Are we really talking about
DACs or about anti-imaging filters in DACs?
I was away for a bit and read this
entire thread last night. I recommend all to do that.
It was
not an edifying experience. Much of ASR seems to have lost a marble or two in response to the review.
That said, all props to Solderdude, one of the few who kept his head on straight throughout.
FWIW I believe Josh's claimed accomplishment is frankly
impossible.
But for Amir to first cite a relay switch noise ('up vs down' , or 'tick vs tock') as a possible tell -- that's entirely possible -- but balk at
recording it....amounting to dotting the 'i' and crossing the 't' on that theory -- was a flummoxing choice to this reader. I seriously,
seriously doubt it requires anything near a $1000 microphone and fancy pre to capture that sound, a sound that could be heard by a good listener (Amir)
wearing IEMS (not playing music). If he doesn't have an adequate one, for god's sake let's buy it for him! I'll send my never-used UMIK USB mic (purchased for REW readings that I still haven't done) to Amir if that helps. If he doesn't have time, fine, put it on the to-do list for the future! But to simply
not be interested in entering an obvious bit of evidence into Josh's 'trial', but also offer sighted testimony
with an 'even my wife could hear it' addendum-- plus continued chastizing of Josh for
not providing us necessary recordings -- that all had me almost literally agog. It all has the makings of an audiophile farce.
Regarding the crap bench results (distortion) this unit displays, Matt Hooper, of all people, hit a salient nail on the head: this means that for
some uses -- such as amp comparison -- the Van Alstine device (NB.,
not the only ABX box ever made) really could be 'masking' a possible 'real' audible differences -- a charge audiophile crackpots have been leveling for decades at ABX boxes. And to use those crap results to wave away any need to even
consider the case or the cause any further -- another rhetorical tactic displayed on this thread -- is a lame out.
Solderdude pointed out why the relay 'tell' theory might
not hold given Josh's particular testimony. It feels like no one read that!. Then we moved on to another discovery, the impedence vs attenuation issue. Solderdude posted
a very nice breakdown of what Josh
did , to conclude this
was the likely issue. No one else did that! Even though understanding what Josh
actually did (to the extent we know) is critical to judging how dispositive any of the theories are. Much less to throwing accusations about what he didn't do, apparently without
knowing that he didn't do it. There was so much posting about theories that had already been explained/discarded earlier in the thread.
Finally, allow me to cite the diversion into LED light conspiracy theories as another low point, and leave it at that.
tl;dr: I'm glad we found a reasonable answer but getting there was a
crazy and dispiriting ride. I say this as a person with routine, perhaps even small-pond
notorious, contempt for 'tone moderating'. But READ THE WHOLE THREAD if you disbelieve. Jeez, ASR, what a performance.