• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

A talk for the local skeptics community

Speaker materials. Aluminum, silk, teflon, kryptonite... Those are elements that can lead to so much BS that it is worth taking an approach.
 
Peter Belt is interesting in that he at least stated openly that he was influencing the listener as opposed to the sound waves.
An important point often missed by both his supporters and detractors.
 
Audiophile fuses are worth a look (not the worst - £4k !!!)
Audiophile fuses are super fun!

For some educational content I think speaker cables allow you to demonstrate a couple of important general ideas. One is the marketing trick of saying something technically correct but not significant in practice. Silver is a better conductor than copper. True! Now let's calculate how much difference it makes. Or how about the skin effect? It's real. I looked it up on Wikipedia. But at audio frequencies it's insignificant. The belief in the technical story can be sufficient to justify or legitimate a desire to buy some fancy thing.
 
Oh, my ghu!

I think one of the elements of the talk will be "just look how much popped up in 48 hours to stare in horror at".

This group is skeptics, not audio people, so explaining how to improve your system is probably not in their wheelhouse, I'm pretty sure that they are mostly happy with their cell phones. I keep the instruction videos for the AES group.
 
This group is skeptics, not audio people
We can’t use the R-word on ASR, but it may be of interest to look at the parallels for your audience.
 
Ha ha, those grounding boxes. I'm guessing that it's a farmer who was putting up an electric fence and and in connection with knocking down the grounding spikes

The farmer, yes. and the factory...

From 2009... Near Tranarp Sweden...

1735687502746.png



1735687156458.png


Factory Video Interview...
 
Last edited:
So @j_j, is your talk more about the products themselves, or about they way they are sold to the public, or the cult like following that some of these products accumulate?
 
So @j_j, is your talk more about the products themselves, or about they way they are sold to the public, or the cult like following that some of these products accumulate?

It's about how human perception can be tricked via expectation, advertisement, malicious presentation, etc. But it's supposed to be entertaining, too, and I suspect the green ink and some of the "color fuses" are going to be toasted and roasted.
 
And the Tice clocks, don’t forget those. They ‘treated’ Micronta (Radio Shack) clocks and then you plug them in somewhere in the house and they “organize” your electrical current.
 
This thread reminds me:

A while back, I auditioned a set of loudspeakers at a local, small high end audio store, run by one of your classic idiosyncratic audiophile proprietors.

When I suggested that I would just bring some of my test music on a thumb drive, or asked if he had streaming, he said no thumb drives or streaming allowed. it was his conviction that music from my thumb drive or streaming, even lossless, could not be high enough quality. And that if I was to bring any of my own music, it must be in the form of CDs.

(this made me laugh inwardly. I had to resist telling him that my own work was computer audio based, routinely spit out through God knows what type of anti-golden-ear paths to FTP sites, and downloaded to be played in million dollar mixing Studios… without any sonic loss),

So I complied. And I guess I wasn’t too surprised when I was sat in front of the speakers to watch him “ demagnetize” every CD I wanted to listen to.

(the speakers sucked by the way).
 
This thread reminds me:

A while back, I auditioned a set of loudspeakers at a local, small high end audio store, run by one of your classic idiosyncratic audiophile proprietors.

When I suggested that I would just bring some of my test music on a thumb drive, or asked if he had streaming, he said no thumb drives or streaming allowed. it was his conviction that music from my thumb drive or streaming, even lossless, could not be high enough quality. And that if I was to bring any of my own music, it must be in the form of CDs.

(this made me laugh inwardly. I had to resist telling him that my own work was computer audio based, routinely spit out through God knows what type of anti-golden-ear paths to FTP sites, and downloaded to be played in million dollar mixing Studios… without any sonic loss),

So I complied. And I guess I wasn’t too surprised when I was sat in front of the speakers to watch him “ demagnetize” every CD I wanted to listen to.

(the speakers sucked by the way).
Weird, as the thumb drive could have a file of greater resolution than Redbook. Same with streaming (at least circa 2024).
 
Weird, as the thumb drive could have a file of greater resolution than Redbook. Same with streaming (at least circa 2024).
I can confirm that in 2025, that is still the case ;)
 
Weird, as the thumb drive could have a file of greater resolution than Redbook. Same with streaming (at least circa 2024).

It’s so weird how these audiophiles, and their theories of how sound quality works, seem to be utterly ignorant, or just don’t take account of how the content is actually made. Usually the content which they find to sound glorious on their carefully curated systems, is made in ways that violate almost all their precious ideas about how sound quality is maintained.
 
This thread reminds me:

A while back, I auditioned a set of loudspeakers at a local, small high end audio store, run by one of your classic idiosyncratic audiophile proprietors.

When I suggested that I would just bring some of my test music on a thumb drive, or asked if he had streaming, he said no thumb drives or streaming allowed. it was his conviction that music from my thumb drive or streaming, even lossless, could not be high enough quality. And that if I was to bring any of my own music, it must be in the form of CDs.

(this made me laugh inwardly. I had to resist telling him that my own work was computer audio based, routinely spit out through God knows what type of anti-golden-ear paths to FTP sites, and downloaded to be played in million dollar mixing Studios… without any sonic loss),

So I complied. And I guess I wasn’t too surprised when I was sat in front of the speakers to watch him “ demagnetize” every CD I wanted to listen to.

(the speakers sucked by the way).
My asthma laughing cough was triggered by your example.... LoL...
 
Back
Top Bottom