse. Did it mean: I tried many different measuring
devices, ranging from an AP analyzer to a digital voltmeter (DMM)? Or was it, I tried measuring many different
parameters, using an AP and a DMM? Or something else meant by
methods? But this is a side-issue]
Amir then wonders if the culprit was the AVA box's output impedence changing with trim setting. This could have audible effects but be
objectively masked by the AP's and a digital multimeter's own large default impedences (100 k Ohm and 1M+ Ohm , respectively). And voila, when he lowers that to 600 Ohms, he now can see (shown in a graph of output impedence vs frequency) that there's a considerably higher impedence for the AVA output at a 90 trim (~8.6 k ohm) than the one with 'no' (99) trim (~5.3 k ohm). It also damningly shows that output impedence varies with *frequency*, and
differently so, between trims, with the 90 trim having much stronger impedence dropoff at higher frequencies that the 99 trim does.
tl;dr: using AVA's level matching could actually
cause an audible difference, especially in the high frequencies. (NB the graph does not measure 'audibility' in dB per se)
The A90 headphone amp input has a 10 k Ohm impedence, so there's likely to be 'big time interaction' between it and the AVA box, too. It won't be fully masking the output impedience difference. But what is its actual effect?
When Amir sets AVA trims based on the A90 headphone amp's output, they're now set to 99 vs 96, and the A and B outputs are now 'audibly very close'. I presume this judgement used the 1 kHz tone, sighted. Amir knows that 'level matching' two outputs that vary in 'EQ' -- e.g. at high frequencies -- as well as in overall level isn't precisely possible without an equalizer. He notes that he needs to go back and try the white noise signal to see if the 'high frequency impact' specifically has lessened with amp-output-based level matching. (Don't know if he did that, and no relevant measurements shown at this point in his post -- yet.)
He then compares this all to what Josh did to level-match:
-- Josh first level matched via AVA trims using a 1 kHz tone and pink (not white) noise and checked/measured the results at the AVA RCA output with a digital multimeter --> Amir says Josh's voltmeter would have an input impedence >1 M ohm, and we now know this would badly mislead the user for 'level matching'.
-- Josh then checks the AVA's level matching at his headphone amp's output, by feeding his Benchmark HPA4 amp's headphone output into a E1DA Cosmos ADC and then digital out into REW using the same signals (1 kHz and pink noise). [NB, this seems rather over complicated, to me, compared to what Amir did.]
-- Josh even repeats the latter with the output of a different amp, the Benchmark LA4
The impedence of one or both of these amps is 50 K ohm, according to Amir, enough to still have a mismatch.
Given Amir's findings, Josh at this point
should have noticed that the AVA-'level matched' DACs he confirmed at AVA output with a multimeter were in fact NOT level matched at amp output, as measured by REW. But Josh did
not report that. Josh (Amir's quoting) only said that measuring at the amp out "
ensured the levels were equal at the output I’d be hearing", with no reference to the previous protocol's result. Nor measurements to demonstrate any of it (at least, none reported by Amir)
At this point Amir shows his AP's FR measurement (RMS level vs signal frequency) of the Topping D70 and Matrix MQA DACs, measured at AVA output (
not headphone output), when AVA trims are set to 90 and 99,
i.e., as he first heard the 'night and day' diffs on his IEMs at the top of his post. He says it shows "nearly 0.2 dB difference due to filter differences".
It
does show that differences, but I find this graph hard to interpret.
I see four colored lines (curves), two thick, two thin, DAC A being red, B purple. (There's also a mysteriously vertical purple line at 20 kHz). I'm not sure which lines are 'data' and which are 'cursors', and I don't see 'delta' (black). The y axis is labelled in 0.5 dB increments -- quite small increments. In thick lines I see there is a consistently very small difference - I would estimate this as quite less than 0.2 dB, closer to the 0.07 dB 'fraction of a difference" -- between A and B across most of the frequency range, growing larger (and crossing) above ~11 kHz. The thin lines seem to be separated by ~0.2bB and are virtually parallel...with a tiny change high up? I think these parallel lines would be the showing the 0.2dB difference Amir refers to? I feel stupid, I don't get the relationship between the thick and thin lines.
In any case, this would seem to be a graph indicating what would have been fed to Amir's headphone amp in his initial listening.
What has me scratching my stubble is, I'm not grokking where a 'night and day' difference heard 'so clearly', comes from, unless its that >11kHz diff, or something his amp did to the signal. Is a 0.2dB diff from 10Hz to 11 kHz otherwise really
night and day? I don't know. Haven't tried doing it. The difference does include the frequency range humans are most sensitive to.
Is this proposed as an explainer for what Amir heard at the start (and by extension for Josh's ridiculous 'successes'?)? But it's more or less what Amir would have
measured at the start, yes?(Or not?) Why was it so confounding
then as an explainer, if not now?
(and just to dot an 'i': Did Josh test a Topping D70s vs Matrix MQA DAC? I'll assume yes, though it wasn't explicit in Amir's post)