AP Mastering: "Nyquist theorem debunked: why 44.1kHz sounds bad"

[restorer-john]

Right! Thanks for adding.

Yeah. Another day, another troll. I just feel that he's almost begging for @amirm to make a video with actual repeatable and objective proof against everything he has said. We could even do some simple nulling experiments to prove everything pretty easily.

That's what these Youtube clowns want. Cut their oxygen off, don't engage or spread their clickbait garbage and eventually their 'channels' wither and die.

 

[boxerfan88]

• what they teach in university for this day and age is "completely wrong"
• even the Nyquist theorem is wrong

I stopped watching after that ... ha ha ha ha ha ha

thank you for the short entertainment !!

 

[EERecordist]

This YouTuber makes sensational videos and shills his own plug-in business. His mastering business is for electronic music. Posting his videos is not helpful to ASR, in my view.

 

[Doodski]

• what they teach in university for this day and age is "completely wrong"
• even the Nyquist theorem is wrong

I stopped watching after that ... ha ha ha ha ha ha

thank you for the short entertainment !!

 

[LTig]

Just wanted to post this pic, thanks @Doodski!

 

[Doodski]

Just wanted to post this pic, thanks @Doodski!

Keep spreading this image around till peeps get it.

 

[fieldcar]

Awe. Cmon guys. I know somewhere in there you get at least a small kick out of these videos. Sometimes we all need to go to the zoo to watch the primates to realize where we're at. I'm just bringing a bit of that zoo into the doors of ASR.

 

[mhardy6647]

but, but... 44.1 kHz doesn't sound bad...

 

[Sokel]

I would imagine this very common with any sort of live recording, especially orchestration. I wonder how many mics they use on those John William recordings. It's gotta be a nightmare to deal with.

Here's an example of the mics and the mic trees (red and green) :

(and the whole video,link)

 

[JSmith]

I'm just bringing a bit of that zoo into the doors of ASR.

Fair call... it's a good thing when people seek further info and possibly come here, then see the video debunked.


JSmith

 

[fieldcar]

I can also say that it's important to not rest on ones laurels as the common saying goes. I look at it like a fun challenge or exercise. Not an argument, but a game. I get really excited by the idea of debunking something like these videos with experiments and objective data/visuals. I think many of us are like that here. At least I would hope so.

 

[SIY]

What are your thoughts?

I would not have even bothered clicking.

 

[Jim Taylor]

Awe. Cmon guys. I know somewhere in there you get at least a small kick out of these videos. Sometimes we all need to go to the zoo to watch the primates to realize where we're at. I'm just bringing a bit of that zoo into the doors of ASR.

You could have at least posted a screenshot instead of a working link.

 

[sam_adams]

View attachment 427946

YOINK!

Thanks!

 

[Old_School_Brad]

There should ideally be a community rating for videos with such claims, or the publisher should be required to label the content as "fictional drama."

 

[Mnyb]

There should ideally be a community rating for videos with such claims, or the publisher should be required to label the content as "fictional drama."

Science fiction

 

[Rednaxela]

Thanks for the excellent way of opening a thread about a YouTube video.

 

[Blumlein 88]

Science fiction

There is this fan dichotomy between science fiction and fantasy in novels. This is more on the fantasy side to me.

 

[dfuller]

This YouTuber makes sensational videos and shills his own plug-in business. His mastering business is for electronic music. Posting his videos is not helpful to ASR, in my view.

his speaker videos are laughably bad.

 

[antcollinet]

I just feel that he's almost begging for @amirm to make a video

He doesn't need to. Monty has already done a perfectly good job.