• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Audio by Van Alstine ABX Comparator Review

Thanks for testing, device is disappointing.

I wanted to make sure I was right so I invited my wife to come and listen.
Ok, but on ASR we should answer: ABX or it didn't happen. Why no ABX with hardware at hand?
 
He's hardly guilty, he just put his trust in a bad box. His original endeavour was to TRY to do proper ABX testing. It just didn't work. Now we know.
And the cash grab afterwards?
I can’t imagine the same scenario if any member of ASR had conducted and then published similar results.
Keith
 
The only thing that Josh should have done (and didn't) was to simply record the ABX test he did.
This is a simple recording from the output, he had perfectly capable gear that far exceeds what the box outputs.

It hasn't been done and (despite repeated requests also by Amir) and is the ONLY evidence that would be needed to verify what Josh heard.
This is passed station and basically means..
People who trust Josh and his test will trust the results.
Others that would have liked to see measurements simply continue to think the result is a fluke.
Box measurements cannot possibly confirm anything except quantify distortion and roll-off under the test circumstances.
 
Well ... I'm not surprised that I'm not surprised. Thanks for the review.

At the risk of asking a question that has alredy been addressed and of me being to stupid to run a proper forum search: GoldenSound has a video with a proper ABX test (that actually showed him being able to tell a difference between DACs).* In this test, he is using an ABX switching box, but somehow I didn't get whether this is comercially available. Is there any information about what this is?

* Actually, he was hearing the difference between two filters and the reason he was able to was because his hearing ability extended beyond 20 kHz, as he and Blaine discussed at the end of the video. Anyway, I didn't want my post to besome too long and I thought my link to the video explains what I mean anyway. But apparently not (see below), so I'm adding a few more words to explain.
 
Last edited:
Funny thing is that those guys at “Audiophile Style” forum are anxiously afraid of the possible effect of the DAC/ADC path, but they absolutely did not care about the s..t component like that abx box, that worsened the parameters about 100x. How typical for the audiophile approach, based on “trust your ears” method. Maybe Chris Connaker might explain.
 
Monetisation + charlatanism =. ‘computer audio’
Hardly a surprise.
Keith
 
Do you not trust his result?
It isn't about trust. Without a recording, it is Josh saying the switching sounded the same and Amir (and his wife!) saying it sounds different.

If Amir does not have time to do that, maybe the box can be passed on to someone to do the recording. Or maybe Erin @hardisj can do it with the comparator that he has. And then maybe this box can be sold to Chris or someone else at AS.
 
He's hardly guilty, he just put his trust in a bad box. His original endeavour was to TRY to do proper ABX testing. It just didn't work. Now we know.
I am sorry, but I do not agree. Any scientific method says - test your test equipment first. Any charlatan based method says try to cover everything into the mist and create a story. And that is exactly how it was done. Intentionally or based on lack of any knowledge, it makes no difference. And in fact I am not sure that in Josh’s case it was the former or later.
 
Well ... I'm not surprised that I'm not surprised. Thanks for the review.

At the risk of asking a question that has alredy been addressed and of me being to stupid to run a proper forum search: GoldenSound has a video with a proper ABX test (that actually showed him being able to tell a difference between DACs). In this test, he is using an ABX switching box, but somehow I didn't get whether this is comercially available. Is there any information about what this is?
That specific ABX test is not about DACs (clickbate title) but about 2 different filters.
He does have an AB box but is nor the same one.
 
Last edited:
The ABX test is not about DACs (clickbate title) but about 2 different filters.
He does have an AB box but is nor the same one.

Thanks. I corrected myself ;)

So ... Any word on that switching box he was using?
 
I am convinced that the results of Josh's testing are based on some kind of tell that the comparator box provides since they simply don't make sense in any way.

I don't think that this necessarily is the difference in the sound of the relay click. He used IEMs for the test, and that particular model (Moondrop S8) has above average isolation. Not sure how much of that click difference can be heard through that.

@amirm - Could you please record a brief comparison session with two DACs into a quality ADC and make this available? A recording of the clicks (e.g. using a UMIK or like from 1m away) would also be very useful.

PS: I just checked the audiophilestyle article to see if the result of the comparator test had been added and saw that my polite comment on that from directly after publication is still awaiting moderator approval.
 
Teardown see attached file
Thanks @amirm for the review

Thanks for the pictures.

I must say that if I were to spend US $1,300 for this unit (or whatever it cost when new) I'd be appalled to open it up and see this hot glue mess inside. Perhaps the assembler challenged themselves by wearing a blindfold and held the glue gun with their toes?

This is the sort of shit I expect to see in a product that comes free in a packet of cornflakes for god's sake!
1000033056.jpg


If I did own this unit I'd feel compelled to redo the LED mounts ASAP to an acceptable standard using something like the following. The result would be so much better than the totally unacceptable hot glue mess on offer here.

1000033060.jpg
 
Last edited:
In my opinion, you are realistically not listening to the DUT anymore when using this box. The comparator absolutely dominates the characteristics of the signal
As clear as night and day. Josh's results and supporting opinions are not worth considering.
 
I extracted the frequency response from the plots and determined the rough -0.1/-0.2/-0.5 dB points based on the nominal level for each volume determined in the range of 50-1000 Hz. The results look like this (rounded to 10 Hz):

Vol. 99Vol. 90Vol. 80
Nominal level (0.05-1 kHz)0.0043 dBr-1.1740 dBr-2.4369 dBr
-0.1 dB point15100 Hz9510 Hz7660 Hz
-0.2 dB point21420 Hz13620 Hz10880 Hz
-0.5 dB point35110 Hz22630 Hz17950 Hz

From what I remember, Josh said he did not use Volume settings lower than 90, so I would consider that the worst case for this specific test.

The just noticeable differences for changes in level for the full frequency range are on the order or 0.15 dB for music. For pink noise, the value is lower - some sources cite around 0.08 dB and I have passed a test with 0.1 dB using pink noise and just barely failed at 0.05 dB. So it's not out of the realm of possibilities that the change for Vol. 90 could be barely audible when compared to Vol. 99. However, that would not explain the successfull DAC ABX comparisons where bot DUTs were tested with the same comparator volume level and - from my perspective - such very small level differences would also not be sufficient to explain the extremely unusual statistical power of the results Josh presented (110 correct out of 112 = 98.2%).
 
Well, apparently not clear enough to distinguish between DAC + ABX and without ABX. Yet differences between DACs are night and day? :facepalm:
Look - testing with a piece of equipment like this is pointless. That is clear as night and day. All the further discussion and turmoil here is pointless.
 
Look - testing with a piece of equipment like this is pointless. That is clear as night and day. All the further discussion and turmoil here is pointless.
My point is that any Golden Ear should immediately have concluded that the device is inadequate by just listening to it ;)
 
Thanks. I corrected myself ;)

So ... Any word on that switching box he was using?
I mentioned the box in the other thread.
I have not seen him use it.
You can also check his YT channel.
Look for Skedra box.
 
Back
Top Bottom