While Pauls video is too hand-wavy and mixes up phase and time, I also don't think Amir's video has the proper nuance, as the peer-reviewed papers probably don't tell us the full story. As this thread demonstrates, lots of people have experience with phase differences relating to auditory...
Yes, for a two-way system, I guess perfect would mean (s+w0)/(s+w0) transfer function, and clearly he will not have that. I am just interested in seeing if any change can be noted for the new axis, since this is seemingly a point of contention here.
For completeness, can you also extract the step response for this axis? Not that it looked bad at all actually for the initial axis, but when the claim is 'perfect step response', it would be interesting to see it for the new axis, if it is not too much of hassle, of course.
I am not native English nor American and certainly not a lawyer. But watching his video I was really wondering if the word Arbitration should not have been used in all communication instead of Litigation, if there was never any intend of a lawsuit?
Respect to @amirm for highlighting this issue.
What a sh!t-show. If they are so concerned about the measurements, and Erin offers to pull the video and redo the test, then what is the problem?
I wonder if there any of the YouTube lawyers that sometimes pop up with short takes on cases from...
What a nice measurement setup. It is too bad that so many people insist on trying to understand theory via measurements, instead trying to understand the theory first, and then use measurements to validate and investigate. Modelling first, measurements later. You can clearly see that he finds it...
The article about lumped modelling was primarily to get the BAR models out before another research group, as I expected they would claim novelty with their models. They now have done that, so my article will be involved in a misconduct case. Just a glimpse of what you have to deal with when it...
There also seems to be magnitude differences in the different signals he compares, as they are seemingly not the same duration in time (although the figures are so gritty that it is difficult to really see what is going on). Everything is weird mish mash of half-truths, analogies, and...
Yes, I agree; you cannot just continue down the same road with this amount of negative 'reviews'. I write a lot for audioXpress, and I may contact them regarding this. It is too late now, though, as it is out, but perhaps more articles are planned with him. I don't think my aXp articles are...
It could be, I am not sure, but I get the feeling that he believes what he writes. Granted, it is a video, and not a journal paper, but he uses this example in a recent audioXpress article http://boson.physics.sc.edu/~kunchur//papers/Hearing-and-Audio-Part1--Freq-phase-and-time.pdf, without any...