Audio Science Pal
Active Member
- Joined
- Feb 22, 2022
- Messages
- 275
- Likes
- 411
My Satin Espresso Sierra LX pair and Dark Cherry Sierra LX pair in 2 different acoustic environments are 1 year old now and have been a pleasure.
Interesting…. Wasnt sure if that was a positive review or not.Erin’s measurements and review of Sierra-lx is available on Patreon now.
I haven't watched it yet, waiting for it to be available on youtube.Interesting…. Wasnt sure if that was a positive review or not.
It's available nowI haven't watched it yet, waiting for it to be available on youtube.
Erin has vids of recommended speakers at different $ points. Search his channel.I own the LX's and thought something was wrong with me that noticed the tonality shift of the tweeters if not ear level. Now we have the science.
As someone who uses these for home theater, that's a bit of a bummer because I sit offside on occasion. Anything else of this caliber, without the minuses?
Agreed. He was more enthusiastic in his review (and recommendation) of the AsciLab C6B for cheaper, although it won't reach as deep bass extension. Though both should use a subwoofer or two.Erin seemed lukewarm at best with regard to this speaker. Low efficiency and high multitone distortion in the midrange are the two club feet of the speaker. Small FR variability like a 2-3 db trough in the upper mids/lower treble is fixable with eq. Ultimately, though, they won't play as loud as most people thought. Anyone who expects to be getting a Revel M126 be for a bargain price will, I think, be disappointed.
This is my only gripe with this speaker. You have low sensitivity so you want something powerful to drive them (I used a Buckeye Hypex Nc502mp), but then you quickly feel the limits of such power due to distortion in the mid-range. So then it’s like “arggggh why did I spend this much money on a powerful amp?” and feel like you are leaving something on the table, whether that’s true or not. Obvious there are physical limitations of the enclosure to keep in mind.Erin seemed lukewarm at best with regard to this speaker. Low efficiency and high multitone distortion in the midrange are the two club feet of the speaker. Small FR variability like a 2-3 db trough in the upper mids/lower treble is fixable with eq. Ultimately, though, they won't play as loud as most people thought. Anyone who expects to be getting a Revel M126 be for a bargain price will, I think, be disappointed.
While I doubt there could be any meaningful difference (for me, myself), I understand that we are somewhat biased towards reviews.This is my only gripe with this speaker. You have low sensitivity so you want something powerful to drive them (I used a Buckeye Hypex Nc502mp), but then you quickly feel the limits of such power due to distortion in the mid-range. So then it’s like “arggggh why did I spend this much money on a powerful amp?” and feel like you are leaving something on the table, whether that’s true or not. Obvious there are physical limitations of the enclosure to keep in mind.
I do think for the room I had them in they were great, and they rank as the best passive pair of bookshelves I’ve had/heard. The bass response plays a large part of that.
But now I’m even more interested in getting a pair of C6Bs to see how they perform.
Agreed. He was more enthusiastic in his review (and recommendation) of the AsciLab C6B for cheaper, although it won't reach as deep bass extension. Though both should use a subwoofer or two.
This makes so much sense now. The upper mids is why I ended up returning them before the 30 days was up. Some songs just sounded too lean and became uncomfortable to listen to. I had an 11ft+ listening position, so if I tried to listen loud it was likely just pushing them too hard. I couldn't figure it out, because it didn't show up in the frequency response.I've always felt that the "weak" point of these speakers was somewhere in the upper midrange. I've mentioned it here before (probably in this thread). I consider it more of a sensation of leanness/constraint as is not atypical of smaller 2-ways, but I wonder how much of that is due to IMD as it certainly doesn't take crossing into 80dB+ average listening levels to notice. Otherwise, I've no issues at all with the speakers given their size and price point. I've gotten them cooking pretty loudly and they stay impressively composed as long as they're crossed to subs. The C6B is certainly a very strong alternative.
Another reason why the multitone measurements are helpful. The THD data doesn't show this.This makes so much sense now. The upper mids is why I ended up returning them before the 30 days was up. Some songs just sounded too lean and became uncomfortable to listen to. I had an 11ft+ listening position, so if I tried to listen loud it was likely just pushing them too hard. I couldn't figure it out, because it didn't show up in the frequency response.
I still don't see any other practical alternatives for the price range.