Last week I took delivery of a PAM158 8-channel amplifier for use with my tri-amped Klipsch La Scala system.
<content deleted for brevity>
Although I desperately wanted the PAM158 to work in my system, I had to send it back.
<content deleted for brevity>
The PAM158 produced an audible hiss from my tweeters, even when no source was connected. The hiss sounded like water running in another room. I tried to eliminate the hiss by:
• disconnecting everything (except the speakers) from the amp
• changing how the unit was powered on (manually, via trigger, via autosense)
• moving the tweeters to different channels on the amplifier
• changing the selectable gain between LOW and HIGH
• changing the input switches from SE (RCA) to BAL (XLR)
• Powering the PAM158 via an isolation transformer to eliminate any possible ground loops
• Using RCA shorting connectors on the inputs of the unused channels
Nothing made any difference to the hiss; it was always present. I couldn't even discern a change in loudness when I changed the gain setting.
My B&C DE120 tweeters are very sensitive (106 dB). I wondered if the hiss was just the PAM158's noise floor. However, given the excellent specs of the 3e Audio A5 (upon which the PAM15X amps are based), I thought that unlikely.
<content deleted for brevity>
I've done some more investigating into the hiss that I was hearing from my tweeters when using the PAM158.
By putting my ear up against the tweeter, I was able to hear hiss from my existing amplifier (Aiyima A07) even when no inputs were connected to the amp. The hiss was quieter than that produced via the PAM158, but it was there. As with the PAM158, the hiss volume stayed the same whether the input cables were plugged in or unplugged. The volume of the hiss didn't change no matter how I positioned the volume (gain) knob on the A07, just as it stayed the same on either of the PAM158's gain settings. Although I didn't short the RCA inputs on my A07, I had found that shorting the inputs on the PAM158 made no difference. That gave me confidence that the RCA inputs weren't acting as antennae and that the hiss wasn't an induced signal.
Because the gain setting (or volume knob) has no effect on the hiss level, I figured I must be hearing a constant internal noise floor from the amplifier bleeding through to the tweeters. As such, it must be a fixed characteristic of the amplifier's internal electronics.
The PAM158 is built using the TPA3251 Class D chip. According to data I found at
QuantAsylum, the
TPA3251 has a minimum residual noise floor of
60 μVrms (A-weighted) and that the actual circuit layout, op-amp input buffers, and power routing can push that residual noise up to
80 μV to 150 μV.
@3eaudio can you share what the noise floor is for the PAM15X and PAM25X amplifiers?
I would have thought that the noise floor would be a bit lower than that (i.e., in the tens of microvolts) and that my tweeters wouldn't be sensitive enough to reproduce that signal. However I am using very sensitive (106 dB SPL @1W/1m B&C DE120) compression drivers on horns as my tweeters. Those tweeters are
far more efficient than "regular" tweeters (domes are typically around 86 dB). Consequently, they could reveal electrical noise floors that would be completely silent on conventional speakers.
I have concluded that my very high efficiency tweeters make me a "corner case" and that my speakers are not well suited for the PAM158 or other TPA325X-based amps. Although the inherent 60 μV to 100 μV residual noise floor of a standard TPA3251 configuration is harmless on ordinary speakers, when pushed into a 106 dB sensitive compression driver, that tiny voltage floor translates directly into an easily audible, constant
"shhh
" acoustic hiss, even from across the room.
@3eaudio would you agree with my conclusion?
Unfortunately, I cannot confirm my suspicions because neither my oscilloscope nor my differential probes are sensitive enough to measure in the sub-millivolt range. My differential probes have a minimum attenuation of 20X (and a noise floor specification of about 22 mVrms on that setting) so that the probe's internal electronic noise would completely mask the amplifier's natural noise.
What to do?
For my HF drivers (such as the B&C DE-120 tweeters) I could switch to low-gain, low-noise amplifiers, ideally something with low residual noise floor (i.e., under 10 μV to 15 μV). A smaller Class A, Class A/B, or high-end composite op-amp based amplifier (like a Neurochrome design) would be more appropriate. I note that the
Topping Mini300 claims to have a noise floor of <15 μV.
Alternatively, I could add a passive fixed L-Pad between the amp's outputs and the tweeter. Adding a -12dB to -18dB L-pad should drop all elements of the signal going to the tweeter --- including the noise --- by that amount, rendering it inaudible.
To compensate for the attenuation due to the L-pad, I could turn up the gain on my DSP for the signal to the tweeters.
*** UPDATE ***
I ordered a Topping Mini300 amp (noise floor of <15 μV) and tried it with my speakers. It was dead quiet, even with my ear pressed right against the tweeter horn.
I am convinced that the hiss I was hearing with the PAM158 was due to the inherent noise floor of that amplifier. The noise floor of the PAM158 was high enough that it turned out to be a poor match for my speakers.