AI music vs real quiz (easy)

[LTig]

4/10 maybe I'm a robot ...

 

[Sokel]

8/10,missed country and pop (know very little about them,makes sense).

 

[restorer-john]

4/10 maybe I'm a robot ...

Blame the lossy algorithm and the jitter in the undersea cable across the Pacific ocean from Australia.

 

[JustJones]

6/10 I personally welcome our new AI overlords.

 

[Jimbob54]

7/10 but I was confused by the ones with vocals. Are they deliberately made to be gibberish if either human or ai so we can't use that to tell? Or is the gibberish a massive clue its ai generated?

 

[earlevel]

I got 9/10. I incorrectly identified the Funk R&B as AI. Not so surprising - it was crap

Exactly the same. 9/10, the funk was so bad that I only let a few notes go by. I wasn't convinced it was AI, but I thought, "this is so bad that if it isn't AI, it shouldn't be blamed on humans..." All of the others also guessed in a few notes—in general, the AI versions were awkward sounding, and if it didn't sound awkward right away, I guessed human.

 

[Berwhale]

7/10 but I was confused by the ones with vocals. Are they deliberately made to be gibberish if either human or ai so we can't use that to tell? Or is the gibberish a massive clue its ai generated?

The AI is just generating sounds based on it's training inputs, it 'knows' nothing about the presumed source of those sounds (be they instruments, vocals or something else)

 

[Timcognito]

If it were 4/10, I wouldn't admit it but I got 7/10 like the other geesers here. Music could have been better all around.

 

[jurop]

i got wrong the funk/R&B b/c... well, IMHO it's really a piece of crap, I judged it composed by AI in the same way I spotted the other craps
I'd say 'non intellegible words' plus 'wrong sounds' are the most significant issues, and now let's think that all of our feedbacks are helping google to improve its algorithms...

EDIT: hahaha, I see now from previous comments I'm not the only one who had been fooled by the funk/R&B piece !

 

[Jimbob54]

The AI is just generating sounds based on it's training inputs, it 'knows' nothing about the presumed source of those sounds (be they instruments, vocals or something else)

That's what I mean. I assumed they might have garbled the vocals on legit music when setting up the test to make it less obvious. But no.

Though to be fair the opera could have been gibberish or Italian and I wouldn't have known either way.

 

[restorer-john]

Though to be fair the opera could have been gibberish or Italian and I wouldn't have known either way.

It was absolute gibberish wasn't it?

 

[Ageve]

I got the Jazz one wrong.

 

[MAB]

4/10. Does that mean I'm an AI? Easiest one is country. What does that say, that AI doesn't understand country music? And I never understand why anyone listens to it either. I had hopes AI would improve country music.

Maybe the AI needs to play it backwards, see if it makes sense then...

 

[Jimbob54]

It was absolute gibberish wasn't it?

I think so

 

[JSmith]

Just a bit of fun

Can you tell if these pieces of music were created by humans or AI? Take our quiz

Here are five pieces of music created by humans and five created by AI. Can you tell them apart?

www.abc.net.au

Yeah did it yesterday... 7/10 on a quick go using basic external PC speakers whilst busy. I did notice AI piano is too perfect and I can tell it's generated fairly easily... also any sung words were unintelligible, which was an easy clue as well.



JSmith

 

[JaMaSt]

It would be interesting to hear the outcome if a program produced a new performance of Bach's cello suites from an amalgamation of prior performances.

Something like the challenging suites can really demonstrate an individual artist's interpretation of a piece of music that has no one-correct-way of being performed.

 

[restorer-john]

Next will be a grammy award given to an artist for song of the year and when the truth comes out, it will be AI.

New millenium version of Milli-Vanilli...

You heard it here first.

 

[voodooless]

8/10. Got the hiphop and funk ones wrong. Most of the others were pretty easy, especially the ones with “lyrics”

Would be fun to redo this with real people performing the songs, with lyrics AI generated as well. I’m pretty sure it will be a lot harder.

 

[jsilvela]

10/10, but yesterday I took the Klippel listening test and had trouble discerning distortion from 30dB. :shrug:

 

[MrOtto]

When vocals are jibberish: always AI.