• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

A Broad Discussion of Speakers with Major Audio Luminaries

It's quite straightforward. Do you want to listen to the speaker or do you want to know how neutral and accurate the speaker? 2 different things. 2 different answers. Lots of people like inaccurate colored non neutral speakers. But very few will admit the speakers are "flawed". No different than liking super salty food.
We have measurements to see if speaker is linear. Or do alot of guys go to listen in mono before bying speakers?
 
I am aware of those. I still just dont get it bcouse the sound changes massively when you add another one and put them in stereo. And you will always listen them in stereo in every room.

We have measurements to see if speaker is linear. Or do alot of guys go to listen in mono before bying speakers?

Most people arent doing speaker reviews so they arent running into a need to listen to a single speaker.

If you dont get it, thats fine, just move on.
 
I've always bought according to measurements, never listened before buying

Smoothe on axis no matter what

Reflective room? Narrow Controlled directivity. Plush room? Wide dispersion, less need for control

Vertical dispersion has a lower bar for 'good enough'

Subwoofer? Sealed box with 12db roll off and higher F3. No sub? Anechoic F3 no higher than 50hz ideally 40hz

Distortion I'll eye according to how loud they'd be playing / how large the room is

Not once has this ever led to anything but stellar results :)
 
Use measurements to weed out the really poor designs, if of course the really poor designs have been measured.
Keith
 
Use measurements to weed out the really poor designs, if of course the really poor designs have been measured.
Keith
Exactly. Poor measurements are probably an accurate disqualifier. But good measurements are not necessarily an accurate validator.
Amazing how this concept seems to be difficult for many to understand.
 
I haven’t encountered a loudspeaker design that measured well and sounded bad, but I have become used to transparent designs.
Keith
 
Exactly. Poor measurements are probably an accurate disqualifier. But good measurements are not necessarily an accurate validator.
Amazing how this concept seems to be difficult for many to understand.
Obviously Dr Toole doesn't understand it either :facepalm:
...
For this reason, I have devoted a substantial part of my life teaching the value of measurements. Personally, from the perspective of sound quality, I would trust my interpretation of a “spinorama” presentation of anechoic measurements more than my subjective judgment in a typical consumer listening circumstance.
...
 
good measurements are not necessarily an accurate validator.
Good measurements for speakers, but not only speakers, all link of the system, is absolutely an accurate validator.
As far as Speaker, or any transducer, are concerned, what we get from the measurement is not as precise as electronic measurements, yes, but still miles ahead of bad measuring transducer.
That this concept seems to be difficult for many to understand, is mesmerizing.
 
I haven’t encountered a loudspeaker design that measured well and sounded bad, but I have become used to transparent designs.
Keith
I have. Usually over-juiced on low end.
 
Good measurements for speakers, but not only speakers, all link of the system, is absolutely an accurate validator.
...
That this concept seems to be difficult for many to understand, is mesmerizing.
"Good measurements" is not defined and thus has no meaning. "Absolutely an accurate validator" - what does that mean? An absolute validator of the Preference Score? An absolute validator of the F6?

Here are some good Measurements - both Klippel NFS - so this should be an "absolutely accurate validator". Which of these speakers sounds better? (A) is solid lines, (B) dot-dashed.

Screenshot 2026-08-25 163446.jpg
 
Obviously Dr Toole doesn't understand it either :facepalm:
See the post above. Dr Toole (or anyone else) can look at all the curves he wants, but cannot tell which of those speakers (A) or (B) he would prefer without hearing them.
 
Which of these speakers sounds better?
That is up to preference, what sound better to any one of us, but they will sound good with no glaring issues if the measurement is good.
Good measurements" is not defined and thus has no meaning.
Good measurement will show that their is no big issues that will make it very difficult to have the speaker sound good in an average listening room.
"Absolutely an accurate validator" - what does that mean?
So, yes, it makes good measurement absolutely accurate as a validator of a certain standard of quality as opposed to bad measurements that will either make it impossible or very difficult to get a good experience from.
 
Measurements aren't the same as listening. I wouldn't buy 3k+ speakers without listening no matter what the measurements told me.
I always listen in 2 channel stereo to evaluate speakers. My point was that i guess very few people test and listens to one speaker in mono to determine the sound quality before buying.
 
"Good measurements" is not defined and thus has no meaning. "Absolutely an accurate validator" - what does that mean? An absolute validator of the Preference Score? An absolute validator of the F6?

Here are some good Measurements - both Klippel NFS - so this should be an "absolutely accurate validator". Which of these speakers sounds better? (A) is solid lines, (B) dot-dashed.

View attachment 554292
These are both performant speakers, and I'm confident they would both sound good to me
 
"Good measurements" is not defined and thus has no meaning. "Absolutely an accurate validator" - what does that mean? An absolute validator of the Preference Score? An absolute validator of the F6?

Here are some good Measurements - both Klippel NFS - so this should be an "absolutely accurate validator". Which of these speakers sounds better? (A) is solid lines, (B) dot-dashed.

View attachment 554292
B looks immediately better -- better bass extension, no droop through the ~150-400Hz region, no droop through the ~2kHz-8kHz region, better directivity. Differences are fairly minor, though, so the audible impact is hard to say. Of course, there's more to a speaker than its on-axis response. The "measurements don't matter" crowd for some reason always ask us to judge based on a single graph -- always the on-axis response -- instead of the full suite of measurements. One might think the problem is actually that they don't understand the measurements.
 
Well, after the excellent review of Amir showing we have a speaker that measures in the excellence range, I am not shy to say, even with knowledge this is Audio Science Review, this a speaker that so far, after about six hours of dedicated listening, conveys the emotional impact of Music to my ears. It keeps me focused to Music, wishing to have a week off work to listen again to all those recordings in my collection distinguished by quality of source and artistic value. One of the many: here (obviously not in the YouTube music format, but 16/44.1 FLAC):
 
I have. Usually over-juiced on low end.
If you haven't equalized the low end to address room problems you haven't completed the installation of any loudspeaker. A bass tone control also exists to assist in adjusting spectral balance. There may be loudspeakers with "incurable" bass problems, but not many. Most loudspeakers lack sufficient low bass output to be persuasive, and subwoofers are called for.
 
If you haven't equalized the low end to address room problems you haven't completed the installation of any loudspeaker. A bass tone control also exists to assist in adjusting spectral balance. There may be loudspeakers with "incurable" bass problems, but not many. Most loudspeakers lack sufficient low bass output to be persuasive, and subwoofers are called for.
To be clear, I'm not speaking on "too much low end" - that's rather an easy fix - I'm more talking about "too much on board EQ used to extend LFX at the expense of any meaningful headroom".
 
To be clear, I'm not speaking on "too much low end" - that's rather an easy fix - I'm more talking about "too much on board EQ used to extend LFX at the expense of any meaningful headroom".
OK, that is a totally different situation, and it started before DSP. With DSP one can extend the bass at lower sound levels and by anticipating distortion introduce a sliding high-pass filter to avoid overdrive - if done well, of course. It is pretty much standard in bluetooth portables, and 'smart' speakers. With the introduction of smart, WiFi connected full-sized loudspeakers it can be done even better. In all cases, though, the audible and measurable bass response is linked to the volume control. Of course, anyone wishing to explore the full frequency and dynamic range reaching high sound levels should avoid such loudspeakers.
 
Back
Top Bottom