• Welcome to ASR. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

1 ohm load speakers - what would be better - Hypex NCx500 or PURIFI 1ET6525SA?

SineWave

Active Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2020
Messages
133
Likes
161
Can't decide which Buckeye amp to get.

I have Martin Logan ReQuest electrostatic speakers:
20‒500 watts per channel
90 dB/2.83 volts/meter
4 Ohms, 1.2 at 20kHz. Compatible with 4, 6, or 8 Ohm rated amplifiers.

I don't play my system loud. Usually around 65 dBs, sometimes about 75. Once in a while about 85.

My Prima Luna Prologue One 35W X 2 ch amp plays more than loud enough for me, but I want to see if I can get a cleaner/ neutral sound instead of the distorted tubey sound sound that I may be hearing withe the Prima Luna. Plus in the summer, the tube amp heats up my room (that has no AC).
And if I do not notice a difference in sound, I will want to use it instead in another system, through my AV receiver's pre-outs. The AV reciever gets real hot with my other set of Martin Logans. I feel one day the MLs may fry it like it did with my previous AV receiver.

Which amp would be a better choice for me?
Hypex NCx500 or PURIFI 1ET6525SA ?

Purifi
Hypex
 
Either Amp will perform fine, even with the highly reactive load of your ML speakers, due to your modest playback levels which will keep current low.

If you plan on pushing higher SPLs, then the NCx500 would be a better choice.

Also pay attention to what power supply the amplifier module is coupled with in the Amp designs that you're interested in!
 
The only answer is to measure it with the mentioned speaker and to check for stability. All else are opinions.
 
The only answer is to measure it with the mentioned speaker and to check for stability. All else are opinions.
With due respect, it is not an opinion when the manufacturer specs say, according to the OP,
4 Ohms, 1.2 at 20kHz. Compatible with 4, 6, or 8 Ohm rated amplifiers.

So, I agree more with @staticV3 , because in this case, it does depend on how loud the OP plays, and that fact that he stated "Prima Luna Prologue One 35W X 2 ch amp plays more than loud enough for me".
 
With due respect, it is not an opinion when the manufacturer specs say, according to the OP,
4 Ohms, 1.2 at 20kHz. Compatible with 4, 6, or 8 Ohm rated amplifiers.
It's well known that some Class-D amps are not stable in these kinds of operations. Therefore, it is indeed best to test this. Most notably the Axign amps do not at all like this kind of configuration. 1.2R at 20 kHz usually means it drops even lower beyond this.
 
Prima Luna state: 0,25% THD @ 1W
That's not far off a guitar amp. Maybe not HiFi by today's standards, but we like what we like....
And 1.2 ohms at 20KHz isn't likely to upset a good class-D - at normal listening levels, that's not much of a signal.
"Instability" can just mean some ringing....
Me? I'd never want electrostatic speakers, whatever the benefits...
 
Last edited:
The speaker spec for 1.2 ohm is at 20kz, so very little current is required to produce sound, if there is any at such high frequency.
Hence why the spec is Compatible with 4, 6, or 8 Ohm rated amplifiers.
Your AVR might get hot for totally different reasons. They all do it in my book.
I would not worry and use it when you do not want to use the tube amp for whatever reason.
Since you are not pushing for high SPL, particularly not in the low frequency, any decent amp will do.
 
Last edited:
I would agree that in general it is best to test, but in this case the OP specifically listed the Hypex NCx500 or PURIFI 1ET6525SA.

In one case of such amp (similar one), Amir commented that "Anyway, the amplifier is extremely robust and doesn't care how difficult the load is."
 
Can't decide which Buckeye amp to get.

I have Martin Logan ReQuest electrostatic speakers:
20‒500 watts per channel
90 dB/2.83 volts/meter
4 Ohms, 1.2 at 20kHz. Compatible with 4, 6, or 8 Ohm rated amplifiers.

I don't play my system loud. Usually around 65 dBs, sometimes about 75. Once in a while about 85.

My Prima Luna Prologue One 35W X 2 ch amp plays more than loud enough for me, but I want to see if I can get a cleaner/ neutral sound instead of the distorted tubey sound sound that I may be hearing withe the Prima Luna. Plus in the summer, the tube amp heats up my room (that has no AC).
And if I do not notice a difference in sound, I will want to use it instead in another system, through my AV receiver's pre-outs. The AV reciever gets real hot with my other set of Martin Logans. I feel one day the MLs may fry it like it did with my previous AV receiver.

Which amp would be a better choice for me?
Hypex NCx500 or PURIFI 1ET6525SA ?

Purifi
Hypex
I have the hypex nc400 on the finals model 15 that even dip to 0.8 ohm, no problems!
 
In one case of such amp (similar one), Amir commented that "Anyway, the amplifier is extremely robust and doesn't care how difficult the load is."
Such statement makes no sense, because it does not exactly define the load complex impedance. Some amplifiers do not like specific complex impedance, as I have shown many times, for example in this post. It is a nature of the feedback system, it is difficult to make it unconditionally stable when it has very low output impedance.
 
because it does not exactly define the load complex impedance.

May not be "exactly, but he make that comment in his review of the NCx500ST. 2 Ohm, 60 deg Capacitive may not be the worst, but 1.2 Ohm at 20 kHz is unlikely to be an issue either because there's not likely going to be much energy up there especially when the OP said his 35 W tube amp played loud enough.

1793133031385.png



Some amplifiers do not like specific complex impedance, as I have shown many times, for example in this post. It is a nature of the feedback system, it is difficult to make it unconditionally stable when it has very low output impedance.

"make no sense", "All else are opinions.".., wow, seems almost a little rude for no reason. I never said those two amps would be "unconditionally stable", that is just your words, not mine. ;) My comments were based on the information given, and know that just because the amps might indeed use a lot of feedback, it would not likely become unstable, based on past measurements on similar Hypex NCx and Purifi amplifiers, the OP stated "35W X 2 ch amp plays more than loud enough for me", and the speaker manufacturer's specifications.

I see no reason to discuss the technical merit of this further with someone who seems so sure about something, seemingly focus on 1.2 ohms, but not so much on the 20 kHz, or the rest of the available information.
 

Attachments

  • 1793132958867.png
    1793132958867.png
    61.8 KB · Views: 22
Last edited:
the tweeter will only take a very very small amount of power, so I'd not be worried about it.
 
For the similar price I'd get the Hypex for the higher power rating. I don't think with your use you'll have any issues with either, tho.
That's what I'm leaning towards now, after reading replies here. Thanks.
 
Back
Top Bottom