• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

AsciLab speakers are about to launch

have you heard the two? Afaik erin gushes about the c6b's envelopment.
Envelopment is dependent on the room and the relative degree of reflection strength for stereo content. It can be manipulated through wider/narrower speakers and use of absorbers (most home spaces are too small to effectively use diffusers).

There's a limited amount to expect from stereo. It's multichannel where envelopment stands out, since the main experience is being surrounded by sound ("enveloped").
 
Envelopment is dependent on the room and the relative degree of reflection strength for stereo content. It can be manipulated through wider/narrower speakers and use of absorbers (most home spaces are too small to effectively use diffusers).

There's a limited amount to expect from stereo. It's multichannel where envelopment stands out, since the main experience is being surrounded by sound ("enveloped").
Honestly dispersion numbers really make me wonder. Why do some manufacturers aim for 50 and below? Is there some sort of benefit to going lower? Who wants their speakers to sound narrow?
 
Honestly dispersion numbers really make me wonder. Why do some manufacturers aim for 50 and below? Is there some sort of benefit to going lower? Who wants their speakers to sound narrow?
Why would narrow dispersion make the SPEAKERS sound narrow?
 
Honestly dispersion numbers really make me wonder. Why do some manufacturers aim for 50 and below? Is there some sort of benefit to going lower? Who wants their speakers to sound narrow?
It is a side effect of wanting constant directivity.
 
Honestly dispersion numbers really make me wonder. Why do some manufacturers aim for 50 and below? Is there some sort of benefit to going lower? Who wants their speakers to sound narrow?
Some like more direct sound. It's equivalent to using absorbers to reduce reflective energy and tightened imaging. I found I like both wide and narrow, constant and sloping, as long as the design is good.
 
Some like more direct sound. It's equivalent to using absorbers to reduce reflective energy and tightened imaging. I found I like both wide and narrow, constant and sloping, as long as the design is good.
So basically if your room acoustics aren't that great directivity is almost always preferred? Is that the right read on it?
 
So basically if your room acoustics aren't that great directivity is almost always preferred? Is that the right read on it?
No. It's a personal decision about the kind of sound you want. For home listening the only true room problems are below 300Hz or so, which speakers cannot control other than cardioid designs down to around 100Hz (somewhat) and multiple, distributed subs below that.
Hey amirm since you did the reviews and are very familiar with these speakers, I've been trying to figure out a discrepancy between the way erin describes the f6b and c6b. For the c6b he said "Incredible dispersion and enveloping sound" but didn't write the same for the f6b, saying the +- 50 dispersion is acceptable but not as wide as he'd like. The dispersion data looks similar though, so I've been trying to figure out what's up. Notably I found your score of the F6B to be actually higher (8.3 vs 8.1 of the c6b). I wonder which context is the c6b better in and which the f6b?
They are the same other than distortion performance. It's easy to get too attached to subjective comments, and it's easy to contradict yourself as a reviewer when making them. Just look at the data. If the data is difficult to interpret, I suggest at minimum reading Toole's book.

Preference score difference are significant only when there is a difference of at least 0.7. Small differences in frequency response cause that 0.2 deviation.
 
how about an updated shipping date for US Bx8c's? Did i maiss a updated post or is this topic persona non grata by ASCI still?
 
Honestly dispersion numbers really make me wonder. Why do some manufacturers aim for 50 and below? Is there some sort of benefit to going lower? Who wants their speakers to sound narrow?
Not only preference but sometimes it may help with not ideal rooms, for example if the system has one side with wall and the other open, radiating less to the sides helps to reduce the reflection asymmetry.

When I built my dedicated listening room one of my goals was to have exact symmetrical sides to help with imaging.
 
how about an updated shipping date for US Bx8c's? Did i maiss a updated post or is this topic persona non grata by ASCI still?
The new amplifier modules are due mid November. Plan is to have the speakers ready by then to just plug them in and ship. This means we will get them by mid December. Please make sure you are on our wait list if you want to get one.
 
No. It's a personal decision about the kind of sound you want. For home listening the only true room problems are below 300Hz or so, which speakers cannot control other than cardioid designs down to around 100Hz (somewhat) and multiple, distributed subs below that.

They are the same other than distortion performance. It's easy to get too attached to subjective comments, and it's easy to contradict yourself as a reviewer when making them. Just look at the data. If the data is difficult to interpret, I suggest at minimum reading Toole's book.

Preference score difference are significant only when there is a difference of at least 0.7. Small differences in frequency response cause that 0.2 deviation.
When minor deviations at that score range are proportionate with thousand dollar increases in price, you start to wonder. :oops: I also noticed that sometimes the score may not be as high, but people regard it in the premium tier bracket. Say the kef r3 or the concertos.
 
Last edited:
When minor deviations at that score range are proportionate with thousand dollar increases in price, you start to wonder.
You aren't wrong. I bet 90% of the folks here could not tell a difference between the two models in a proper ABX. One buys the C6B as a premium product that boasts less distortion at high volume, but is it worth it? Not to someone budget minded.
 
The new amplifier modules are due mid November. Plan is to have the speakers ready by then to just plug them in and ship. This means we will get them by mid December. Please make sure you are on our wait list if you want to get one.
Like a good marketing guy, you provide incomplete information. December of what year? Almost 15 years in marketing so i know the tricks.
I have been on your wait list since March. There has been so many excuses and missteps along the way and while i appreciate your input (none of this is in your control so this vent has nothing to do with you) its about as believable as a seeing leprechaun and unicorn in my garage. The other problem is that I have been on your wait list and could easily miss out due to the small volume of product you get, the large number of people waiting and the way they are dished out when you do get them. I would not want to be in your shoes so i feel for ya, but its WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY better than being a customer waiting for ASCI to ship product. But hey, they got 47 new speakers in the planning stage. They cant make the ones they have released but the pipeline is full. Wooohooo! Party on Garth
 
Here you go:

View attachment 564174 View attachment 564175 View attachment 564176

F6B and C6B have identical directivity.

Q150 has pretty much identical radiation width/height, just slightly more coarse and w/o the vertical crossover error of the Ascilab's.

Not sure what immersion means to you, but if it's envelopment that you're after then neither Ascilab speaker will be a noticeable upgrade.

Frankly, I don't really know how to interpret spinorama scores anymore these days. You have people swearing up and down that the kef r3 is one of the best but its score is 8.0 .
 
Last edited:
Frankly, I don't really know how to interpret spinorama scores anymore these days. You have people swearing up and down that the kef r3 is one of the best but its score is 8.0 .
Forget about Harman preference scores for evaluation and just look at the actual measurement data instead.

Harman aren't using the preference scores internally and for good reason.
Absolutely no disrespect to Mr @staticV3 . However, IMHO, the actual words from the person who invented the spinorama method of evaluating speakers and the boss of those developed the "Harman preference score", do carry a little bit more weight :)
Ignore the Harman Preference Scores.png

Dr Toole has also very generously prepared and shared with us a presentation on how to interpret spinorama measurements. See the attachment in this post.
 
Like a good marketing guy, you provide incomplete information.
It is complete version of all I know. The Hypex amps are being updated with proper capacitors so they can be exported to US. They have promised a date. Will they keep it? I hope so as it is not a big change. Ascilab has told me they will have the speakers ready to plug them into on the day they arrive. Will they keep this date? I hope so as they know how many months we have been waiting for the speakers. And the fact that we have prepaid for all of them.
December of what year?
??? This year. Assuming another war doesn't break out and create another shortage. Or another import stop order doesn't get issued from US government almost to the day they were going to load our manufactured speakers on the boat. At this rate, maybe lightning will strike and push us into the new year. I don't know. What I do know is that I have told you all I know.
 
Like a good marketing guy, you provide incomplete information. December of what year? Almost 15 years in marketing so i know the tricks.
I have been on your wait list since March. There has been so many excuses and missteps along the way and while i appreciate your input (none of this is in your control so this vent has nothing to do with you) its about as believable as a seeing leprechaun and unicorn in my garage. The other problem is that I have been on your wait list and could easily miss out due to the small volume of product you get, the large number of people waiting and the way they are dished out when you do get them. I would not want to be in your shoes so i feel for ya, but its WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAY better than being a customer waiting for ASCI to ship product. But hey, they got 47 new speakers in the planning stage. They cant make the ones they have released but the pipeline is full. Wooohooo! Party on Garth

"...Like a good marketing guy, you provide incomplete information...Almost 15 years in marketing so i know the tricks"

incongruous much?

odd...having spent 30+ successful years in a particularly rarified, billions-of-dollars-in-realized-business (yes, with a b) realm of highly-technical marketing, all of the "good marketing guy(s)" I know are scrupulously transparent, utterly thorough, and impeccable in word and action.

on which side of the ethical boundary are you, Wayne, to espouse such generalization?
 
Back
Top Bottom