• WANTED: Happy members who like to discuss audio and other topics related to our interest. Desire to learn and share knowledge of science required. There are many reviews of audio hardware and expert members to help answer your questions. Click here to have your audio equipment measured for free!

Review and Measurements of Holo Audio Cyan DSD DAC

gvl

Major Contributor
Joined
Mar 16, 2018
Messages
3,425
Likes
3,979
Location
SoCal
I have this Cyan DSD and also both Spring 1 and Spring 2 DACs and running at DSD256 they sound about as neutral as the RME ADI-2 running at DSD256, with less characteristic sound than ESS Sabre which always seems to have it's own immediately recognizable characteristic flavor

This community doesn't believe in sound flavors. I thought I did but no longer sure I do, or at least not to the extent I originally thought.
 

Miska

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Audio Company
Joined
Feb 20, 2019
Messages
615
Likes
448
This community doesn't believe in sound flavors. I thought I did but no longer sure I do, or at least not to the extent I originally thought.

I never thought that as thing matter of belief.

My approach for selection has been to first perform sanity check by measurements and then do selection based on listening. Not much different from buying a car or motorcycle. One can check the specs, but when you start driving one you notice how it behaves and no specs can describe that. I don't select a car or bike based on power and torque curves either... Although I usually use software to improve my car too, on my previous car which was Mini I had SuperChips ECU tuning to bring quite a bit of extra power and torque (it improved fuel economy by 0.5 l/100km too). Now I need to look up a good tuning for my current Volvo too. Yeah, both measurable and noticeable difference as well. :)
 

pkane

Master Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Aug 18, 2017
Messages
5,626
Likes
10,202
Location
North-East
I never thought that as thing matter of belief.

It is a matter of belief that all things matter for audio. You spend a lot of time fixing and making things appear better in measurements. I'm all for that. I'm an engineer and I also use your software (mostly for DSP). But, as far as I can see it is only a matter of belief that these things really need to be fixed. A lot more objective evidence is needed to demonstrate that there are audible effects to a -100dB spuria at 1MHz that need to be corrected.

And I've certainly mucked around with reprogramming ECUs on my cars. But I tell you, a carwash and new coat of wax increases torque and HP by at least 10%!
 

gvl

Major Contributor
Joined
Mar 16, 2018
Messages
3,425
Likes
3,979
Location
SoCal
I never thought that as thing matter of belief.

My approach for selection has been to first perform sanity check by measurements and then do selection based on listening. Not much different from buying a car or motorcycle.

Do you have any theories based on the data you collected as to why ESS chips have that characteristic sound that's attributed to them?
 

Miska

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Audio Company
Joined
Feb 20, 2019
Messages
615
Likes
448
You spend a lot of time fixing and making things appear better in measurements.

That is part of the picture. But OTOH, I have spent even more time thinking and listening different filter designs which all provide very good measured performance. Same goes for modulator designs too. Talking about objective numbers, especially on forums like this, is much easier than talking about listening experiences.

And once again, I want to combine this with other important things like digital room correction and headphone processing, etc. It all goes along nicely in the same DSP engine. Once you run one of these, you can as well have the other.

A lot more objective evidence is needed to demonstrate that there are audible effects to a -100dB spuria at 1MHz that need to be corrected.

I've been mostly talking about correlated images around 352.8/384k at level around -60 dB. It is not about just broadly spuria, it is specifically about correlated spuria.

Given that there are audible differences between different scenarios, and certain measured differences as well between the same scenarios. Given all the options I have some picture how different things correlate. There are of course many things one can measure.

As I earlier said, there's some amount of gap between "I can measure things you can't hear" and "you can't measure what I can hear" camps. And I firmly stand right in the middle. Sometimes feel like being ripped apart. :rolleyes:
 

Miska

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Audio Company
Joined
Feb 20, 2019
Messages
615
Likes
448
Do you have any theories based on the data you collected as to why ESS chips have that characteristic sound that's attributed to them?

Not very good one. But it to some extent seems to be about modulator design, but not entirely. To other extent about how the DSP + conversion stage behaves together. It is not all that different from what ESS has said either.
 
  • Like
Reactions: gvl
OP
amirm

amirm

Founder/Admin
Staff Member
CFO (Chief Fun Officer)
Joined
Feb 13, 2016
Messages
44,368
Likes
234,381
Location
Seattle Area
Sometimes feel like being ripped apart. :rolleyes:
Ex CTO of Intel once told me: when you stand in the middle, you get hit by both sides. :) That is what was happening in the last forum I started so decided this one would not be in the middle. That said, I also don't want us to be too orthodox.

BTW, took me a bit to realize you are the author of HQPlayer. Do you mine putting that in your signature for the benefit of others? It is good to know where someone comes from. HQPlayer shows a lot of knowledge on signal processing side and that is a good thing to identify to membership.
 

Miska

Addicted to Fun and Learning
Audio Company
Joined
Feb 20, 2019
Messages
615
Likes
448
BTW, took me a bit to realize you are the author of HQPlayer. Do you mine putting that in your signature for the benefit of others? It is good to know where someone comes from. HQPlayer shows a lot of knowledge on signal processing side and that is a good thing to identify to membership.

Isn't it showing there already? I put it there almost immediately after creating the account! I have no intentions being any kind of under-cover person!

Thanks!
 

vinh

New Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2019
Messages
2
Likes
0
Because you get around some of the limitations of DAC chips and get to choose your own modulator as well. Since in modern DAC chips and also in this case (all are SDM DACs) the sound largely depends, in addition to the conversion stage itself, on the digital delta-sigma modulator.

Sure, you can do it with some DAC chips as well, like the more recent AKM ones that have DSD Direct mode, and with TI/BB chips fed with DSD.

I have this Cyan DSD and also both Spring 1 and Spring 2 DACs and running at DSD256 they sound about as neutral as the RME ADI-2 running at DSD256, with less characteristic sound than ESS Sabre which always seems to have it's own immediately recognizable characteristic flavor (and doesn't support direct DSD). The on-board AKM chip to convert PCM to DSD has surprisingly poor performance though, I would have kind of expected more from AKM.

Given selling price of these, like Holo and Chord, surprisingly they are not really more expensive than comparable chip-based designs either.

Hi,
I am deciding between Cyan DSD and Spring 2 Level 1. Since you having both cyan dsd and spring 2 . Can i have the review comparing between them ?
Beside, The Cyan DSD now has a new design as they has removed the amp socket. I wonder if they improve/fix some of the performance.

Warm regard,
 

mikemaverick

Member
Joined
Feb 24, 2019
Messages
10
Likes
2
Hi,
I am deciding between Cyan DSD and Spring 2 Level 1. Since you having both cyan dsd and spring 2 . Can i have the review comparing between them ?
Beside, The Cyan DSD now has a new design as they has removed the amp socket. I wonder if they improve/fix some of the performance.

Warm regard,
I would suggest Cyan DSD if you only listen to DSD musics since its DSD performance is pretty close to Spring 2. However, if you have more budget I would suggest that you wait for Holo May as it will perform much better than Cyan and Spring.
 

vinh

New Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2019
Messages
2
Likes
0
I would suggest Cyan DSD if you only listen to DSD musics since its DSD performance is pretty close to Spring 2. However, if you have more budget I would suggest that you wait for Holo May as it will perform much better than Cyan and Spring.

I actually listen to PCM most of the time, but PCM come with the amp as well. I only need a DAC. I thought Cyan DSD is closer to Spring 1 but not Spring 2 ?
 

Veri

Master Contributor
Joined
Feb 6, 2018
Messages
9,596
Likes
12,036
I would suggest Cyan DSD if you only listen to DSD musics since its DSD performance is pretty close to Spring 2. However, if you have more budget I would suggest that you wait for Holo May as it will perform much better than Cyan and Spring.
Much better? The manufacturer said it will be a very smalll update for those that want to pay for the 'best' so shouldn't be a big difference
 

donniewn

New Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2020
Messages
2
Likes
1
did you guys listen to this DAC? measuements don't give the whole picture . does it sound good? I want a good native dsd dac
 

Veri

Master Contributor
Joined
Feb 6, 2018
Messages
9,596
Likes
12,036
did you guys listen to this DAC? measuements don't give the whole picture . does it sound good? I want a good native dsd dac
Schiit used to make a Loki DSD-native DAC. It never took off so it was quickly scrapped. If a DSD-based DAC is what you're looking for, this Cyan is what you want. It'll sound good, no measurements to prove otherwise. It is expensive for what it is, though ;)
 

donniewn

New Member
Joined
Nov 11, 2020
Messages
2
Likes
1
I have the Loki , it’s reasonably good , just looking for an improvement. I’m sure the power supply on the Cyan is much better than the USB of the Loki .
 

Veri

Master Contributor
Joined
Feb 6, 2018
Messages
9,596
Likes
12,036
I have the Loki , it’s reasonably good , just looking for an improvement. I’m sure the power supply on the Cyan is much better than the USB of the Loki .
Wow you must be one of the rare owners of the Loki DSD, that's actually really cool. The Cyan sure looks like a solid performer to me. If you can afford it, I wouldn't think twice.
 

pcasr

New Member
Joined
Jan 11, 2021
Messages
1
Likes
0
ESS has a lot of theories why their dac has that characteristic sound that's attributed to them. And most importantly are resarching for them, which is part of science usually.

 

Billy Budapest

Major Contributor
Forum Donor
Joined
Oct 11, 2019
Messages
1,810
Likes
2,674
@amirm

Amir,

Any chance you would be able to review the latest iteration of the Holo Audio May DAC? Would the manufacturer send you a sample to measure? I think it is conceptually one of the most interesting DACs out there and according to some other reviewers, measures very well. I think its noise floor performance was the best Stereophile ever measured a few years ago—22 bits of dynamic range.
 
Top Bottom