• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Arendal 1610 SLIM 8 Speaker Review

Rate this speaker:

  • 1. Poor (headless panther)

    Votes: 5 2.7%
  • 2. Not terrible (postman panther)

    Votes: 28 15.3%
  • 3. Fine (happy panther)

    Votes: 114 62.3%
  • 4. Great (golfing panther)

    Votes: 36 19.7%

  • Total voters
    183
I feel like arendal knows they dont need to have perfect response cause a lot of their speakers are going to be sold to home theater guys who are going to DSP to some HT target anyways.
I don't think this is true. The1528 is also not ruler flat. They set their goals and make the design choices they need while keeping/weighing all measurements/factors into account. You just can't get it all in one design. Bass, output, sensitivity, near concentric design, curved baffle etc.

Have a look at this short with their designer. It is part of a longer video which is called "masterclass" and can be found in the arendal club website, very insightful.

 
Last edited:
So, once again, which commercially available, comparably priced, low-profile on-wall speakers demonstrably outperform the Arendal?
I think these measure well for an on-wall speaker. The price of $2800 in the USA will count against them while the price looks a lot better elsewhere at £2200 including duty, shipping, a 10 year warranty and 60 day free returns here in the UK.

On-wall speakers don't often get measured, I think partly because of the difficulty of simulating the wall, which I don't think was done in this case, meaning that maybe the measurement isn't fair to the speaker design.

It's also partly because these won't measure as well as a speaker designed for open-space use with a much deeper box and a big rear port. I don't even need to look to know that the 1610 bookshelf 8 will measure better and the 1610 floorstander 8 better still, yet their measurement and sound are not relevant to this review as they are a different form factor for a different placement.

I also think that on-wall speakers don't get measured or reviewed that often because they already sell well based on looks and convenience of mounting. It may be enough to say that the bookshelf from the line has great reviews and the on-wall will sound nearly as good but you can hang it on a wall which is great for saving space and getting accepted by the interior designer or wife!

At this point it feels like LiveTek is wilfully ignoring that these are a slim on-wall design, even posting an image of a homemade-looking speaker that is far too deep to be suited to LCR on-wall mounting.

Edit: Deleted an irrelevant sentence.
 
Last edited:
Cost for a pair of f6bs in the uk is £700 a pair vs the £2200 for the 1610 slims. I own the 1610 slims myself but I do wonder what if anything I would lose moving to ascilab seeing as I don't listen very loud at all, the 1610 center comes in at £1800 whereas I have a feeling the 3 way from acilabs will be cheaper and possibly better overall looking at what they have posted on their website. Not a lot for decent on wall speakers out there.
I'm curious as to what you're looking for here. Are you looking for a wall mounted centre to go with your 1610 slims or are you not happy with the 1610? To me, it looks like the Arendals have much lower distortion so unless you need to sell them and buy cheaper to raise cash, I would stick with them. Bear in mind I'm no expert at comparing speaker measurements, far from it.

I haven’t mentioned the price, but ASR has shown us time and again that performance is not always correlated with price. I find the 1610s really attractive, but the price-to-performance ratio of the F6Bs seems hard to beat.
I've considered the F6Bs myself for LCR speakers as a possible distant-future upgrade/sidegrade to my old floorstanders or as rear speakers. They do seem to have great price/performance. I was considering the KEF Q4 Meta for wall mount but I think they are probably inferior to the F6Bs now those exist. Not that the Q4 meta has been measured here, just going by measurements KEF have posted themselves.

The Dali Opticon LCR MK2 or Robikore On-Wall might be comparable to the 1610 slim but they are not likely to be measured. I've asked Dali about sending a pair to Amir for measurement and they declined. I have a pair of Dali Oberon On-Wall which are currently in the loft while I consider if I want to use them and I've been considering sending one for measurement. Shipping to the USA is an obstacle though.
 
Last edited:
According to Arendal these are designed to combine with a subwoofer. So why the big 8" woofer? Wouldn't a 6" have gotten to the crossover point just as well and be a smaller case?
 
I've considered the F6Bs myself for LCR speakers as a possible distant-future upgrade/sidegrade to my old floorstanders or as rear speakers. They do seem to have great price/performance.

You can't go wrong with Ascilab
On the other hand, I went back to my old Polk R100s, I missed them too much. Once properly calibrated with RoomFit and with the Spinorama PEQ, these speakers are simply captivating with a good sub. )))
 
According to Arendal these are designed to combine with a subwoofer. So why the big 8" woofer? Wouldn't a 6" have gotten to the crossover point just as well and be a smaller case?
I can think of a few reasons:
  • To have a coherent look across the 1610 range.
  • To use common parts across the range; drivers, waveguide, baffle etc. and reduce cost.
  • The speaker needs to be wide to have much internal volume and still be slim and a small driver looks odd in a wide speaker.
1793711763783.png

I think the small driver in the Q4 meta looks weird for example. Most on-wall speakers need their grille to be kept on for this reason whereas I think the Slim 1610 looks good without.
 
...Also the fact that if you priced in your time in building a speaker at minimum wage levels, ...

This is a misunderstanding of opportunity cost that comes up almost once a week. Unless someone is taking unpaid time off work, then you would not consider that time as a cost.

...and source the parts and materials and ignoring the cost of the tools and workshop required, you would likely come out with a price several times that of the Arendals and likely a far inferior appearance
Seems like bad assumptions. But as pointed out earlier, it's not very constructive to point out in every speaker review thread whether DIY can do better. If anyone, including Livetek or myself, wants to make that point we should create a thread in the DIY subforum..
 
This is a misunderstanding of opportunity cost that comes up almost once a week. Unless someone is taking unpaid time off work, then you would not consider that time as a cost.


Seems like bad assumptions. But as pointed out earlier, it's not very constructive to point out in every speaker review thread whether DIY can do better. If anyone, including Livetek or myself, wants to make that point we should create a thread in the DIY subforum..
These are fair points so I edited my post. The time to build something is always a consideration though and having read about DIY speakers, time is an obstacle for many as well as the cost of buying the tools and having the space for the tools. I don't fix my own car for similar reasons. I'm wondering how many unfinished DIY speaker projects there are out there.
 
I'm curious as to what you're looking for here. Are you looking for a wall mounted centre to go with your 1610 slims or are you not happy with the 1610? To me, it looks like the Arendals have much lower distortion so unless you need to sell them and buy cheaper to raise cash, I would stick with them. Bear in mind I'm no expert at comparing speaker measurements, far from it.


I've considered the F6Bs myself for LCR speakers as a possible distant-future upgrade/sidegrade to my old floorstanders or as rear speakers. They do seem to have great price/performance. I was considering the KEF Q4 Meta for wall mount but I think they are probably inferior to the F6Bs now those exist. Not that the Q4 meta has been measured here, just going by measurements KEF have posted themselves.

The Dali Opticon LCR MK2 or Robikore On-Wall might be comparable to the 1610 slim but they are not likely to be measured. I've asked Dali about sending a pair to Amir for measurement and they declined. I have a pair of Dali Oberon On-Wall which are currently in the loft while I consider if I want to use them and I've been considering sending one for measurement. Shipping to the USA is an obstacle though.
I tried Q4 metas before purchasing 1610 slims. Q4s sounded very boxy even after Dirac ART calibration. I guess there was some resonances causing it, Q4 is very light speaker compared to 1610 Slim.
 
I tried Q4 metas before purchasing 1610 slims. Q4s sounded very boxy even after Dirac ART calibration. I guess there was some resonances causing it, Q4 is very light speaker compared to 1610 Slim.
How do you like the slims?
 
How do you like the slims?
They're great. On-wall placement and untreated living room but still they shine. I had 1723 S bookshelves before the Q4s. Subjectively 1610 Slims are more neutral (1723 a bit bright), better soundstage and envelopement. I don't listen very loud, around -20 AVR volume, my Denon 3800H drives them without distortion. Not much to say about bass on their own because I have 2 subs but they integrate well around 90Hz FSL with Dirac ART.
 
I'm curious as to what you're looking for here. Are you looking for a wall mounted centre to go with your 1610 slims or are you not happy with the 1610? To me, it looks like the Arendals have much lower distortion so unless you need to sell them and buy cheaper to raise cash, I would stick with them. Bear in mind I'm no expert at comparing speaker measurements, far from it.
Not looking to change anything as I do have a 1610 center coming, I do however have to question price vs performance when comparing to other brands, if the acilabs could have got me say 90% there with sound quality/performance while being 66% cheaper, that is huge to be honest, every speaker acilabs puts out currently measures very well, reminds me of kef but I have yet to actually hear one so can't really assume they would sound better for my application of just movies and tv shows.
 
I have great admiration for the DIY approach, someone who technically understands what it takes to objectively improve a loudspeaker or build one from scratch. Naturally, there is a wealth of information available on constructing speaker enclosures, designing crossover and units.

In fact, it was a friend involved in DIY audio who first introduced me to the concept of "high fidelity," helping me break free from the vicious cycle of the "high-end" audio world. I owe him a lot; that was over 20 years ago.

However, building a profitable business and navigating all the associated red tape—that’s an entirely different world.

I believe LiveTek speaker is likely very competent, but making such a speaker accessible to potential buyers is another matter—not to mention promoting the brand and setting the right price point.

As for a speaker with a depth of only 16 cm—designed for wall mounting—that’s an interesting concept. There are surely many others like me who don’t have a dedicated listening room, are tired of having bulky speakers in their living area, and would love to swap them for something that is both high-performing and aesthetically pleasing.
 
The second is that the Baffle step compensation should be omitted or nearly omitted from the speakers crossover design. Speakers further from the wall lose more bass and lower midrange energy as the sound wraps around the speaker, sending much of the energy rearward behind the speaker and then you get cancelations as it all bounces back forward & all around.
(These cancelations happen with on wall speakers in higher frequencies, the bass and lower midrange is generally reinforced and not canceled and not wrapping behind the speaker)
That is part of why Arendal likely tuned the 300hrz dip but these still seem to have some small amount of baffle step compensation so they may sound slightly thicker and a wee bit chesty on a wall. Conversely these should sound a bit thinner than neutral out on stands well away from the wall.

I have the 1528 Slims for audition, and a pair of 1528 Bookshelf speakers. .

When I first received the 1528 Slims, I thought they sounded more closed in and darker than the Bookshelves. Eventually, I discovered I could get a similar timbre from the Bookshelves if I set both the Mid and Treble jumpers to low.

For this comparison, the Bookshelves are on the Arendal 1528 stands, and the Slims are on top of the Bookshelves. I engaged a crossover at 70Hz for both speaker pairs, with port plugs in and out for the bookshelf’s. Obviously I had to change my vertical listening position for this test. It’s been a few weeks, but I also recall level matching (albeit with SPL Pro on iPhone).

The speakers are about 2.5’ from the back wall, and 4’ to 6’ from side walls.

Based on the discussion here, this is not how I would expect the 1610 Slims to sound compared to 1610 Bookshelves. Am I wrong?
 
Damn Mofi... those are incredible speakers. I wish they could introduce big center with multi woofers like tower models.
 
Yeah you can. Mofi 888.
85.6dB / 2.83 V as measured by EAC is extremely average.

That being said, in the usual triangle of:

Compact size - LFX - high sensitivity
(choose two)

..the 888 clearly sacrificed the former.
 
Yeah you can. Mofi 888.
Don't agree on that as measurements just don't tell the whole story. I've been arguing that for the 3rd time now. Which you seem to ignore. But I'll respond to you one last time.

The mofi has a better horizontal and vertical directivity as is clearly shown by measurements, but will also send a lot of energie to the ceiling and floor.

The arendal has a waveguide that severely limits the energy that goes to ceiling and floor. In normal rooms that don't have complete absorption on floor and ceiling, this is a big advantage as it means less reflections and less smearing of the sound.

Downside of this is that it does affect the FR and vertical directivity (prob also the horizontal).

How much? I would say yes you can see it in the graphs. They are not perfect, but they are in no way bad and it is extremely debabtable if you will even hear those imperfections.

Is it better than eg the mofi?? I can't say as there is IMHO no one measurement to prove this. But the folks @ Arendal surely believe that the overall result is better that way.
 
Don't agree on that as measurements just don't tell the whole story. I've been arguing that for the 3rd time now. Which you seem to ignore.

Oh, you are certainly right I am going to absolutely ignore any argument made with this basis.

The arendal has a waveguide that severely limits the energy that goes to ceiling and floor.

So does the mofi. The mid is the waveguide.

Is it better than eg the mofi?? I can't say as there is IMHO no one measurement to prove this.

There's an entire gamut of measurements that show the Mofi is better at Erins Audio Corner, but it's a different sized speaker entirely, but size wasn't a criteria you mentioned in your post.
 
Back
Top Bottom