But it seems (??) there are no services that will give for free a couple of small [or (better!)) normal\big] Genelecs to the respected Pearljam))But there are services
But it seems (??) there are no services that will give for free a couple of small [or (better!)) normal\big] Genelecs to the respected Pearljam))But there are services
Thanks. While $900, not $99...
I can't find them online either. But did see them at the show in China. Very compact little speakers. I *think* I have a picture of them which I will post in my show report.
www.audiosciencereview.com
Cool, so why are we sharing and listening to videos him talking about his design process… It doesn't matter. Why are we paying any attention to what he says about his reasons for adopting field coils… It doesn't matter.Regardless, his products are to be judged the same way whether he uses the most up to date Science or visits Wonderland and gets advice from the Mad Hatter.
The end product is what matters and not how it was achieved. You can judge his work in quite a few of Erin's measurements and I'd be interested to know what you think.
Far from it. It might be damning evidence against the argument that all the special tweaking that he claims to do actually matters. If indeed he even does it. The guru speaker designer trading on his reputation as a guru needs to assert that he's got special sauce, even if he doesn't do any such thing and just uses measurements to design speakers that measure very well. We don't know. And like Satanica says above, it doesn't matter.I would guess that he does. But if he doesn't that would be pretty damning evidence against the argument that controlled conditions are all that critical. He has been designing speakers for 42 years, KEF, Infinity, TAD, Pioneer, Elac, Mofi and Jones and Cerreta. His speakers over this time have almost universally been demonstrated to sound AND MEASUIRE good. So if he isn't listening under controlled conditions, he sure shouldn't change what he has been doing.
Curious why the guy didn't design a stand that put his exotic field coil concentric driver's tweeter at ear level or somewhere close..Having known Andrew for a couple decades I would expect if you’re a serious buyer and you reach out to him, directly or through a dealer, that he will share with you whatever measurements you require to make a decision.
Regardless this is a very niche speaker for those that want a high sensitivity design. There are specs on the website. One that stands out is the low extension which on the surface doesn’t seem competitive for the size and price. But I would think tube/turntable listeners will prioritize efficiency and a friendly impedance curve. And for real music I expect the two 12s in this very large cabinet will sound fantastic.
These will surely be reviewed and measured soon enough. In the meantime if you are a real buyer, reach out to them. And also take a look at the reviews and measurements for the many speakers Andrew has designed.
Because we are on a speaker review site, in a thread about his speakers, and someone posted his interview with Erin. The same reason we talk about how Audio First, Ascilabs, and Ascend Acoustics do things in the threads about their speakers.Cool, so why are we sharing and listening to videos him talking about his design process…
I have never heard him claim he's got special sauce. He never once said he does anything different, or more special, than anyone else, he is at an audio conference doing an interview about measurements and speaker design. Its quite nice that he encourages DIYers...he has been to at least two get togethers in the Midwest and been a judge at the Parts Express Speaker Design Competition twice....If indeed he even does it. The guru speaker designer trading on his reputation as a guru needs to assert that he's got special sauce, even if he doesn't do any such thing and just uses measurements to design speakers that measure very well. We don't know.
I was responding to a post that asserted that only the results matter, not to the question of whether anybody has any curiosity about other things.Because we are on a speaker review site, in a thread about his speakers, and someone posted his interview with Erin. The same reason we talk about how Audio First, Ascilabs, and Ascend Acoustics do things in the threads about their speakers.
So, he just gets the measurements right, and "job done"?I have never heard him claim he's got special sauce. He never once said he does anything different, or more special, than anyone else, he is at an audio conference doing an interview about measurements and speaker design.
Yes, that is nice, in terms of donating one's time. Judging with his golden ears as an acknowledged authority, invited for that particular reason. Or was he simply judging on appearances and technical details?It's quite nice that he encourages DIYers...he has been to at least two get togethers in the Midwest and been a judge at the Parts Express Speaker Design Competition twice.
The issue isn't "only" designing by ear, it is designing by doing something after measurements that seems to involve, what, what do you want to call it? Because I'll bet it isn't experimentally valid controlled listening using panels of listeners.I would think it is pretty safe to assume that he designs the way he says. Other than a few people that claim to only design by ear, he is describing the process that almost everyone uses. In the thread "What role should listening play in speaker design" I believe every speaker designer who posted in that thread (which was a very small number) stated they do a very similar thing. (As we are on ASR, no one posting in that thread claimed that they only design by ear.)
Isn't that the whole point? If people are turned off by the technical side it makes sense to shift the marketing away from that and towards the personalities. Audiophiles love a guru - if a guru is involved they're automatically drawn to the product. Didn't something similar happen in F1 where the marketing focus shifted from the cars to the drivers, because the wider potential audience can relate to people, but not to the techncal/engineering side?I am pretty impressed that a guy of his calibre, experience and expertise exposes himself to the host of enthusiasts on the internet. Statistically the majority of whom were uninterested by or had no aptitude for anything scientific as children, never studied it to any level, never worked in it but have very firm opinions about things as adults despite no firm foundation on which to build any opinion.
I suppose he still has products to sell.
Have you watched the video? I don't think he mentioned doing some "secret sauce" post a measurement baseline prototype to take the next prototype to an even higher level. From memory, he mentioned his main purpose of listening is to try and listen for problems, and then to try and correlate those heard problems to measurements and potentially fix them in the next prototype. I'll admit, I was quite impressed by the video as a whole. Once again, from my memory, I don't think he mentioned the Jones and Cerreta speaker and if he did it was only briefly.The issue isn't "only" designing by ear, it is designing by doing something after measurements that seems to involve, what, what do you want to call it? Because I'll bet it isn't experimentally valid controlled listening using panels of listeners.
and he has to cultivate his fame and cult of personality even as his ears inevitably turn to cardboard (he tunes speakers by ear, after all). these video conversations are ads for his speaker brand and himself as a marketable name in speaker design.he still has products to sell.
A septuagenarian's sighted listening is not a value add.he mentioned his main purpose of listening is to try and listen for problems, and then to try and correlate those heard problems
I assume his microphones are much younger than septuagenarian.A septuagenarian's sighted listening is not a value add.
Yes, and they're also (guaranteed) much more reliable than are his earsI assume his microphones are much younger than septuagenarian.
Fixed it for you.I wish I had the confidence of the people on this forum who thinks they know more about how to go about designing aspeakercoaxial driver from the ground up than Andrew Jones.
I absolutely accept that making it about people rather than technology makes for a far bigger audience, and makes a lot more money. F1 fandom was always about the drivers more than the cars, but the PR from the new owners has taken it to a new level - to a considerable extent ignoring the car.Isn't that the whole point? If people are turned off by the technical side it makes sense to shift the marketing away from that and towards the personalities. Audiophiles love a guru - if a guru is involved they're automatically drawn to the product. Didn't something similar happen in F1 where the marketing focus shifted from the cars to the drivers, because the wider potential audience can relate to people, but not to the techncal/engineering side?
No need, IMO, the original statement was also spot on anyway.Fixed it for you.
That's why they're so confidentWhat I find exasperating is the number of enthusiasts who have scant scientific knowledge on which to base an opinion are so confident in their critiscisms.